Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

Posts

Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#1

Aage Rendalen

Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

Aage Rendalen

I feel safe standing at the end of the ways turning, with the headstock on my PM3520B pulled all the way back. It's comfortable and you're out of harm's way when you begin hollowing the inside of a bowl--so why use a face shield?

Now I know the answer. As I pulled out my gouge I was careless and the tip hit the spinning rim of the bowl and the gouge kicked back violently and hit my face shield with a frightful bang. I don't see how I could have avoided the emergency room if I hadn't had my face shield on. I may have to replace my face shield, but that's $14 dollars. Cheaper than my deductible, for sure, and much less painful.

You think you know where the danger might come from and then you get gobsmacked from something you didn't even think about.

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#2

Don Leydens

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

Don Leydens

Glad you're OK, Aage. Close call for sure.

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#3

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

Hal Taylor

You never know till it happens. Thanks for sharing.

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#4

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

Bill Howatt

Glad you are survived intact.

Your post brings to mind something similar to the common refrain about those who don't use safety equipment such as TS blade guards or faceshields. The thought that the procedure is inherently quite safe and if there is some degree of danger my brain and alertness will keep me out of trouble.

Problem is we aren't always alert and brains doze off from time-to-time regardless of how great we think ours is. In most cases nobody sets out to do something they consider unsafe although they may not have good judgement as to what safe/unsafe is. It is the things that "just happen" that often gets us. In the TS world, it is the "I've reached over the blade 10,000 times before but today I hit it with my hand". Having done something unsafe 10,000 times without incident does not make safe on the 10,001 time.

Keep that faceshield on!

Bill

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#5

Alan Zenreich

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

Alan Zenreich

I'm so glad you are ok. Many of us consider a faceshield to be the most basic form of protection.

It may not protect you from catastrophic collisions, but it can make something like this into a non-event.

Yes, one needs to be attentive. Yes one needs to stand out of the line of fire.

Yet... sh*t still happens.

Thanks for sharing.

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#6

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

robo hippy

I have a friend who had some thing similar happen. He was pulling a small scraper out, his attention drifted, and it caught the rim of the bowl. It sent under the end of the face mask, and left a small horse shoe mark on his lip.

Turn it off, or pull it all the way out before turning away with the tool.

robo hippy

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#7

Rob Wallace

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

Rob Wallace

Aage:

Could you relate to us whether you would have been similarly protected by wearing just safety glasses or goggles instead of a full-face shield? I argue that while goggles might protect the eyes from flying debris and some dust, real protection begins with a full face shield, and further to that theme, a face shield that also provides protection to the lower face and jaw with some form of structural support there (i.e. not just a piece of acrylic plastic hanging from a headband). I have heard the argument from some turners that once the "dangerous" parts of roughing a blank are done, and when you are working out of the "danger zone" as you were off the end of the lathe, that you can switch to using just goggles to do the 'finesse' procedures of refining the shape, etc. This concept is really a false sense of safety that should be discouraged from even being considered as adequate. Your close call certainly argues for full face and head protection regardless of what is spinning on the lathe!

Your comments about a face shield being less costly than the deductible of one's medical coverage are well taken, but the real cost to unprotected turning without proper PPE that involves a similar incident goes far beyond insurance deductible amounts relative to face shield costs..... No amount of insurance deductible costs are even in the same ballpark as the non-monetary, life-long cost of disfigurement, permanent damage to muscles and nerves, or loss of sight, etc. by being hit with a turning tool or being clocked in the face or head with a shattering blank.

Thank you for posting this incident to inform us of another real-life calamity that was averted by personal protection equipment. I am very happy you are uninjured; I hope you will continue to rely on full-face protection while you turn!!!

Rob Wallace

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#8

Aage Rendalen

Safety glasses would not have covered me

Aage Rendalen

Good point about safety glasses. Judging from the mark in the face shield, the gouge would have slammed into my mid-face, around the mouth-nose area. And yes, disfigurement and nerve damage hurts even more than deductibles.

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#9

Re: just the other day..

Wayne Kuhn

..I was roughing the outside of a bowl. The little bits in my face were irritating, put my face shield on an continued. Thirty second later BAMM!! a large chunk of bark came off and slammed my face shield. It will go on every time from here on out.

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#10

Harry Robinette

Re: just the other day..

Harry Robinette

Face shield: the most important turning tool

Very glad you OK

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

Keith Tompkins

Aage, glad you are OK! The faceshield saved you from a disaster. BUT...I've enclosed a pic of one of my rectangular "winged bowl" pieces spinning at 2,000 rpm. If this thing comes off the lathe, chances are it could kill me. Do you think I trust a faceshield in this situation? I've begun wearing a hockey mask with a metal guard that locks in place. I wear my eye protection underneath. I've demonstrated this type of turning in several states, and I give a safety lecture to go along with the demo. With this type of turning, there is no room for error....a slip with the gouge will send it flying violently across the room or worse. Fingers carelessly placed on the toolrest will be mangled. 100% attention! (I ride a motorcycle as well, and the advise is the same: 100% attention...you just don't get to make mistakes) Remember, your face shield is the LAST resort, after everything else has gone wrong..not the first!

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#12

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

Ken Ward

I love reading these stories about being saved by a face shield,It has definitely saved my mug on more than one occasion.So you non believers take notice,they Will save you butt.

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

Keith Tompkins

Ken, You misinterpret my intent...I'm not saying "don't wear a faceshield". I'm saying a faceshield is not a substitute for safe turning practices. And there are a LOT of unsafe practices out there! Wearing a shield does NOT make unsafe methods ok, and it is not designed to stop flying wood blanks. Remember, there are people using lathes and bandsaws that should not be using them. With or without a faceshield. Just look at youtube...or start teaching. Why do you think safety has become such a priority with the AAW?

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#14

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

Ken Ward

Keith,I wasn't referring to yours or anyone else's comment.I was talking about folks in general that doesn't use or even believe that face shields are any help at all towards offering protection,and yes I have seen many vidios with folks spinning a piece of wood at 2000 RPM without ANY face protection.Sorry about the missunderstanding.

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Face shield save at the butt end of the lathe

Keith Tompkins

It's cool Ken....I get wound up on the subject, esp. when many accidents can be prevented . Gotta' be safe..