Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Tape doesn't work. (A theory)

Posts

Tape doesn't work. (A theory)

#1

Tape doesn't work.  (A theory)

Doc Green

First of all, I'm saddened to hear of the accident that Lynn experienced, and I wish her a speedy and full recovery. There but for the grace of God go a lot of us.

I've often wondered if applying tape or a plastic film to a turning does any good. I think it doesn't, other than to partially contain the explosion after the turning comes apart.

The reason is that the tape or film is more elastic (stretchy) than the wood. Like a rubber band, tape has to be stretched before it applies any significant restraining force. By the time the tape is stretched enough to exert a useful force, the wood will already have come apart.

Experience is not a good indicator that the tape really does anything. You and I may have applied tape to 99 turnings over the years and never had a taped turning come apart. But, we don't know for certain that any of the turnings would have come apart even if the tape had not been applied, so the absence of explosions cannot be taken as firm evidence that the tape prevented the explosions.

My concern is that a belief that the tape really does something may lull us into a false sense of security. We may be led to putting tape on a questionable piece of wood and then going ahead without realizing that the tape may as well not be there.

There may not be a definitive answer to the question. Duct tape I know is rather stretchy. On the other hand, strapping tape with its reinforcing fiberglass is much less so. The only thing we can say for certain is that the tape won't hurt, and it will contain the explosion to some extent if the piece does come apart.

Just my thoughts. I would like to hear yours. ~Doc

Re: Tape doesn't work. (A theory)

#2

Re: Tape doesn't work.  (A theory)

Barry L Elder

I do not, as a rule, use tape to hold together a wannabe turning. Ever since I was a beginner I have had numerous pieces of wood populate my shop after bouncing off my hands, arms, chest, and faceshield and because of this have developed the habit of stopping the lathe every few minutes to examine the piece for its' beauty and for cracks and other danger points. Some of my friends use tape at times and admit they feel the false sense of security that Doc speaks of. I have been very fortunate in recovering from my injuries, which have not been serious, and I pray that all of you will recover as well. God is great!

Re: Tape doesn't work. (A theory)

#3

Re: Tape doesn't work.  (A theory)

John Lucas

Doc I probably should not have recommended tape at all. The only reason I did is because it seems people will not give up on a piece even if it's cracked. They'll CA cracks or epoxy them and keep on going. CA is brittle and the piece can still fly apart, especially if you catch.

I have used strapping tape a lot to hold inside out turnings together for practice pieces to check how my idea will work. These are small spindle turnings, the biggest being about 5" square. It works great for that. I have also in the past used it to hold together cracked bowls or hollow vessels with voids. And I will agree with you it's probably a false sense of security. I did get buy with it. Will I get lucky next time, maybe not.

I think what we are seeing here is a very necessary trend toward wearing safety gear of some kind. I am particularly bad about not wearing a face shield. Just never liked them and 90 percent of my turnings are small. However I did purchase one the other day and I'm trying to get used to wearing it. I mean I had the false assumption that I can't get any uglier so why worry. But ugly and losing your sight or your life are two different things.

Re: Tape doesn't work. (A theory)

#4

Re: Tape doesn't work.  (A theory)

Dale Miner

Doc,

I don't think it is a 'Yes' or 'No' regarding does tape work. Duct tape is as you mention, somewhat elastic and has no place on a questionable piece. Masking tape even more so. Filament strapping tape is almost non elastic, and with a SUFFICIENT number of wraps, would provide some protection.

I don't think taping a piece with a known crack with any type of tape is wise. If the piece has a crack, the crack can only become larger during turning, increasing the likelyhood of an accident. If a person pushes on with a cracked piece, minimum rpm's are a must, but tossing it out would be better.

A burl or other mishapen piece that will end up with voids or openings may benefit from the filament tape. However, the piece must be evalualted for centrifugul forces before turning thru the connecting fibers. Filament tape used to add support to a peninsula or finger of the piece to help resist deflection while hollowing is not nearly as prone for catashtrophe as the use of tape to hold large cracked sections together. Bark included crotch sections should be treated the same as a cracked piece.

The saying "Speed Kills" also applies to rpm's.