Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Question for you experts on short main bevel

Posts

Question for you experts on short main bevel

#1

Question for you experts on short main bevel

John Lucas

I've noticed that several top turners are now using a very short main bevel and then have a secondary bevel right below. I've heard that it reduces friction so you can "feel" the cut better. I've been playing with it for about a year or so now. It does seem to do that. I also find that it doesn't leave the little bruised lines that you often can get on the inside of a bowl. Anyone else want to chime in on why people are doing this grind.

I was talking to a master machinist the other day. I'm trying to learn and I'm on the low end of beginner. Anyway he told me that if you want a really clean cut on a tool come down about 1/16" and grind away the lower part of the cutting edge. This gives the metal a place to expand into after the cut. Well this is exactly what Mike Mahoney's tools look like and what I've been trying to duplicate. I'm wondering if this actually works in wood. You also see a chip breaker groove cut just behind the cutting edge on the top of carbide tools. This is supposed to help clear the cut and leave a cleaner surface.

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

Mike Stafford

Jimmy Clewes is proponent of this and I have watched him use it up close and personal. He is able to do it with ease but when I tried it I had a hard time finding the shorter bevel. His shorter bevel is only 1/8" or less. I do agree that shortening the bevel and having a secondary bevel will reduce the bruise marks from the heel as you go around the inside of the bowl.

I do use a shorter bevel on several of my gouges particularly those I use for hollowing end grain but shorter is a relative term for me as my main bevel is still 1/4"-5/16".

Jimmy Clewes I ain't....... :( He has skills I doubt I will ever possess.

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#3

I'm not sure but it sounds like the Michelson

Mike Foster

grind that I use. I learned this from Johannes a year ago or so, and now several of my gouges have his grind. Jannes likes it for the very reason you stated. Often the hollow grind off the wheel will leave the convex corner a bit sharp, and if you ride the bevel (I don't think you would John) as beginners are instructed, that corner can bruise the wood behind the cut. Jannes also finds the gouge will sneak into tighter spots than an Irish or Elsworth grind. Johannes' grind is a mini bevel (about 1-2mm) with the metal behind that ground away in a soft curve. I really like the grind, but you need to have a good feel on how to present the edge, as you have far less bevel to ride. It also is a freehand grind (although Johannes now has a jig for this that I haven't seen or tried) and you have to be comfortable with your skills at the grinding wheel (or belt sander as I use).


Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#4

Re: I'm not sure but it sounds like the Michelson

John Lucas

I've been playing with Johannes's grind. I haven't mastered sharpening or using it yet so I haven't been able to understand the advantage. More experimentation is in need on my part.

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

Keith Tompkins

Hey John, I've got another new tool that you should try out...and, it's got a short bevel...I may have to send you one!! :D does it work? yep.

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#6

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

phillip medghalchi

Keith can I get in line next after John to get your tool to try? ;)

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#7

Re: I'm not sure but it sounds like the Michelson

Bob Rogne

I have been taking off the bottom of the grind after sharping because when i am

doing taking finish cuts on green natural edge bowls i found there was a rub line that would not sand away. Rounding the heel makes a world of difference. It took me a few months to figure out what the problem was. I freehand taking the heel off.

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#8

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

robo hippy

A few things here. First, I don't think the proper term should be 'secondary bevel' but 'relieved bevel. It is not used at any time during the cutting process.

The idea behind it is two part. First, the closer the cutting edge is to the bevel that you are using go guide the tool, the easier the cut is to control. This is why we never get those concentric rings on the outside of the bowl, or on any convex (bends outwards) shape. Any bevel angle will work, and just about any tool as you will be rubbing very close to the cutting edge. With the concave shape, you will have a longer space between the heel of the bevel and the cutting edge. If this edge is left sharp/square, and you are rubbing it, it will leave bruise marks, and it actually pushes the cutting edge into the cut making it harder to control. By grinding half or more of the bevel away, you shorten the lever/distance between the bevel you rub and the cutting edge, making the cut easier to control.

I have seen some people grind a very neat secondary bevel on their tools. I just roll the heal around a bit and round it off. It doesn't have to be neat.

If you have ever seen Eli Avesera, he uses a convex style grind on his skew. The claim is that it is much more user friendly. I have tried it, and though I don't really know how to use a skew, I have found it easier to cut with, especially if I am doing convex shapes. Maybe a bit more difficult to cut a straight profile, but again, I don't really know how to use a skew.

I did see Christian Burshard years before I heard of Johannes Michaleson, and he was using a gouge with no bevel for some very dainty cuts.

robo hippy

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

Keith Tompkins

Hi Reed, My v-skew has a convex grind as well...it works.

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

Keith Tompkins

Sure...if you can pry it away from him :D

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#11

I've been grinding away the heel ........

JamieDonaldson

...of the bevel on most of my primary gouges for many years. It eliminates the compression rings as well as reducing the friction of metal dragging on the wood. J.F. Escoulen makes a micro bevel with a diamond hone on the very edge of his spindle gouges, and they slice through wood as though it was butter, at least when he is holding the tool! :D

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#12

Re: I've been grinding away the heel ........

phillip medghalchi

Can you experts kindly post a picture of what you guys talking about for us less experts? I have heck of a hard time to understand or vision this lingoes you folks used in order to get the idea. Help would be greatly appreciated.

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#13

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

Dale Miner

I will put a double or sometimes a triple bevel on my bowl gouge that is used for the final cut on the inside of a bowl.

Using a Varigrind or other type jig, after the gouge is sharpened as normal, just extend the gouge another 1/4" by eye, and lightly grind a second bevel, then if needed, another 1/4" by eye and very lightly grind a third bevel. I use a primary bevel of about 1/8" or so on a 5/8" gouge and a little less on a 1/2" gouge (North American sizes).

The advantage is as you noted, much less bruising to the wood. Another advantage that results from not using a long bevel: When the gouge is levered against the heel of the hollow ground bevel to cut the concave curve on the inside of the bowl, the actual edge of the gouge lifts off the wood briefly, and tearout occurs until the cut establishes itself again under the edge. Once this occurs, the cut will match the hollow grind of the bevel until the levering action takes place again. A series of small circular ridges will result, spaced apart approximately the width of the bevel. Also, when the actual cutting edge is being lifted, the heel is bruising the wood in the same spot at the undercut occurred in the bottom of the previous groove. This increases the need for sanding to first remove the high spot of the circular rigdes, and then additional sanding to remove the torn/bruised wood. If it were possible, a convex grind that perfectly matched the desired curve of the inside of the bowl would allow for a floating bevel with no ridges or bruising and minimal tearout. The double or triple bevel is a cheap approximation towards that match with a pretty good payback for as little effort as it takes. I typically only grind a triple bevel on the gouge for smaller bowls with smaller concave radii.

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#14

Re: ... A "relieved" bevel on a gouge *LINK*

Doc Green

Phillip, the second photo in the article link below shows a spindle gouge where part of the bevel has been ground away. The part of the bevel that is effective is the part near the cutting edge.

http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/gouges7.html

Click on the photo for a larger view. Click anywhere outside the photo to return to the text.

~Doc


Link to Photo

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#15

Bill Blasic

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

Bill Blasic

JoHannes' new jig does a great job of duplicating his grind. It took just minutes to set up and use.

Bill

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#16

micro bevel photos

John Lucas

Here is a photo of my two most used tools. The top is a Henry taylor U shaped bowl gouge that I ground to stewart Batty's grind. I grind it free hand on the Oneway tool rest, then simply freehand the second and 3rd bevels.

The bottom is a Thompson V gouge that I grind on the Wolverine jig. I grind the main bevel and then move the tool forward in the slot to where the V joins the arm and grind the second bevel. Then I pull the tool out of the Wolverine jig and freehand grind the sharp edge off the bottom bevel.

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

#17

Re: Question for you experts on short main bevel

bowlman

I'll be your field tester. old friend!