More physics for hollowturners...
Steven Antonucci
I thought about trying to illustrate this discussion in complex formulas and proofs, but the truth is that I haven't been around that math in 25 years, and it's pretty much beyond my abilities these days. I spent a minute looking at the torque formulas again, and I thought this might be helpful to anyone looking to understand the physics of hollowing:
1.) F=ma. Force equals mass times acceleration. Torque = force applied around an axis of rotation. Extrapolated from these two equations: The greater the mass, the greater the torque potential.
As turners, we worry more about final cuts than first cuts, but the potential energy is much higher when the spinning mass is heavier.
2.) Newtons law suggests for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. Tying this back to the first point, when the force at the cutting tip gets out of centerline, it applies torque to the tool. If the mass of the thing you are turning is sufficient, it will transmit that torque through the tool to the turner in a potentially unpleasant way. If you are turning something big and heavy, you can reduce the potential torque by arresting the back end of the bar or slowing down the lathe.
If your piece was thin, you probably exceeded the strength of the material. Thin pieces cannot withstand the forces. Thick ones can. If you apply a force to the piece in an inappropriate manner, the piece will apply the same force back to the tool. The equal and opposite reaction HAS to occur.
3.) Angular momentum is a measurement determined by the radius crossed with mass times velocity. It's pretty obvious that if you make any of these items bigger, you get more energy in the system. In a nutshell, the heavier or wider that a piece of wood is on the lathe, the slower you want to run it.
4.) Lastly, Mike Foster and I discussed the issue of having a tool at the end of the bar that is out of line with the centerline. This creates torque. If you look at this picture from Wikipedia, consider it an Ellsworth style cutter on a hollowing tool:

The F represents the cutter, and the torque is only created by the perpendicular component of the force. It's determined by the angle (sine), which is always less than one. For a 45 degree angle, it represents about 70%.
So if torque is created by a force through a distance, a longer cutter will create more torque. However, torque problems are far worse when the cutter moves.
Think of a framing square that is "slightly out of square". If you place it on a sheet good and strike a line, you get one measurement at the bottom and another measurement at the top. That miniscule change in the angle can translate to a measurable error at the top. In our Ellsworth tool example, being slightly out of level is the mechanical equivalent of the cutter growing longer!
What then happens, often more quickly than one can react to is an "avalanche condition", where the force on the cutter grows higher, causing even a greater angle at the support point, and even more forces at the tip... until something gives.
So, in summary, almost all hollowturning issues are cause by the cutter being out of level. (Thanks to Lyle for being the guy who pointed this out to me years ago...) It is just this simple. If you keep the cutter level, all of the physics become manageable.
Steve
P.S. A special case of the "cutter getting out of center line" is vibration. Some day, I will revisit my materials class and think about mechanical cross sections, harmonics, and stiffness of beams... but in the end, it will come down to bigger is better for most load conditions.





