Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Raising a burr on a scraper.

Posts

Raising a burr on a scraper.

#1

Raising a burr on a scraper.

John Lucas

I did quite a bit of playing around yesterday because I had to flatten 2 large platters flat enough to glue together with no gaps. Consequently I needed to sharpen my scrapers fairly often. I also wanted to answer (in my mind anyway) what was the best method to get a perfectly flat platter. More on that in a minute.

What I found was that each scraper prefered a different method of raising a burr. I had 5 scrapers. One worked best straight off the grinder. The burr was polished off using a 600 grit diamond hone and then straight off the grinder.

On the other ones I also polished the top. On some the medium or fine diamond hone or John Jordan's ceramic stone running up the bevel but slightly more blunt angle than the bevel raised the best burr.

On others I found that I could raise a better burr by holding the JJ ceramic stone in my hand with my thumb against the side of the scraper and the rounded edged of his stone pulled somewhat forcibly across the sharp edge to raise the burr and then once again at a greater angle to round over the burr very similar to what you might do with a Cabinet scraper. This is probably very similar to using the Lee Valley scraper butt tool but I have more control.

I also tried polishing the top and bevel, then drawing a burr out by running the rounded portion of the ceramic stone across the top with force, then drawing the stone across the cutting edge to bend this burr over just like I would on a cabinet scraper. It didn't seem to work and actually made it worse.

As for getting a board really flat I found the best method was to use whatever tool to get it close using your tool rest as a guide with your hands against the rest. I tried Easywoodtools #2 scraper, Hunter Herculese, round nose sraper and flat scraper. Once you got it close to flat the round nose type scraper were hard to control because you are taking off very small amounts of wood. The flat or very slightly convex scrapers worked better. Once you've got the wood flat enough that there are only small amounts of light showing through when you put a straight edge on it a flat nosed shear scraper with a fresh burr worked best. In fact I also found that a fresh burr on a regular scraper cut better and had more control than the #2 Easywoodtool.

Re: Raising a burr on a scraper.

#2

Re: Raising a burr on a scraper.

Hal Taylor

So John, two questions: what's the bottom line for sharpening (raising a burr) a scraper in the real world; and why were you gluing two platters together?

Re: Raising a burr on a scraper.

#3

Stay tuned for why I glued to platters together.

John Lucas

Hal The bottom line is you have to experiment. As I said each of my scrapers seemed to prefer a certain method for producing the best or should I say cleanest cutting burr. On most of them running the diamond hone up the bevel leaves a good burr and you can change the size of the burr by using course or fine stones. The Medium seems to give the best overall burr that lasts the longest.

John Jordan's ceramic stone is the best for raising the burr on his tool and on one of my flat scrapers.

One scraper is apparently much harder steel and neither JJ's or the diamond hones raise a burr that is anything but very tiny. On that one straigth of the grinder works best.

Re: Raising a burr on a scraper.

#4

Mike Stafford

BIG Yo-yo?????


Re: Raising a burr on a scraper.

#5

Re: Raising a burr on a scraper.

robo hippy

I guess you can use 'specialty' burrs for different situations, but for 99% of what you will do most of the time, the burr straight off the grinder is fine. I do prefer the burr from the CBN wheels, and I do hone off the old burr first on a 220 grit DMT plate. Used as a scraper, as opposed to a shear cutting tool, it is at best a roughing cut, and not a finish cut. If you can get your straight tool rest exactly 90 degrees to the ways of the lathe (lay a big speed/framing square on the ways and eye ball it), then you can clamp a guide to the scraper blade and let that ride on the back side of your tool rest, and that will get you as flat as is humanly possible.

If I am going to burnish a burr on my scrapers, I do it with a triangle burnishing tool, rather than the Veritas burnishing tool. It is important to hone the grinder burr off. I usually will burnish the top of the scraper first, then burnish the bevel side, only a few degrees off the bevel angle, meaning that if the bevel angle is 70 degrees, then burnisher should be at 75 or so degrees. You can over burnish to the point where the burr breaks over the top, like an ocean wave, and you have to really raise the handle of your scraper high to get it to cut, or it won't cut at all.

I have not had a lot of luck with honed burrs. However, like you said, the coarser the hone is the stronger the burr is.

robo hippy