Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

another finial....

Posts

another finial....

#1

Keith Tompkins

another finial....

Keith Tompkins

Here's another one: this one is yellowheart. What a wonderful wood to turn. 3" tall, under 1/16" at min. diameter. I gave away a whole bunch while at PV...better than this one :(

Re: another finial....

#2

Re: another finial....

Bernie Weishapl

Beautiful Keith.

Re: another finial....

#3

Wonderfully done............

jake Niedling

Keith, the curves and the shape on both of them are well done. Getting the right curve and transitions is not easy. What is your main tool for these turnings? 3/8" detail gouge and 1/2" skew? It would be nice to see a short youtube video, if you care to share just a little bit to wet our appettite. Thanks for the pictures and inspiration.

Re: another finial....

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Wonderfully done............

Keith Tompkins

Thanks Bernie! Jake, yes I used a 1/2" skew, and 3/8" spindle gouge, ground way back. The skew is used long point down. Thanks!

Re: another finial....

#5

Re: another finial....

phillip medghalchi

keith, your intentions are very nice. Nice work. However, visually it brakes the eye three times.. and curves don't follow in one plane. you started the tip right then you gave it a bead slightly bigger than the diameter of the tip then it's ok down to the larger curved bead. The base where it's supposed to sit on the lid or anything it will attach to is smaller than the last curve above it. I hope you take this as a design critic and nothing else.

Re: another finial....

#6

Steven Antonucci

I saw some of the drawings still on the whiteboard

Steven Antonucci

A finial class... hmmm. Much quicker clean-up...

Any chance that you guys were turning rosewoods in this class? My allergies were killing me all weekend. Might have been the walnut we cut...

Steve

Re: another finial....

#7

Don Leydens

Sweet!

Don Leydens

Keith, some things just look sweet although they might defy common wisdom. To me, this is one of them. Very nicely done, love it.

Re: another finial....

#8

Re: another finial....

Craig Daymon

Great finials Keith.

Any chance you watched, "The Lorax", recently? The shape has a strong resemblance to Dr. Seuss's birds. (Heads point up, of course.)

-Craig

Re: another finial....

#9

Keith,

GaryG in MD

I really like the definition in that upper "flying saucer".

Sweet, Gary

Re: another finial....

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: another finial....

Keith Tompkins

Phillip, I DON'T want all of my curves to follow the same plane. One criticism of turning is that it's boring, too symetrical. My turning is done intentionally to break up the line you describe, also varying diameters from large to small helps break up the symmetry. Also, beads and coves are asymmetrical for the same reasons. Perhaps you could post a finial pic for discussion...thanks!

Re: another finial....

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: I saw some of the drawings still on the whiteb

Keith Tompkins

Hey Steve , Yes we may have turned some rosewood..sorry. Did you check out the finial on the shelf above the blackboard? THAT was a good one!

Re: another finial....

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: another finial....

Keith Tompkins

I almost forgot..the base is small only because of the stock's initial dimensions. If you look at the other finial I posted, it sits in a larger collar. which this one will as well. These are practice pieces, a finished piece will usually be turned with an integral collar.

Re: another finial....

#13

Steven Antonucci

I did notice it...

Steven Antonucci

And it did stand out!

Steve

Re: another finial....

#14

Re: another finial....

John Lucas

I agree with Keith. The line could be an arc just as easily as a triangle. In the case of an arc the base could actually be smaller. It would be the difference between a static look and a dynamic look. Either one is correct but depends on what you are after for that piece.

Re: another finial....

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: I did notice it...

Keith Tompkins

:b Steve...does that mean it was out-standing?

Re: another finial....

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: another finial....

Keith Tompkins

Hey John, loved the lamp, btw! John, as you know, I use different shapes to get an idea of proper proportion...golden rectangle, etc. I also wrote an article on the "tompkins triangle" method of designing work...however, always sticking to preconceived ideas becomes a trap in itself, and I only use these as guidelines, not as if they are etched in stone. If one believes the finished piece must stay within the constraints of the line, they've stepped in their own trap.

Re: another finial....

#17

Re: another finial....

phillip medghalchi

Keith, I posted my comment in visual way, I respect that you taught a class and didn't realize that until after I posted this comment. I didn't expect you to take it the wrong way, as teachers and students we should be open to criticism as well as comments and compliments. If we take everything harshly then we close the doors for improvement, and also if one teaches then he should be humble to listen if another one make a comment. I haven't started to make finials yet since I don't have the proper tools for it yet, however, I have been looking and studying other designer's work to learn from their experiences. This is how different designers evolve in the same field, because they have different approach to the same concept. Sorry, if my comment took you on the wrong path.

Re: another finial....

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: another finial....

Keith Tompkins

Hi Phillip,

I do appreciate your input; While I'm not the first person to use triangles as a design/teaching aid, I introduced the concept to woodturners during a demo at the AAW national symposium several years back, and have written magazine articles on the subject. Several top turners liked the idea, and have asked my permission to use the same triangle idea during their classes and demos. It works for bowls, hollow forms and even finials, as shown in the pic I included. So, I am aware of the triangle concept. If I sounded annoyed (yeah, I was a bit) I apologize...there are just so many other design ideas that contribute to a good overall design. Flowing curves, with no straight lines, varying diameters, good proportions, a sense of rythm or continuity....you get the idea! Personally, I'll turn a form, even if it doesn't seem to match the perfect"ideal", then set it aside and study it...just to see what I like or don't like about it. And yes, a good teacher always listens to, and learns from his students.

Re: another finial....

#19

Re: another finial....

phillip medghalchi

Keith, I appreciate your reply and wanted to shake your hand if we were in person. I am like you, while I design something I bring it in the house and study it under different light, time of the day, and even moode and be honest with you even though I am new at turning, I am blessed to have my wife who has sudied Japaneese water color, has a master degree in art and is very creative she also has very good eyes for shape and lines, so she is my critic and I trust her opinion. As, long as we are open to constructive crtitcism then we can grow as artis and student as well as teachers. I appreciate your open mindedness and sharing above concept too. Thank you.

Re: another finial....

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: another finial....

Keith Tompkins

Cool! If we were to meet, I think you would find me good company! You are lucky to have such a talented wife...perhaps you could do some colaborative pieces!