Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

pot/box

Posts

pot/box

#1

Keith Tompkins

pot/box

Keith Tompkins

Here's a small figured maple form I'm working on...not completed yet, I may burn the ring around the lid and the feet. I'm working towards my own version of what a box should look like....my feeling is that it should look good with or without the lid in place. Comments are welcome..I have my own critique on this one.

Re: pot/box

#2

Rob Wallace

Re: pot/box

Rob Wallace

That sure is a pretty fancy pot box Keith.....a great place to house your stash!

Just don't get caught - Be sure they have a warrant to search your place.... ;)

(Nice form, BTW! I like the lid and the feet!!)

Rob

Re: pot/box

#3

Re: pot/box

Bob Rogne

Great shape and beautiful wood. The detail on the feet is great.

Re: pot/box

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: pot/box

Keith Tompkins

Not THAT kink of pot, Rob!!

Re: pot/box

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: pot/box

Keith Tompkins

Thanks Bob..the feet took much longer than turning the box!

Re: pot/box

#6

Re: pot/box

John Lucas

Keith it has a sort of full belly kind of look. I like it. It should have arms rubbing it's full tummy. :) Love the feet.

Re: pot/box

#7

Don Leydens

Re: pot/box

Don Leydens

I love the feet as well, Keith. What are the dimensions? I'm just wondering how a hand will be able to reach inside. Love the lid as well.

Re: pot/box

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: pot/box

Keith Tompkins

Thanks John, My own critique...I want more mass in the base, it would have given even more of the appearance you see. I like pieces with legs, the entire form can be seen. I did this one on the fly, I usually have a sketch to go by.

Re: pot/box

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: pot/box

Keith Tompkins

Hi Don, It's about 3" across..It might be tough to get a hand into! Thanks, carving the legs was a pain...I don't think you could make any money selling these!

Re: pot/box

#10

Mike Stafford

Re: pot/box

Mike Stafford

An interesting concept Keith. Here is my opinion and well, you know what they say about opinions..... :D

My thoughts are that the overall box is neither a sphere nor an egg. I think it should be one or the other. An egg shape would allow you to redistribute the mass to either the bottom third or the top third of the box. A sphere would be pleasing to the eye.

The lid is not a continuation of the curve of the body; I would have liked to see the curve of the body continued on the lid right after the bead. Lots of box people would agree with you that a box with an inset lid such as this is still a useful container and decorative piece if the lid is lost or damaged whereas box bodies with flanges which are missing their lids are not very pretty. I have a number of those sitting in my shop as a result of lids splitting or otherwise going bad..... :b

Lord knows it is more work than I want to do or have the skills to do but what if the feet were ball and claw or something similar. That would really make it something special. The round knob and bead begs to be balanced by round feet or some other "roundosity" on the bottom. Easier said than done I am sure as I can't carve a toothpick.

All that said I think it is a great little box. I love the concept and the knob is perfect for it. I would add it to my collection in a heartbeat. I look forward to seeing where you take this. I like it!

Re: pot/box

#11

Re: pot/box

John Lucas

Mike this is one time I disagree about the sphere or egg. I think the idea of a potbelly is just that. It needs to look like a overfull belly or pot belly stove and I think he got that. I do agree about the lid. The flow of the line is off just a hair. I'm still not sure about the ball on top. I think it works with the overall concept but not totally convinced it's the best shape for this.

Re: pot/box

#12

Re: pot/box

Don Orr

I like the box very much. The feet really make it "stand" out. The knob and lid flow extremely well down into the body. The only thing that bothers me is the size of the bead. I don't think it needs to be that big. Just my opinion based on extremely limited qualifications for critique. Since this is a study piece, I'm sure you will be experimenting with other designs and features. Looking forward to seeing more in the future. You are definitely on a good track with this.

I like the idea of ball/claw feet, cabriole, trifid, even turned spindle legs. More carving though. Many years ago Mike Schwing did something with raptor talons as feet on one of his pieces. I think he even carved chicken feet as well.

Re: pot/box

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: pot/box

Keith Tompkins

Thanks Mike, I appreciate you input. Here is my take, or critique of my own work...The line A shows how the curve flattened out...making it difficult for the curve to flow from the base through the lid. Solution: Don't turn the box and the lid at different times...insert the lid, leaving enough wood on both to work with the curves. Line B shows the emphasis point..almost centered, and creates little to no visual interest. The curved line on the left shows the air space where the line should have been...a ring was turned around the base, this became the legs, once the waste was carved away...THIS RING determined the overall shape...once turned. all else had to work within its dimensions. Good reason to draw out the piece first!

This was a seat-of-the -pants turning...I almost always have a plan before I turn anything..the results here are obvious. A failure? Heck no...pieces like this, if one is honest with their results, are a great way to examine and critique one's own work, understand what works, what doesn't work.. and how the NEXT piece can be improved. Notice I stretched the image, just to see how it would appear.

Carved feet? I've carved my share of ball and claw feet, and yes, it would be very cool, but lots of time! Thanks Mike!

Re: pot/box

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: pot/box

Keith Tompkins

Thanks Don, Yes the ring looks overpowering in the image, but I think it's the camera angle..in real life, it doesn't look so big...I agree, more carving on the legs...

Re: pot/box

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: pot/box

Keith Tompkins

I tend to agree with you, John, the sphere does nothing at all for me. Egg? Maybe.

Re: pot/box

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: pot/box

Keith Tompkins

Here's an even more pronounced form that I "drew" legs on. I like the shape better, and it allows for a larger lid. Better flow in this form...What do you think??

Re: pot/box

#17

Mike Stafford

Re: pot/box

Mike Stafford

Your flattened out version is much better in my opinion. I like the continuation of the curve of the lid much better.

The squatter version also seems to be more proportional between the various elements.

You know more about design and turning than I ever will and just throwing my two cents in and getting feedback from you and John helps me get better.

Re: pot/box

#18

Re: pot/box

RCH

Definitely more interesting shape, and the much smaller bead also helps.

Re: pot/box

#19

Leo Cuellar

Love the shape!

Leo Cuellar

That is very nice piece, Keith, great job all the way around!

Re: pot/box

#20

Yes, Yes, Yes!!!


Re: pot/box

#21

Re: pot/box

Lan Brady

Keith,

Very nice box. I do like this more squat version.

Although the carved feet would be very time consuming. What if you just made 2 v cuts, creating 3 toes on each foot? I think even Chippendale did that later on for cost savings.

Thanks for this post, I have learned from it.

Lan

Re: pot/box

#22

Re: pot/box

John Lucas

Keith That shape is interesting but appears more like a sugar bowl. Not bad if that's what you want but i like the other one better. It sort of appears animated like a characature or something.

Re: pot/box

#23

Don Leydens

Re: pot/box

Don Leydens

I agree with you about the shape, John. Besides, what would Mike know about "pot bellies" ?

Oh man, I'm going to hell for that one. :D