Tape doesn't work. (A theory)
Doc Green
First of all, I'm saddened to hear of the accident that Lynn experienced, and I wish her a speedy and full recovery. There but for the grace of God go a lot of us.
I've often wondered if applying tape or a plastic film to a turning does any good. I think it doesn't, other than to partially contain the explosion after the turning comes apart.
The reason is that the tape or film is more elastic (stretchy) than the wood. Like a rubber band, tape has to be stretched before it applies any significant restraining force. By the time the tape is stretched enough to exert a useful force, the wood will already have come apart.
Experience is not a good indicator that the tape really does anything. You and I may have applied tape to 99 turnings over the years and never had a taped turning come apart. But, we don't know for certain that any of the turnings would have come apart even if the tape had not been applied, so the absence of explosions cannot be taken as firm evidence that the tape prevented the explosions.
My concern is that a belief that the tape really does something may lull us into a false sense of security. We may be led to putting tape on a questionable piece of wood and then going ahead without realizing that the tape may as well not be there.
There may not be a definitive answer to the question. Duct tape I know is rather stretchy. On the other hand, strapping tape with its reinforcing fiberglass is much less so. The only thing we can say for certain is that the tape won't hurt, and it will contain the explosion to some extent if the piece does come apart.
Just my thoughts. I would like to hear yours. ~Doc



