Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

Posts

Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#1

Steven Antonucci

Fitting 5# in a 1# bag 

Steven Antonucci

Fresh off of a weekend course I taught at Peters Valley. Introduction to woodturning is taught over the course of 2 days, with day one being a spindle day and day two being a face grain day.

I always get a mix of some local people that I know, and some that I do not. I also get a mix in personalities and learning types. I try really hard to strike a balance between folks that I know, folks that I don't and how people learn. In general, I really enjoy teaching the class, but I am always trying to find new ways to reach people to correct some of the very basic issues.

In no particular order, anyone that has an opinion on the topics below is welcome to comment:

1.) How do you handle a situation when someone is not particularly coordinated? I would assist them in getting the gouge to the wood and say "ok, now I am going to let go. Don't move it. At all. Just hold it still." As soon as I would let go, they would lurch forward and stab the wood. Over and over. 100X throughout the weekend.

2.) How do you get a simple point across when the simple explanation just doesn't work? An example is "When you are cutting the inside of a bowl, the flute needs to be at 1 o'clock. Never face the flute towards the wall of the bowl. If you do, you will get a catch". There were several people who had several catches and they would ask me "I don't understand what I did wrong.", and I could never get it across to them, and I couldn't think of another way to explain it. What do you do when the this happens?

3.) I know what I do when people part from the syllabus, but how do you handle them? (I personally abandon them until we get to a new part or we catch up to them). It is usually someone who thinks that they know a little bit more than they actually do, and it's sometimes hard to reel them back in and explain to them that they are actually not very good (When I took David Ellsworth's class, I was this guy...)

As an example, I usually try to pace the class in 20 minute sections for things that take me a minute to do. With 8 people in the class, that means I can spend a minute with each person 2X to make them better turners and help them understand what we are trying to do. If we are cutting a box, some people need more help trying to figure out what sequence to work in. Others, might need to change a body position. If I get the minute with each of them, I try to fix the problems before getting to the next step. At least 2 guys were consistently "running ahead", and it happens every class... so I use their minute with someone else...

4.) Next, when the "run ahead" guys aren't getting the minute visit, they tend to be surrogate instructors. It's kind of a mixed blessing, in that 8 beginners is a lot to handle, but I think that sometimes their help is actually in the way. As an example, the one "runner" is a friend from the club that took the class, and he's not a very good turner, but hasn't had that moment of reckoning yet. He does some things better than others and has a desire to help, and he actually spent a lot of his class time trying to help someone who needed a lot of help (more than I could give). What would you do?

5.) Lastly, do you ever get to a point where you realize that there are some people that you just won't be able to help enough without stealing time from some of the other students? I struggle with this a lot, in that everyone has paid to be there and some people need more help than others... but there is only one me? I really try hard to not play favorites, but have you ever gotten to the point where you've had to abandon someone because you know that you just can't help them?

With that, I leave you with the peace of a Peters Valley sunset from Saturday night (after some wicked storms knocked out the power for 3 hours.)


Please consider answering from both a student and teaching perspective...

Steven

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#2

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

Chuck Engstrom

Hi Steve - I wonder if maybe you are expecting too much from yourself -- and your students -- in a two-day format. You are seeing likely the variety of success/aptitude/attitude that every teacher probably experiences, and as you wryly point out, David Ellsworth faces the same issues.

Learning to turn is a protracted process of creating hand/eye/brain coordination, just like learning to play a musical instrument, and real finesse -- any finesse at all -- takes way more than two days, just as learning to play the guitar takes more than learning to strum three chords. In the end you have to emphasize that everyone needs to go home and practice, practice, practice.

The specifics of your approach sound about right to me, and I doubt that you could get a much different result with even the most radical change of style. Your more accomplished students probably understand that beginners require more time from you, true in almost any class.

By the same token, you will find that as you teach and demonstrate more and more, you will find ways to convey more material faster, etc etc. Do you suppose that Ellsworth or Clewes or Raffan were as good their first time in front of a class as they are now? Seems doubtful to me. I'd be glad to demo twice a week just to get better at it.

Best to all -- Chuck

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#3

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

Jim Rutten

Now take that 16 and add 19 to it and you have what a school teacher goes through every day. Here are my thoughts:

1. This is a tough one. I think I would have them practice with a sheet of paper instead of a bowl. Don't rip the paper. Tough to do without adding stress to that person.

2. Was this person a young'un cause they don't understand face of a clock cause they grew up with digitals. Try "hold the flute at 60 degrees to the tool rest and see if that works better.

3. I don't think there is much to do for these people. They paid for the class so all you can do is try to keep them on task. I would use there 30 seconds to a minute to maybe say something like "I see you are done but I was wondering if you could clean up that bead a little. Go up to my lathe and take a good look and see if you can get there.

Also, I love the way you are structuring the class with the 1 minute to 20 minutes. I would think that would be just about right for the rank beginners.

4. The guy from your club should know better and I might approach that on a personal level. On the other hand I have been in classes before when I had finished early and I have gotten questions from others in the class. Not wanting to be rude I always gave the answers politely. If this is the case maybe a facilities change so the people are separated and cannot see each other's progress.

5. I was in a woodturning class turning a big bowl. I got a catch and, although the bowl stayed in place, I got a thumb knuckle caught between the tool rest and the bowl. Happened in just a few seconds but as a result I bled like a stuck pig. All over the floor and when I finally got to the restroom to get it cleaned off I felt sick. Layed down for a couple minutes and didn't feel better so I went home (where my nurse/wife took care of me ;) ). I missed probably 75% of that lesson. I came in early to the next one hoping to catch up a little bit and found my project at the same level as the other turners. At first I was a little offended but at the end of the class when I had something to take home I was happy. I would not do this with everyone, but some I would.

Good luck Steve. Please persevere as the world needs more teachers and learners and less politicians and lawyers!

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#4

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

Tony - Memphis

Well, I wish I could help. I'm mostly a student though, and not a teacher. I just wanted to chime in and commend you on your level of thought and consideration. I've taken a few classes and experienced all of the above types that you mention. Hang in there. It takes a special person to be a good teacher.

I took a class at Lonnie Bird's school once. There was a student that was telling people what/how to do everything. There was a blow up and the student and Lonnie had words and the student left. In fairness, the class was too big and too complex for a week and several students quit early. Long story. But the point is that it dampened the whole affair for all of us.

When I am in a class, I'm there to learn. Fortunately, I realize I don't know it all and that I can learn even simple things if I pay attention to somebody like yourself or Lonnie. And I don't think any students paid their money to listen to me either, so I try and keep my mouth shut unless it is something simple I can assist with.

Maybe I can take a class with you someday. My woodturning is awful. I do 99% spindle work (furniture parts). Still mostly luck, not skill.

Anyway, keep up the effort. Eventually, the ones that don't get it will get it and have you or somebody like you to thank.

Tony

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#5

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

Barry L Elder

(1) My main problem is being hardheaded. And when I was starting out, my mentor explained the cutting tool, the fulcrum, and the angle of the dangle, by taking his great big 5/8 gouge and banging on the tool rest for about 5 minutes as he explained the first cut.

(2) Then he demonstrated the "cutting edge" with the proper angle by rotating the wood by hand and showing us the little curl. Then he showed how sharp his gouge was by slicing his thumb on the edge. Accident? It was effective! :D

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#6

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

Grant Wilkinson

I've never been, nor likely every will be, a teacher. As a student, I'll address your 1 o'clock flute position. You'd be surprised how many people can't get the concept of where the hour hand on a clock is within the context of something else. When out on my boat, I can tell my partner that a loon is at 2 o'clock and she will not look in that direction. For beginners, you may want to simply say that the flute should be turned clockwise from straight up and down - or even to the right - a little bit. If they are off a bit, no worries. I took lessons from Bill Grumbine. He uses 45, 45, 45. It seems to work.

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

Mike Stafford

One of the problems in teaching a turning class regardless if it is classified as a beginner, some turning experience required, or advanced is that you can almost always count on getting students who have never seen a lathe, students who are there willing to learn and students who know more than you.

Students who know more than you are not necessarily a problem as long as they don't spend the entire time demonstrating that to the rest of the class. When they are willing to help you teach those students who need to most help they can be a blessing.

From your post I gather you had 8 students. That is too many to handle by yourself. It is well above the reasonable span of control. 8 inexperienced students is a disaster waiting to happen. Fortunately where I teach if you have 8 or more you get to have an assistant and that makes all the difference in the world.

Answering the questions point by point if I have an answer:

1. Students who jab the tools into the wood I help by showing them how to find the bevel by first rubbing the heel of the tool on the wood and then gradually raising the handle until the edge makes contact. It may or may not work for all students but I have found after a few colossal catches they will either listen or I will give them EZ wood tools to use. Nothing works for all students as some people are too stupid to use power tools. I require all students to sign a release to indemnify themselves for their own stupidity.

2. See response to number 1. EZ wood tools allow people who will not listen to scrape out some semblance of a wood turning and most of them are happy with that as they really don't have plans to go home and start turning. This is very common where I teach as there are a lot of retired people who get a discounted tuition, come with no tools or skills and are there to spend some time.

3. Guys that run ahead can be a mixed blessing if they do not interfere with the rest of the class. I tend to give them some attention, offer suggestions but in general don't get in their way. If they get into trouble I offer more advice which I hope they can use.

4. If your helpers aren't helping you have to ask that they not assume that responsibility. The school has decided you are the instructor and that you have the responsibility for teaching and as much as you appreciate their help they need to respect your wishes. If they cannot understand that then you have to tell them in a different way.

5. Yes, this happens in every class. In my last class I had very fine gentleman who very quickly realized he was way over his head. My assistant and I spent an inordinate amount of time with him for the first couple of days and got him to the point where he was confident in turning cross grain boxes. He decided that he did not want to attempt the end grain portion of the class and spent the entire week turning cross grain boxes. He was very pleased with his work by the end of the week and I was gratified by his progress. I knew he had a successful week when he bought several sets of blanks for cross grain boxes which he took home. You have to spend time with those that need your help and are willing to learn. You also need to spend time with those who might kill themselves because of their inability or unwillingness to learn. I have found that people in the latter category should be given alternative tools so they can scrape out whatever it is they want to turn. In another class I had a woman who was incapable of learning. She jabbed every tool in, damaged tools, split pieces of wood and spent the whole time standing out in the aisle beckoning me for help. Finally I just turned some things for her and handed her the sand paper and finish. She went home with some finished projects and I retained my sanity such as it is......

My scariest moments have come from people who had no idea how to sharpen and decided to sharpen their tools when I wasn't looking. No deaths yet but I have more gray hair.

A good assistant is a blessing. So are experienced turners who recognize that you need some help.

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

Keith Tompkins

Hey Steve, a couple of thoughts. Newbies. They always try to control the cut with just their hands and arms. No control. I have them lock the tool against their abdomen, and use big body motions to control the tool...much more effective...legs and hips are important. Then, slightly opening and closing of the hands for very fine feed control of the tool. I did a recent demo in Maine, people in the back couldn't see where my flute was pointed, so blue painters tape on the handle with a big black arrow solved that problem. Perhaps the same idea would work for the students...the arrow is THIS WAY! Handouts....right in front of them to look at! Like this!

During my finial class, I drew up a sheet showing beads and coves; not just any shapes, but specific size beads and coves, and combinations..if they couldn't turn those...good luck turning a finial! Beads and coves all day if necessary, while more advanced students move on.

Guidelines: STOP! Nobody uses the bandsaw except me. Nobody sharpens my tools except ME! (been there) Roll your sleeves up, take your watch and rings off. I had a lady attempt to get her money back because I insisted she remove her big, bulky sweater. She removed it.

Know your assistant: Nothing is worse than an assistant who knows more than you do! (or think they do) Talk to your assistant ahead of time..nothing is worse than an assistant contradicting your teaching methods or techniques!

Hope this helps.

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#9

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

Allen Howell

Here are my 2c worth, as a teacher (of Drafting, not turning).

1. Some students will never get it. But, as a teacher, you should never give up. Try to find out exactly why they are messing up, either by talking them through it, or by observation. Sooner or later, it will click with them. No one learns more than the teacher.

2. I have found that good teachers have the ability to say things three or more different ways, to get across to different learning types. This is something you should think about as you teach (inside your head, say "how else could I have said that?").

3. Sometimes just asking the jumpers to slow down so the others don't feel left out will help. Sometimes, not.

4. As the teacher, it is incumbent on you to ensure that the students learn properly, and maybe at the beginning of the classes, you could emphasize that you may be asking the more advanced students to assist those who are less advanced, but to wait until asked to do so. This might help.

5. Different people learn at different speeds and with different needs. The ones that need it most will, of course, take more time. Those that get it quickly, will need less time. It's a balancing act, for sure.

Hope this has given you some additional insight or inspiration, but not indigestion.

Allen

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#10

Steven Antonucci

Agree on all points (and I am doing all of them)

Steven Antonucci

I actually used the jumpers to help some of the slower students for three reasons.

1.) it stopped them from jumping

2.) I needed the help (and so did the students)

3.) It showed the jumpers that they didn't know as much as they thought they did, or in some cases, it allowed me to see it through their eyes so I could explain it some other way. Watching someone teach it wrong explains what they don't understand and helps me connect the dots.

Thanks for the insight.

Steve

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#11

Steven Antonucci

See my clarifications


Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#12

Steven Antonucci

Some clarifications (and my Day 1 syllabus)

Steven Antonucci

For starters, I didn't have a "turning assistant". There is a shop assistant (Jim) who was very helpful with other things that needed to happen, but he's not a turner. It was just me, and 8 brand new turners, 3 who are from 2 clubs I belong to (so they had a little experience...but only a little)

I have read the responses about some of the ideas and the funny thing is that I am doing almost all of them. Here is the syllabus broken down into what I think are digestable blocks.

We start with the basic operation of a lathe and an introduction to wood and how a tree grows.

I show them a roughing gouge, we put wood between centers and make it round. Spindle turning 101. Me first, then them. 20:1 ratio

I pick up a spindle gouge and explain beads and coves Beads start at the top and cut down hill. Coves start at the edge and cut down hill. always cut downhill. I show them a couple of pieces, then they go. At least 20 to 1, probably more like 40:1.

We aren't specifically making anything except beads and coves on a stick...

Next up, I suggest that if you had a big enough stick, you might be able to make a candlestick. I introduce them to making a tenon to fit a chuck and how critical it is to be able to make an accurate tenon. I tell them to grab a new piece of wood and make it round, then turn two tenons on either end. 20:1 with me fixing a lot of tenons and re-explaining the accurate tenon thing.

Finally, I show them a drill chuck and a forstner bit for setting in your candles. We drill a 7/8", 1" deep. Now turn some beads and coves on your candle stick. 20,30, 40:1.

Lastly, I show them how to turn a tenon for that 7/8" hole and jam over it to finish the bottom. The first piece of wood is retired and the first lesson is done.

The day ends with making a box, which is nothing more than the exact same things as above, only a few more steps in the work sequence (another hole gets drilled, a few more accurate tenons, and an additional jam chuck...but no new steps or tools)

This is day 1. I sharpened all the tools the night before and put green painters tape on the handle of their SRG, parting tools and 1/2" spindle gouges. I explicitly forbid them to use anything but these three tools to do the work. I have laid it out to make each segment add only one thing from the last segment.

This year, I added a lot more demonstration than I have done in the past. I figured that if I showed them how to do it correctly, it would eliminate some errors. Didn't change a thing. In fact, it made me remember the following directions test we all failed in school (you know the one that said read all the question first before answering... and the last question says don't answer the first 50 questions and write "BLUE" on the back of the paper.) I would turn on my lathe and say "Ok, when you get to here stop and wait for everyone to catch up." and almost everyone would go off on some tangent.

I know I take this stuff too seriously, but a some level, I feel responsible for these people's safety in the future. I suppose we all survive the learning years...I know I did.

Steve

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#13

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

Barry Irby

Steve, I am somewhat dyslexic or dysgraphic or maybe just bass-ackwards. My son started turning when he was about 12. My job became to procure turning blocks. I taught him what I could and got him DVD's and books. I took him to Arrowmont when he turned 15 to turn with David Ellsworth for a week.

It became clear to me that I completely misunderstood David's description of how to orient the gouge. I misunderstood what he meant by "orient the flute". I took it to mean as if there were a "rod laying in the flute" or the same direction the shaft was pointing rather than which way the "opening" in the flute was pointing. I know that this is so stupid that I am having a hard time making myself clear. Think of it as if you put the edge of your hand into the flute and your hand is flat and your thumb is pointing straight up (toward 12 o'clock). I thought he meant which way your pinky was pointing. This is just to demonstrate there is nothing that can not be misunderstood.

My first attempt was something like sticking a stout stick into the prop on a bass boat with the motor running. David came over and took the end of the gouge in his fingertips and cut a curve around the inside of the "bowl" I was hacking at, with one hand. I got much better instantly.

Also, David took me aside and told me they hated it when a husband and wife or any "duo" took the class. I asked why and he stumbled around a bit and finally revealed that one of them was always better than the other. He was awkwardly trying to tell me that my son was much better than I was. (He thought this revelation would hurt my feelings.) I burst out laughing and told him I already knew that and that I had taught my son all I could and that I hoped David would teach him all he could. In my opinion its a good thing when the student surpasses the teacher.

I think you should explain to your classes that you are sure some of them are better than others and perhaps some of them just won't get it. That YOU are the instructor and you expect that those of you who are more advanced will take the time to absorb what you have to offer and then perhaps they can help some of the others, but only if they want the help, but try to stick with the program.

You might also consider having an evening session for any who want it to catch up.

A fellow in our class came to me and complemented my son for being such a nice guy. Turns out he was turning on a Poolwood lathe and could not get his gouge to cut at all and he asked my son what he was doing wrong. My son pointed out that the lathe was running backwards and went back to what he was doing. The guy thought it was remarkable that my son did not tease him unmercifully after such a perfect set up. My son just thought anyone could make that mistake.

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#14

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

robo hippy

I don't understand how any one could handle more than 1 or 2 newbies (this is a lathe....). With a class of maybe 4, if they were some what experienced, then you could turn them loose for a bit to practice a certain skill, while you tend to others. 8 students, well, if they were all at higher level, say, not up to graduate school level, then not too much of a problem.

I can understand 'some should never be left alone', and this just isn't for every one. Hard part is determining who that applies to. Maybe if I reach the 1000 student level, I may get there.

robo hippy

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#15

Joe Bradshaw

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

Joe Bradshaw

I have taken two classes with Mike, and really enjoyed both of them. I plan on taking a third class next June. It is like a vacation for me, even through I'm retired. I manage to learn something new each time, plus there is no pressure to produce a turned box. Mike probably says, oh, crap, Joe is taking this class again. Steve, you sound like you are on the right path, teach the ones who want to learn and try to keep the other ones out of trouble.

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#16

Steven Antonucci

A picture is worth a thousand words...

Steven Antonucci

and can cover 2 days worth of material.

Here is my attempt at creating a memory device for people to remember the materials:


Whenever something bad happened, I tried to tie it back to violating one of the rules...

Steve

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#17

Hey Joe, that group was so much.....

JamieDonaldson

...fun that I might join you and Mike again! Evening meditation(no, I didn't say medication!) on the veranda was a great break from all the work Mike was demanding of us! :D

Re: Fitting 5# in a 1# bag

#18

Mike Stafford

Re: Hey Joe, that group was so much.....

Mike Stafford

I would love to repeat that class again. That was a fun bunch of guys. I needed the evening medication after dealing with you guys all day.