Some nuggets of wisdom in this infommercial *LINK*
Steven Antonucci
Particularly, grain Structure of the metals...
Still, a scraper though...
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Some nuggets of wisdom in this infommercial *LINK*
Steven Antonucci
Particularly, grain Structure of the metals...
Still, a scraper though...
So Steve
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Does Ellis get to send them a bill for the advertising?
Re: Some nuggets of wisdom in this infommercial
John Lucas
Interesting. What he's calling shear scraping is actually a bevel rubbing cut. Maybe on the outside of the bowl it was scraping it was hard to tell but on the spindle and inside of the bowl he was rubbing the bevel which still has the same catching problems you have with bowl gouge. Which is fine of course as long as you know what your doing.
I'll be doing some comparisons between this type of tool and the Hunter tools as soon as I can. I think the Hunters will cut and scrape better but won't know until I actually try them side by side. I have done that before but it's been a while and I didn't really have the right scraper cutters to do the comparison.
The world of advertising is changing Mark
Steven Antonucci
[Rant on]
Conventional "pay for impression" models are changing, Mark. I will suggest that by embedding the ad in the window here, both parties can potentially benefit. If you know anything about technology, it is easy to track sources for "referrals" and if the advertiser notices that a lot of traffic comes from WoodCentral postings, well, they might just buy an ad at some point.
In addition, Ellis needs the audience to attract ads, and that mean content. In a world where there is so much irrelevant content, it is nice to see someone actually think about producing some thoughtful information about their product that isn't just hype. I could have done without the last 6 minutes of the product picture, but then again, I didn't stick around for it anyhow. I thought their coverage of carbide vs. HSS was relevant to this board, so I posted it.
Ellis shouldn't expect to convert every post into revenue, and it is pretty safe to assume that some "free content" may also have marketing material contained within. I won't buy one of the tools, and I don't know that anyone else will as a result watching the video...but what they explained to the viewer was sound and relevant to the WoodCentral audience.
I don't foresee me asking Ellis if it's OK to post links or embed videos for people who do not advertise on WoodCentral, and I didn't post it as an endorsement, so I wouldn't get my panties in a bunch...
[Rant off]
.... also nuggets of UNSAFE TECHNIQUE
Rob Wallace
If I were an instructor supervising this guy's technique, I would point out the safety red flag in his tool holding technique regarding the position of his left hand on the tool rest.
Actually, let me correct that to the fingers of his left hand OVER the tool rest. I find it very uncomfortable to watch him dangle his fingers over the tool he's using, and then get them positioned between the front of the tool rest and the rotating piece of work. I consider this VERY unsafe turning practice.
I don't know how many others of you caught this situation with his left hand (don't watch the cutter, and focus on his tool holding technique), but this is something that I would never teach any woodturner, and IMHO it has no business being included in a video done by "professionals", whether trying to inform about and sell woodturning tools, or a video to be used for some aspect of instruction.
To me this is an inherently flawed video that should not be released for other turners to emulate - whether it is produced by the Robert Sorby company or not. It still clearly shows dangerous turning technique.
Rob Wallace
Re: .... also nuggets of UNSAFE TECHNIQUE
Mike Stafford
You beat me to it Rob. I couldn't believe that at times the only finger he had behind the tool rest was his thumb.
This is the way this man turns. He has positioned his tool rest much farther from the work than most turners would to allow his fingers to control the movement of the tool while his thumb acts as a fulcrum.
At the beginning of the advertisement he explains that the tool is to used flat on the tool rest but in practice he is using it handle up/cutter slightly down in full on scraper mode. He is also turning at a very high RPM which will help scraper performance (as well as most other tools that are sharp).
There are carbides and there are carbides. Those that know something about carbide can tell you that not all carbides are created equal.
Re: The world of advertising is changing . .
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
to free, all under the banner of "providing content", right?
So an advertiser looks at all that "traffic" you've created with "free content" and asks, "Why should I pay to put an ad on WoodCentral when these other guys get all the views for free? All I need do is get a few people to imbed or link to my own site and everything's cool." Next thing that happens is the core advertisers whose revenue keeps WoodCentral up and running question their bills. At Internet speed, it won't take long before the ads disappear and the lights go out.
The world of economics governing the costs to run WoodCentral haven't changed one little bit, Steve. Since those bills don't come to your mailbox, your rant is a bit disingenuous. If the Sorby commercial on their own website or video site makes a valid point during the presentation, note where in the video it occurs and post a link with directions on how to access it like "good/bad point regarding HHS and carbide at 3:56 on the video at www***** "
Since you clearly use and enjoy WoodCentral, you might, at the very least, have cleared your post with Ellis. Unless, of course, the World of Common Courtesy has changed as well.
You are missing the point
Steven Antonucci
So, from now on, if anyone wants to post a link to a video, they should ask Ellis first because it might contain a product or information about the product from some company that doesn't advertise with WoodCentral? Aside from being completely impossible to enforce, it's detrimental to the community.
Sure, Ellis makes a living selling ads to run the site, but he can only do that if he has a community to offer his advertisers. If someone makes a point about carbide vs. HSS, and it offers a balanced and constructive POV to his community, don't you think it provides WoodCentral advertisers a competitive advantage? Sorby may have made the point about carbide, but people at WoodCentral know Mike Hunter. Do you think they try to find somewhere that carries the Sorby tool, or do they reach out to Mike at his e-mail address next to his name in his last post here because he is "one of us?"
There is a saying that the incoming tide raises all boats. In advertising, if I am the only one selling a product, odds are I need to evangelize. If there is competition, then there is a market. Would you rather have 100% of a small market or 50% of a big market? The people with the audiences sell ads, and you only have an audience if you provide valuable content. Unless you are offering to shoot a video on Carbide vs. HSS tools with approved WoodCentral sponsors, I'd accept the free infommercial for what it was- FREE, and on point.
Steve
Yabut...
Steven Antonucci
If you have ever seen Japanese kokeshi turned, his rest is way far back and hand is in between the rest and the spinning workpiece...
skinned cats...
s
Es verdad.....
Mike Stafford
....but he is turning on a 2" diameter object.
I would never want to teach either of those techniques to new turners who are going to mount large unbalanced bowl blanks on a lathe.
Then again, I would never teach people to use a saw on a piece of wood on the lathe while it is running but I learned recently that this is a common practice among the turners on WC.
***Commercial posts***
Ellis Walentine
Steve, I appreciate your wanting to share that bit of content with the rest of us, and I also appreciate Mark's concerns for WoodCentral's economic well-being. What it comes down to is this, and I will appreciate everyone's understanding and cooperation on this. One of our only ironclad policies here is "no commercial posts," and we take it very seriously. I depend on advertising revenue to keep the lights on, to use Mark's metaphor. It just isn't fair to our paying advertisers if we allow competing companies to flog their stuff here, whether directly or by proxy. I know that Steve is not a shill for Sorby, and I know he had only innocent motives in posting this video; but, no matter how you cloak or reconcile the video, it is a 14-minute commercial, first and foremost, for Sorby.
I regret that I was tied up yesterday and unable to deal with this in a more timely manner. Now that the horse is out of the barn and we've had some good discussions already, I am in the process of editing Steve's initial post to include a link to the YouTube video, in case anyone wants to follow the link and see for themselves what Steve wants to share with other members. In the future, though, I would appreciate it if we could find a better way to direct people to this sort of content than actually embedding commercials here on the messageboard. This is a tough call for me, as I don't want to discourage or alienate Steve, nor do I want to suddenly allow commercials to be posted here after 14 years without them, regardless of how sensible it may seem.
This is kinda no-win for me, but I absolutely owe it to my advertisers and to the forum to enforce our rule.
Ellis
Re: Some nuggets of wisdom in this infommercial
Jerry Klug
My experience is nowhere near Steve or Mark so I watched the video with another slant. The size and bulk of the tool seemed to me to require a large space between the work and the tool rest. The tool bulk allows greater reach but why not use a Hunter with a smooth shaft right up to the cutter mount and still maintain a close tool rest. I try to minimize the over rest reach as I was taught to eliminate the torque of the cut pressure and vibration.
"Mr. Sorby" Lost Me
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
about 3 minutes in when he started with the BS/Urban myth about what steel is "sharper" including that lame attempt at drawing metal crystals that is completely superfluous. I saw that, I didn't need to go any further for pearls (or nuggets) of information.
Re: "Mr. Sorby" Lost Me
Dale Miner
I bailed when he did the finger wipe of the representation of the TiN coating. The part about only the top of the tool wears made me reach for the BS repellant.
Re: "Mr. Sorby" Lost Me
Dick Coers
What's wrong with his theory? I don't cut with the bevel on my scrapers. Maybe a burr?
Re: "Mr. Sorby" Lost Me
John Lucas
I can't say for sure because I don't have the microphotographs to verify but the new "nano" or micrograin carbide cutters get awfully sharp. I have some metal lathe cutters that will shave hair and the Hunter cutters are extremely sharp. It could be true that HSS will get sharper and for hand carving that's probably necessary. No actually that is necessary which is why all of my hand carving tools are carbon steel. Will HSS get as sharp as the carbon steel. I'm not sure but my skews will easily shave hair and I spent extra time on my Thompson skew one time to prove it would sharpen and I the hairs jumped off my arm rather than be cut by that thing.
As far as the Titanium coating. I think it actually does work but don't know how well. I've drilled a lot of holes in steel using both non coated and coated and not being a scientific test I feel that the titanium coated ones actually did stay sharp longer.
Stop
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
John, you've enough metals experience to know that the sharpness of the edge is determined by the abrasive, not the alloy. If you grind with a 200 grit wheel, it will give you a 200 grit edge, unless, of course, the material is harder than the abrasive. In the scheme of things, razors, stropped to say 2,500 grit, are relatively dull when you consider that some things are ground to 5-10,000 grit-size edges.
If you want gauge a particular alloy's potential for sharpening based upon the the size of its molecular structure, then yes, carbon steel, with its extremely fine crystalline structure, can be sharpened to a finer edge that so ASP 2060 powdered metal or carbide. But no turner will have or ever need the equipment to hone to such ridiculous fineness.
I sharpen my turning PM gouges on a 180 CBN wheel, and then remove the slight burr with a couple of swipes of a hard arkansas slip along the interior of the flutes. Those edges will shave you quite nicely.
UNSAFE is unsafe.....
Rob Wallace
Steve:
The kokeshi turner's tool rest obviously is moveable, and does not present a significant pinch hazard as does the Sorby turner's fixed metal tool rest that is about a finger's thickness from the rotating work. Even considering kokeshi turners work in this manner does not reduce or eliminate the dangerous condition shown in the Sorby video. Comparing apples and oranges - definitely NOT the same situation, and I don't consider the kokeshi example as relevant here to argue that the Sorby guy's technique is OK. It is not.
I can only imagine this guy getting a catch that either throws the gouge across the tool rest and into his fingers dangling between it and the rotating blank, resulting in a metal to metal (gouge against rest) shear effect right into (or even through) his fingers, or getting a catch or dismounted blank that might otherwise crush his fingers (or worse) against the tool rest. Whether using this 'finger dangle' position is just laziness or lack of concern for what might happen, this should NOT be shown in a video that might be emulated by novice or other turners.
There is ABSOLUTELY NO REASON to have fingers ahead of the tool rest and between it and the rotating work. Period. The pinch danger is far too high to consider this as any form of acceptable woodturning technique.
This shouldn't really be a "yabut" response; it actually should be a "Holy crap, I can't believe the guy is turning like that!" reaction.
Rob Wallace
The rest is 4" away...
Steven Antonucci
While it isn't something I would do, it's not because of safety. If you watch the video, the rest is a good 4" away, so there's really no pinch hazard. If I am not mistaken, Japanese turners are know for using ring chucks, a wooden tool rest that it not attached to the lathe at all and they often cut below center.
In the Sorby video, he consistently shows a 4" gap. While levering the tool might seem to be a bad idea, if you've ever watch someone turn on an old wooden treadle lathe, it is pretty common through antiquity:
That said, I agree that this video is not the best technique, but it's not dangerous...
Steve