Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

reminder on rotational physics

Posts

reminder on rotational physics

#1

reminder on rotational physics

-e-

accidents happen but as my wise physician's words resonate "reduce the risk", it's good to review the forces we use at the lathe:

..................250 rpm---450 rpm-----600 rpm---1,200 rpm--1,800 rpm---3,000 rpm

1/2" dia------.4 mph-----.7 mph------.9 mph-----1.8 mph-----2.7 mph----4.5 mph

06" dia------4.5 mph---8.0 mph----10.7 mph----21.4 mph---32.1 mph----54.0 mph

12" dia------8.9 mph--16.0 mph----21.4 mph----42.8 mph---64.2 mph---108.0 mph

14" dia-----10.4 mph--18.7 mph----25.0 mph----49.9 mph---74.9 mph---125.0 mph

above is a generalized table of the possible force of a lathe-mounted object released as a projectile -- you must also add in the density of the material, the shape of the object at impact and the distance of impact.

consider that the closer the face and chest is to the rotating object, the greater the impact from the kinetic energy. therefore those of us of smaller dimensions will most likely have the delicate face and chest closer and in the direct ballistic trajectory of the projectile.

please review Alan Lacer's article 'Speed Zone' in the American Association of Woodturners journal.

Re: reminder on rotational physics

#2

Dale Jablonski

Re: reminder on rotational physics

Dale Jablonski

This was interesting information. My question and perhaps it was in the AAW article which I have to chase down is ? What is there a preferred or optimum speed for roughing, shaping and finishing cuts based on diameter, density and rpm?

Re: reminder on rotational physics

#3

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: reminder on rotational physics

#4

Dale Nish speeds in graphical form

Doc Green

The suggested speed range is shown in a graph at

http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/lathespeed.html

(Click on the graph to make it bigger.)

Re: reminder on rotational physics

#5

Rob Wallace

PLEASE CORRECT THIS......!!!

Rob Wallace

The 6,000 - 9,000 range is NOT rpm!!!

This number is a constant that must be DIVIDED by the diameter (in inches) of the piece to determine the recommended revolutions per minute at which it can safely be spun.

Do not consider this range of constant values as rotational speed! It merely enables conversion of the relationship between diameter and suggested safe speed. Nothing more.

Rob Wallace

Re: reminder on rotational physics

#6

Re: PLEASE CORRECT THIS......!!!

David Walser

In addition to Rob's important correction, it's also important to note that Dale Nish's formula applies to blanks that are sound, in balance, and securely attached to the lathe. So, the formula doesn't give a safe turning speed for turning a cracked blank, one that's out of round, or one that's held in Cole jaws.

Re: reminder on rotational physics

#7

Dale Jablonski

Re: Dale Nish speeds in graphical form

Dale Jablonski

thanks Doc, only problem is that you can't save as a document and have the graphics come up. Need to save while in Internet Explorer as a webpage.

Re: reminder on rotational physics

#8

Re: reminder on rotational physics

-e-

http://azwoodturners.org/LatheSpeed.pdf

Re: reminder on rotational physics

#9

just copy and paste into Word


Re: reminder on rotational physics

#10

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: reminder on rotational physics

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re:Maybe more important....

Jesper, Denmark

The centrifugal force, which tries to throw things from the piece in th lathe, increases with the SQUARE of the increase in speed.

The hoop stresses increases with the CUBE of the increase in speed.

Re: reminder on rotational physics

#12

Re: reminder on rotational physics

RCH

Diameter is a crucial factor, but there is another factor that seems to be only implicit in this discussion. A blank has not only diameter but also THICKNESS. Those together determine the volume and thus the mass, which in turn determines the energy. Even if you are turning at the recommended speed for a given diameter, the impact energy will be greater as thickness (and thus mass) increases. Two disks 10" in diameter are quite different missiles when they they fly off the lathe if one is 1" thick and the other is 5".

Re: reminder on rotational physics

#13

Here is some balance related information. *LINK*

Keith Newton

Even though this is about cutter heads, the physics would be the same for given diameter and speeds for out of balance forces.


http://www.woodweb.com/knowledge_base/Knife_Grinding_and_Woodworking_Manual_1.html

Re: reminder on rotational physics

#14

Re:Maybe more important....

David Walser

The centrifugal force, which tries to throw things from the piece in th lathe, increases with the SQUARE of the increase in speed.

The hoop stresses increases with the CUBE of the increase in speed.



Isn't that what a roughing gouge is for, to turn SQUARE CUBES into round cylinders?

*ducks*

Re: reminder on rotational physics

#15

It's about Kinetic Energy

charlie belden

It's Kinetic Energy we're deaing with.

Kinetic Energy of mass M (usually in pounds, traveling at velocity V (in ft/sec) is M x V^2

For an object rotating, rather than traveling in a straight line, it's velocity is Angular Velocity

and for KE calculations we want the speed in Ft/Sec.

Given a lathe speed in RPMs (Revolutions Per Minute), we want the speed in revolutions per SECOND.

So if the RPMs are divided by 60 (60 seconds per minute), we get Revolutions Per SECOND.

Given the Diameter of the rotating piece, in inches, the Circumference is Pi x D, which is the

distance a point on its surface will travel for each revolution. But we want the distance that a point

on the surface of the piece is traveling in FEET.

So if we divide its circumference in Inches by 12 (12 inches per foot), we get the distance in FEET.

Now we can calculate the "V" in the KE = M x V^2. The M we can get from a scale.


Notice that if you double the weight you only double the Kinetic Energy. But if you double the speed (rpms) you quadruple the Kinetic Energy.

While we think it's the weight of the piece we should worry about most, it's the RPMs that kick up the danger more - by a factor of two.

Just some info to add to the discussion - along with some specific numbers for comparison.