Re: Nice video, but maybe....
Dale Miner
Hi John.
I wasn't finding fault with the tool. I actually have a Hunter tool, and although not the Osprey, to me the tools with the canelure or chip breaker groove offers more versatility than the straight scraper type. I have one of the flat top scraper types also. I think the carbides have their place, and do use them for some tasks.
I've seen you demo at OVWG and use a skew with proficiency during that demo. With a little practice, no doubt a pen could be turned with a sharpened screwdriver, or a finial with a hatchet (been there, done that). Even though it is possible to use a wide variety or tools to do the same task, some tasks are better performed with certain tools. I think the skew is suited for pens, moreso that the Osprey. Especially if the turner wanted to put small beads or other fine details on the barrel.
It is very likely that most beginners get exposed to woodturning from turning pens. I've seen pen sessions at a local retail outlet where people use everything from 2" roughing gouges through EZ Roughers to beading tools on down to detail gouges. I'm not sure that serious pen turners fall into the catagory of beginner though. Most of the folk I know that have been turning pens for a while use a skew or spindle gouge, unless doing acrylics.
Floating the bevel concept is a tough one for beginners to pick up and especially frustrating when not followed with a skew. Using a Osprey scraper fashion would take the need for that concept out of the picture, but would add a lot of sandpaper time to the equation. Tool control for any tool should be done with the large muscle groups when doing long curves, whether it is a skew or an Osprey. That is another concept that is tough to pick up. The problem for me at least, is that the carbide tools are touted as being easy for beginners to use. While that is true, getting the concept of bevel floating and tool control become less important and often those concepts never do become employed. I think learning to use a spindle gouge for spindle work is the best avenue to learn those concepts. Once the spindle gouge is able to be used with proficiency, learning the skew is worth pursuing.
So, you think I know what I'm doing eh? What do ya know, got at least one person hoodwinked.
We can disagree, no problem. Tell you what, next time we meet, I'll buy you a carbonated beverage of your choice whether it is a diet cola or a barley soda.