Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Another Hunter Osprey challenge

Posts

Another Hunter Osprey challenge

#1

Steven Antonucci

Another Hunter Osprey challenge

steven antonucci

Based upon the recent interest in the Hunter Osprey, I spent some time with mine yesterday to see what I could do with it. Purely academic exercise.

Picture #1 shows the 4 tools that may have been used to turn this finial

All 4 of them have been used at least once, but it is your job to figure out which tool make which cuts:


Left to right:

Thompson detail gouge

Hunter Osprey

Thompson 3/4" skew

Sorby 1/4" skew

The finial (not my best, but it was made by a committee of tools, so indulge me)


Since this was a Hunter Osprey capabilities test, your starting point should be to assume that it was all cut by the Osprey, then figure out which elements were not cut by the Osprey. I will guess that the entire thing is about 220 grit sanding finish, and I assure you that all of the tools were used at least once.

If you offer up a reason, please suggest why you think so.

Good luck and have fun

Steve

Re: Another Hunter Osprey challenge

#2

Re: Another Hunter Osprey challenge

John Lucas

The 3 small beads and the deep V cut near the bottom bead probably would not be cut by the Osprey. The rest of the cuts I could do with the mini Osprey and maybe even the big one.

Re: Another Hunter Osprey challenge

#3

Steven Antonucci

Partially correct (mostly not though  )


Re: Another Hunter Osprey challenge

#4

My Guess

charlie belden

I was shown what is now the Osprey at the WC luncheon held at the SJ Symposium but didn't get a chance to use it so I can't comment on its performance and have to guess at what it can do in spindle work. I have and have played with the Thompson Detail Gouge, 1/2" skew and 3/4" skew and have a pretty good idea of what they can do.

Based on my experience with the other tools used, I think the long sweeping curves were done with the Osprey. Not having used it, I don't know if it will cut "uphill" or how tight a space it will work in.

Here's my guess as to What Turned What


Re: Another Hunter Osprey challenge

#5

Steven Antonucci

A little worse than john's 


Re: Another Hunter Osprey challenge

#6

Steven Antonucci

The answers

steven antonucci


While not easy, the answer is sort of surprising. I've put 4 arrows in the diagram as references.

The first arrow is everything up to the top of the first bead on the left, including the left side of the bead. All done with a Hunter Osprey, including the lef side of the bead. You have to be a contortionist and a little crazy, but it can be done.

The second arrow is for the right side of the bead, which didn't have enough room to use the Hunter in that steep V cut. I used the detail gouge, then the larger skew, but the bottom of the V wasn't well defined until I switched to the small skew. The thicker skew was too thick to get in at that point, but the little one gave a sharp point in the V cut.

The large arrow denotes everything between the first V cut up to the small bead at the end below the ball. Everything, including the bead and the V cut, was cut with an Osprey. Why? Because I wanted to see if it worked like a gouge. There was some odd positioning, but you can get there if you ride the bevel. No sane person would do this, but you can make a 1/8" bead (with almost perpendicular sides... almost) and a reasonable shallow V cut.

The last elements were turned with the detail gouge. I probably could have done the right side of the ball, but the motion is so extreme and unnatural, that it is very difficult to do it. Just because you can doesn't mean you should.

What did I learn? Well, for one, almost any sharp edge can be presented against a spinning piece of wood to cut it. However, depending upon where that edge is, it may lead to some ridiculous contortions to make those cuts.

I'll post a picture of the bowl I turned and then subsequently lost...

Steve

Re: Another Hunter Osprey challenge

#7

Cool! Turning tools that apply color 


Re: Another Hunter Osprey challenge

#8

Steven Antonucci

Assume it was Ted Turner that appied color? 


Re: Another Hunter Osprey challenge

#9

Steven Antonucci

And the bowl that got away...

steven antonucci

I knew that I had gotten awfully close to "zero thickness" in a couple of spots, but it wasn't until I turned the bottom until I realized how close. If you look in the center of the bowl, you will see a small mark where I actually tore the hole in the bottom trying to pare the last little nub down.


I could not get the Osprey down the side wall of the bowl for the life of me, but I did cut the transition to the center with it. Tis a very odd bird... I managed to cut the bottom unintentionally to beween .0037 and .0055 without really knowing it. I think that it was an ugly bowl anyhow, and it would have likely cracked the first time someone put it down hard, but that thickness with very little vibration? Not sure what to think of it...

Some odd positions again, but if you put a sharp edge to wood the right way, you can cut it...

steve