Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

More physics for hollowturners...

Posts

More physics for hollowturners...

#1

Steven Antonucci

More physics for hollowturners...

Steven Antonucci

I thought about trying to illustrate this discussion in complex formulas and proofs, but the truth is that I haven't been around that math in 25 years, and it's pretty much beyond my abilities these days. I spent a minute looking at the torque formulas again, and I thought this might be helpful to anyone looking to understand the physics of hollowing:

1.) F=ma. Force equals mass times acceleration. Torque = force applied around an axis of rotation. Extrapolated from these two equations: The greater the mass, the greater the torque potential.

As turners, we worry more about final cuts than first cuts, but the potential energy is much higher when the spinning mass is heavier.

2.) Newtons law suggests for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. Tying this back to the first point, when the force at the cutting tip gets out of centerline, it applies torque to the tool. If the mass of the thing you are turning is sufficient, it will transmit that torque through the tool to the turner in a potentially unpleasant way. If you are turning something big and heavy, you can reduce the potential torque by arresting the back end of the bar or slowing down the lathe.

If your piece was thin, you probably exceeded the strength of the material. Thin pieces cannot withstand the forces. Thick ones can. If you apply a force to the piece in an inappropriate manner, the piece will apply the same force back to the tool. The equal and opposite reaction HAS to occur.

3.) Angular momentum is a measurement determined by the radius crossed with mass times velocity. It's pretty obvious that if you make any of these items bigger, you get more energy in the system. In a nutshell, the heavier or wider that a piece of wood is on the lathe, the slower you want to run it.

4.) Lastly, Mike Foster and I discussed the issue of having a tool at the end of the bar that is out of line with the centerline. This creates torque. If you look at this picture from Wikipedia, consider it an Ellsworth style cutter on a hollowing tool:


The F represents the cutter, and the torque is only created by the perpendicular component of the force. It's determined by the angle (sine), which is always less than one. For a 45 degree angle, it represents about 70%.

So if torque is created by a force through a distance, a longer cutter will create more torque. However, torque problems are far worse when the cutter moves.

Think of a framing square that is "slightly out of square". If you place it on a sheet good and strike a line, you get one measurement at the bottom and another measurement at the top. That miniscule change in the angle can translate to a measurable error at the top. In our Ellsworth tool example, being slightly out of level is the mechanical equivalent of the cutter growing longer!

What then happens, often more quickly than one can react to is an "avalanche condition", where the force on the cutter grows higher, causing even a greater angle at the support point, and even more forces at the tip... until something gives.

So, in summary, almost all hollowturning issues are cause by the cutter being out of level. (Thanks to Lyle for being the guy who pointed this out to me years ago...) It is just this simple. If you keep the cutter level, all of the physics become manageable.

Steve

P.S. A special case of the "cutter getting out of center line" is vibration. Some day, I will revisit my materials class and think about mechanical cross sections, harmonics, and stiffness of beams... but in the end, it will come down to bigger is better for most load conditions.

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#2

Great Post!

Don Orr

I appreciate facts over opinions any day. You can't deny physics. Newton is our friend! Adapt accordingly. Takes me back a few years too. Not an engineer but took a few semesters of physics.

May the force(s) be with you. :D

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#3

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

John Lucas

I don't argue the facts. My question is, what is level as it pertains to a round object. In other words suppose I tilt the tool down toward 8 oclock but then cut at 8 oclock on the piece. I'm talking about a hollowing tool here with a bent tip. So imagine that I put the tool bend parallel to the ground and cut at 9 oclock on the piece. Then I tilt the tool down a few degrees and cut at 8 oclock but lets say the top of the tool is perpendicular to the area where I am cutting. Aren't the forces the same at that point?

Bear in mind that I'm not an engineer and suck at math. I've just worked on mechanical things all my life and kind of understand how things work, I think.

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#4

Steven Antonucci

Negative rake scraping inside

Steven Antonucci

John-

When you cut with the tip rotated down from 9 o'clock to 8 o'clock, you are essentially negative rake scraping, which lessens the force because of the angle the same way that the force is lessened by having the angled cutter. Part of the force is directed downward into empty space, and part perpendicular into the wall at 9 o'clock. If you have a swan neck and the cutter is in line with the shaft, you do not have a torque arm, so tipping in downward actually also makes it less aggressive without the presence of the original torque issue!

I tried to keep the post qualitative (more vs. less) than quantitative (70% vs 65% e.g.) so that people wouldn't argue over the exact numbers and the math, but instead focus on the relationships of mass, distance, RPMs, and how they translate to turning forces.

Hope this makes sense.

Steve

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#5

Re: Negative rake scraping inside

John Lucas

Steve I'm not talking about negative rake scraping. If you took a drawing of the tool intersecting the arc at 9 oclock and rotated it counter clockwise to 8 oclock you would have what I'm talking about. This isn't the same thing as cutting with the tool tilted to make a negative rake. Does that make sense.

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#6

Steven Antonucci

Going to need a picture (I'm not gettin' it?)


Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

Lyle Jamieson

John you are absolutely right, the forces would be the same at 8 or 9. The good news when cutting at 9:00 is the force of the cut is distributed directly down on the tool rest and easy to control. The bad news for cutting at 8:00 is the forces are now at an angle to the tool rest and forces will have to be resisted. Equal and opposite as Steve said. It would likley bounce and chatter in there, as it pushes away from the wood surface accross the tool rest, and make vibration even worse. It would want to skate to the right as it cuts.

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#8

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

John Lucas

Well that's what I was thinking. The wood doesn't know the difference because it's round and as long as the cutter to wood orientation is the same no difference. However the cutter to the tool rest makes a huge difference. Part of my demo on occasions is to turn a bead on a platter using a straight bar sticking straight up. I'm turning the bead at 12 oclock with the spindle gouge pointing toward the wall. This works of course because the tool rest is in a totally different position.

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#9

Steven Antonucci

I don't think this is true?

Steven Antonucci

While the difference is probably minor and insignificant from a practical perspective, I do not believe that the two are equivalent from a physics perspective.

The frame of reference for the cutter being presented at 8 or 9 is probably true, because the interior is round and as long as the cutter is normal (perpendicular to the wood), the physics at any point in the circle might appear to be the same, but it is not. Let me provide a very simple example:

Move the cutter to the 3 o'clock position. Or 6 o'clock. Would you say that the forces are the same? Of course you would not. There is a gradient change from 9 o'clock to 6 o'clock, meaning that every point along the dial is slightly different between the two. It is imperceptible between 9 o'clock and 8:59, but still there.

In addition the forces transmit through the system. Simply it again... straight bar with a straight cutter. If I cut, the force at the tip goes straight down, and creates a force at the fulcrum point, or where the bar touches the tool rest. I counter that force on the handle to keep the system in equilibrium (aka...the cutter on centerline). Now, switch the cutter for a scraper tip and start to roll it counter clockwise. Part of the force goes down through the tool, but there is also a force pushing the tool to the right that you feel.

If you lower the cutter to 8 o'clock, it has a similar effect because the force transmits through the bar to create torque. It isn't significantly different than the torque at 9 o'clock (I think about 87% if I remember my trig), but that other 13% is now lateral.

Please don't make me relearn statics and dynamic from my mechanical engineering classes. I took Dynamics twice, but I did get an A the second time around...

Steve

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#10

Re: I don't think this is true?

Don Orr

I think some of the confusion may be related to the terms being used to describe what is being changed to determine if forces change. I believe there is a big difference in forces and torque between a straight tipped hollowing tool and one with a tip angled off to one side away from the center line of the tool. This is what Steve was trying to explain-and did a good job of it. The position described by using the clock reference only describes the rotation around the longitudinal axis of the tool. What can change the forces involved, and has not really been discussed but needs to be, is raising the tool handle/lowering the cutting tip. This is mostly an issue when using hand held hollowing tools, but then so is rotating from 9 to 8 o'clock. When using some type of torque-arresting hollowing setup-such as Lyle's-it is generally recommended to position the offset cutter at the center of lathe rotation with the bar holding that cutter(scraper) level relative to the floor/lathe bed. Correct me if I am wrong here. In this situation the force diagram Steve showed is accurate. If the tool bar is not level, not at center, tip not at 9 o'clock, things change, sometimes dramatically. All these factors are relative to each other. When doing hand-held hollowing the resultant forces can be much more than a human hand-arm-shoulder can withstand. Thus the main advantage of captured/articulated hollowing system-saving your body and safer hollowing. Controlling these forces provides for a much more pleasant turning experience. It's supposed to be fun, right?

I don't do a lot of hollowing, but when I do, I prefer a captive system. ;) :O :D

Don's Theory of Relativity: everything is relative to everything else.

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#11

Re: I don't think this is true?

John Lucas

Steve But everything would be the same if the tool rest or fulcrum point moves with the tool. How can it not be since we are dealing with a round circle. I am assuming that we have 2 points that never change, that is the angle the tool meets the wood and the fulcrum point.

Of course it would be different if either one of those changes, or for that matter a straight tool vs a curved tool.

I know we are splitting hairs it doesn't mean squat to the average turner, it's just fun to speculate and try to understand better how things work.

Now the trick is, how do we use this info.

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#12

I agree with you John

Mike Foster

I was following along with this, but did not have time to reply. My take on what you had proposed was that it was a totally hypothetical situation. To take it to an extreme, you could hollow with the cutter upside down cutting at the 3 O'clock position. But then you would need a captive tool rest as well as gravity would no longer be your friend. But it should work.

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#13

Steven Antonucci

You just proved my point Mike!

Steven Antonucci

So if you look at the difference between the force on the tool rest between 9 o'clock and 3 o'clock, the arrow goes from straight down to straight up. Every point in between 9 and 3, the arrow is rotating counterclockwise for the same total force, but since it is not perpendicular to the toolrest, the force breaks into two components as seen in the diagram in the original post.

Some of the force is actually being directed parallel to the toolrest. It may not be enough to overcome friction beween the support and the tool. It may not be so excessive that you cannot arrest it with you hands. It ALWAYS exists, regardless of whether or not it can be observed by the user.

That's the beauty of physics. It's not about belief. It's science.

Going back to my original post- almost every issue with regards to hollowing can be solved by simply keeping the cutter on centerline. If you BELIEVE this, you don't need to understand the physics :)

Steve

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#14

Re: I agree with you John

John Lucas

Mike Exactly what Graham Priddle demonstrates, although he does it as a joke. He starts the lathe in reverse and turns with the bowl gouge upside down under the tool rest. He keeps going until the room fills with laughter and then goes, "What" don't you all turn this way. Everything runs backwards on the other side of the equator.

When I do my demo with a straight bar sticking out of the tool rest and turn at 12 oclock I should probably do the same thing with a scraper. What I'm trying to show is that the tool rest doesn't always have to be in the same height. This is often taught as center of the turning height and there are lots of gadgets out there to put on your tool post to lock the rest at this height. I constantly change the tool rest height depending on the tool and how I'm cutting with it.

I also show that there are limits of where a tool rest should go based on what Lyle said. The forces of the tool should go down into the rest rather than you having to fight it. This is where Steve's science comes in. You need to understand the forces involved and how to use them to our best advantage

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#15

Agreed Steve, but

Mike Foster

if you angled your tool rest as you changed your cutter position, all would be good (except for gravity) :D

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#16

Steven Antonucci

Nope, you are thinking in the wrong axis...

Steven Antonucci

I'll keep at it...

Forget for a second about the wood spinning. It applies a force to the tip of the cutter, which is transmitted through the tool shaft over the contact point on the tool rest. If I put sensors on that point to measure the X, Y and Z axis, you get that there is a force up/down (Y axis-gravity/resistance to the downward cutting force).

Ther are also forces along the other two axis' depending upon presentation of the tool. If you've ever used a Hunter cutter, you've felt the Z axis (in/out)where the tool is drawn into the wood, and you need to resist it. That just leaves the left and right forces, since you are cutting on the left, the wood is exerting an equal and opposite force to the right, but that force is variable dependent on the angle you are cutting at... and adjusting the tool rest does not correct for it.

You guys are going to force me to diagram this, aren't you?

Steve

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#17

Steven Antonucci

A good summary...

Steven Antonucci

is exactly what John said that Lyle said...

You want to keep the forces going down into the tool rest. The best way to do this it to keep the cutter level at centerline, as anything but that starts to add physics into the equation, and you can quickly find yourself on the wrong side of the equation.

Steve

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#19

Naw,

Mike Foster

I don't think I made myself clear. You don't change the angle of the tool rest as we conventionally do. You weld a new rest on a post that is perpendicular to the force, so the rest is now not parallel to the bed, but at an angle. Just the same as if you did the 180 and cut with the tool rest above the cutter (rather than under it) and cutting at the 3 oclock postion.

These angles are really hard to describe in words, but I am pretty sure we are all really on the same page. Kind of fun though.

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#20

Never seen Graeme do that, though

Mike Foster

I've seen him do several demo's. Sounds like something fun to try. I guess you would need a tool rest that doesn't have the v angle on the bottom. I have one of Michelson's bar rests that should do the trick. I might just give it a go just to say I can. Could be fun to show at a club meeting as well. Your trick sound like fun as well.

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#21

Steven Antonucci

You'd have to alter the pull of gravity too

Steven Antonucci

Perhaps you could attach a large planet to the tool post you welded to make gravity pull normal to your newly welded toolpost?

Man, I wish I was as smart as I was 25 years ago...

Steve

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#22

What about just doing away with gravity

Mike Foster

You got me thinking on my drive home from work about the problem how gravity affects the whole problem. I started thinking about what it might be like to turn a HF in space. Sets up some interesting problems. No gravity to help keep the tool on the rest, so it really wouldn't matter what angle you turned at as long as the rest was perpendicular to the force on the tip imparted by the turning mass of the wood. You would have to hold the tool on the rest, or come up with a trap for a tool rest or you could potentially get a nasty catch by presenting a tool to the wood without tool rest support. Could end up with some other problems as well. I envision wood chips filling the living quarters of a space capsule, no nice pile of chips to stand on. Then there is that sticky problem offered up by Newtonian physics. For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. The turning mass of the wood would start to set up a spin of said capsule that may not be desired. An interesting thought experiment.

Re: More physics for hollowturners...

#23

Steven Antonucci

No gravity makes for an easier clean-up

Steven Antonucci

so, I can see this being the future of turning. Space shops would be cleanroom clean, with the possible problem of static electricity causing some of the sawdust to cling. I think hollow turning in space would be problematic, as every time you hit the compressor, it would propel you across the shop like an astronaut on a space walk. For some reason, I think that I have heard that if they want to go forward, they hit the forward thrusters (not the ones behind them... nothing to "push on")

You would have to wear an Airshield because the dust would be floating around you, and, frankly, there is no air in space. You wouldn't need a chainsaw, because there are no trees in space either. Even if you brought your wood from Earth, your chainsaw would be useless because it wouldn't have any oxygen for the internal combustion engine. Probably have to get a hydraulic one.

When you consider all of this, it's just a lot easier to push a broom...

steve