Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

Posts

Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#1

Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

Greg Haugen

I've used the original anchorseal for years to seal roughed out / cored bowls before placing them in the kiln. It was a good product. Now UC Coatings has come out with Anchorseal 2, a more "Eco" version of it. I've heard some mixed reviews of the newer product. I bought a gallon of it a couple of months back to try it out. I must say, the original was a good product, but I like the newer version better. It has a higher viscosity, the original was a little too thin at times. Coverage is much more consistent and thorough.

I'm curious as to what your experiences have been with the new product compared to the original?

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#2

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

slharder

Most reviews from woodturners in the midwest have favored the original over V2.

Most common complaint was more cracking and checking of completely covered bowls after drying for months, needing to do 2 coats with V2.

I had purchased a 5gal of V2 when it first came out. Then I was seeing a lot of unfavorable comments. I contacted UCCoatings, just asking for their comments. They immediately offered to send 5gal of V1 for free and did not want me to return V2. My takeaway was they had heard from others prior to my contacting them.

I buy and use V1.

Your mileage may vary.

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#3

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

Greg Haugen

I've heard that too. I've heard the customer service call V1 as "The Woodturners Formula". The only thing that I've had crack or check was a wind shake in a piece that I didn't see before hand, and that wouldn't have matter which version was used. Lately, I've been processing wood for spindle projects and peppermills while using V2 with, knock on wood, not a single check. The way I process wood for spindles is to turn most everything into cylinders, seal the ends, and let it sit for a couple of months before going to the kiln. Lately, it's been box elder and ash.

One issue I do see though is that all of the stores are carrying V2. The only way to get V1 is to order direct, which is also the most economical way but at times not the easiest.

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#4

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

Bernie Weishapl

I have had just the opposite experience. Out here in the midwest where the humidity is very low (10 to 12 percent most of the time) I have found that the original works better for me at least. I sealed some walnut bowl blanks, some with AS2 and some with original. None with the original AS cracked but the AS2 blanks all had some cracks. So I buy all original.

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#5

Let me hear more- please

John Lucas

I am planning on buying another 5 gallons. I've been doing a lot of playing with saving wood in the last 7 years but haven't done a whole lot with Anchorseal mostly because I only have the V1. I'd like to know more about how everyone uses it, what they like and don't like, and do they prefer a different product.

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#6

Phil Stivers

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

Phil Stivers

Contact information to order direct, please???

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#8

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

Barry Irby

Google UC Coatings Nice people

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#9

Re: Let me hear more- please

Greg Haugen

John,

In my opinion, other than finish turning while green or freezing (which only preserves the wood), there is no better product for storing wood. But as you know, everyone has their own way-the "only way" to do it. I've had success with both versions, but there are many who only like the original. For spindle projects, I'll turn the green wood into cylinders, seal the ends and store. I made some sticker sticks out of wood lath and dowels to act as racks so I can stack cylinders but still assure they're drying evenly. If I'm in a hurry, I'll put them in a freezer kiln for 1 month per inch of diameter. I'll dry up to 3 1/2" diameter with this method. For bowls, the status quo. Roughed out, sealed rim, foot, and end grain. Either stored or placed in a kiln afterwards.

Paint, canning wax, DNA are all valid options. For me and my climate, this works the best with less fuss and I can deal with large quantities.

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#10

Re: Let me hear more- please

Dale Bright

I am a member of 2 clubs in the Northern Virginia / Washington, D.C. area and we bulk buy Anchorseal in 55 gallon drums. We only buy the Classic formula. The newer formula is simply not as good as the classic.

Dale

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#11

Re: Let me hear more- please

John Lucas

By not as good, what do you mean. Doesn't spread as easily or too easy, doesn't coat as thick or thicker. Curious minds want to know.

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#12

Re: Let me hear more- please

Dale Bright

John, it just does not prevent checking and cracking in drying wood as good as the classic formula. I have about a 5% loss, or less, using the classic on my rough outs. When I tried the new formula, I was somewhere around 20% lost to checking while drying. I normally coat the entire piece with Ancorseal and put them on a shelf for a few months. On some woods that are pretty stable, I only coat the endgrain.

I have spoken with several turners that had similar results.

Dale

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#13

Bill Blasic

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

Bill Blasic

My club has gone through two 55 gallon drums of the new formula and I myself have seen no difference between the new and old as far as the pieces cracking. One club member out of 45 said he had wood crack using the new vs the old. Again I have not found that to be the case with my use.

Bill

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

#14

Re: Anchorseal Vs. Anchorseal 2

Barry L Elder

I purchased 5 gals direct from UCC back when there was only the original. The directions suggested 2 coats and that is what I have always done through the re-order a few years ago. I have no complaints so I see no reason to change the type I use. Quite happy with the product as is.