Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

Posts

A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

#1

A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

Roger Chandler

I started turning bowls in the late fall of 2008.....only occasionally. Up to that time I had turned a few table legs and some small spindle work........that was why I got my first lathe. This is the 3rd bowl I ever turned....did not finish it back then...........I found out with the abundance of catches and what not, that I did not have the proper tools..........at that time, not even a chuck, or a bowl gouge..........I left it thick because it had a lot of windshake cracks in it, and I was just very frustrated back then.........it has been sitting in my shop all this time.........many times I almost threw it in the wood stove, but just could not bring myself to do it.....thinking .........I might try to fix this someday, even though it is really cracked a lot.

Yesterday I saw it again........last night in my semi-sleep state, it came to my head.......beckoning me to do something with it. The form was pretty creative for a novice turner of bowls, who had no tools except spindle gouge and skew at the time, and well, I found out pretty quickly that I needed different tools to make this form work.

I have since acquired numerous tools for my turning arsenal, and some chucks [and a much better lathe for that matter] The shape required an oland style tool, a gooseneck scraper, and some work with a bowl gouge to get it pretty uniform at 1/4 inch thick.

I have reached my limit with this......even though the finish is not perfect by any means. The many cracks from being a severely windshaken tree, makes me not want to do anything else with it to try to get it better.....it can only go so far in that direction.

It has been one of my nemesis' and even though I was a novice at bowl forms, it still haunted me every time I went to the shop! Today, I returned to the battle, and I feel like I won the victory with this one....

This form is 7.5 inches wide and 3.75 tall, and the wood is black walnut. Comments welcome!


Re: A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

#2

Betty Scarpino

Re: A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

Betty Scarpino

Well no wonder it was a struggle. That shape is very challenging to turn. Congratulations on success!

Re: A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

#3

Ellis Walentine

Re: A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

Ellis Walentine

Hi Roger,

Thanks for posting the back story of this bowl. I like the way you resolved the curves, and the form seems nicely balanced to me. The finish, as you admitted, could use some further light sanding and polishing to even out the sheen, but you can still do that if it amuses you.

What do you think would happen if you were to try to duplicate (or extrapolate from) that form today, with your current arsenal of tools and fixtures? I for one would like to see how you might make out with a nice solid piece of wood.

I'm glad you got that nagging reminder taken care of. You did it very well.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

#4

Re: A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

Roger Chandler

Thanks Ellis..........

Putting any more effort into finishing this particular piece is an exercise in futility in my opinion. That wood has so much windshake that it could almost fall apart if it were not for all the CA glue I put in the cracks.

I am done with this one.........but I do feel a little bit of vindication that I did not let it remain in the thick, rough state it sat in for over 3 years in my shop.

I might take your suggestion, and find a better piece of wood and revisit this form, and see where that might take me......thanks again for the encouragement!

Re: A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

#5

Re: A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

Roger Chandler

Thanks Betty........I appreciate you taking the time to look and comment.

Re: A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

#6

Re: A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

phillip medghalchi

Roger, if you said that you were new and didn't have all the fancy tools then you should be happy that you turned a very nice and curved bowl and you should be proud of it. I know very many turners that have thousands of dollars tight up in tools, but don't have any concept of design. I think walnut is a challenging wood since about a week or two ago I posted a form that I had trouble with it. So, we learn a lot form these challenging woods early on.

Ellis said you can refinish the piece and i wonder how you can do that if you already turned the chucking foot away, or do you have to do it all by hand?

Re: A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

#7

Leo Cuellar

Re: A new battle with an old Nemesis.........

Leo Cuellar

Thank you for sharing this, Roger. It does have a nice form, and a good story to go with it. Keep at it! :)