Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

Posts

First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

#1

First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

ILYA Z

Hello All,

I've been turning bowls for a few years but have never done a single spindle project. A friend of mine asked me if I could make a set of pieces for a Russian game called Gorodki. If you click on the attached link you will see a typical set. All the text is in Russian but it shows the pieces in a photo.

A typical set consists of a pair of bats and a set of "targets", for lack of a better word. These targets are simple cylindrical pieces that are 20 X 4.5 cm (~ 7.9" X 1.8"), and you make simple shapes by stacking them in different ways. The object of the game is basically to hit these shapes by the bats from a distance. The bats are tapered conical shapes 90 cm in length and with end diameters 3.5 and 3cm (~ 35" X 1.2"-1.4").

These pieces are pretty simple so I am thinking of making this a spindle learning project. I have some questions:

1. What's the minimal set of gauges I need to turn these?

2. The pieces in the photo are made of oak. I presume I should pick that or another type of hardwood rather than pine or something similar that's soft. Other than maple, what other common wood types would you choose? Do you think poplar would be too soft?

3. Do you think for a novice like me, it would be easier to turn each target piece separately, or turn one long one which I would simply later cut into 20cm pieces? Even though the shape is a simple cylinder, I do need the targets to be the same size.

4. Looks like the most complicated part are the long tapered bats. Is there a good resource online that would describe how to turn these?

Thanks much!


Set of bats and targets

Re: First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

#2

Re: First spindle project: some questions

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

An interesting topic. Is your lathe capable of holding between centers wood that is 90 cm. That is a VERY big lathe. Make some guages out of thin plywood for each diameter, similar to end wrench ends. Use good, kiln-dried stock that should not warp after it is turned. Hickory or ash would be a good choice. Cut tapers by using a parting tool to establish the depth of cut. Do several cuts of several inches space apart. You might need to scale this down depending on your lathe bed length.

Re: First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

#3

Re: First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

David Walser

I'll try to address each of your questions in turn:

1. What's the minimal set of gauges I need to turn these? A parting tool and a spindle roughing gouge should be able to handle these simple shapes. I'd recommend a spindle roughing gouge about 3/4" in size. (I've included a link to an example of the type of gouge I mean.) The gouges are available from a number of vendors at a variety of price points. A 3/4" skew would (in the right hands) leave a better finish than that obtained from a spindle roughing gouge, but a spindle roughing gouge will give you a very good finish if you're careful. After sanding, no one would be able to tell the difference.

2. The pieces in the photo are made of oak. I presume I should pick that or another type of hardwood rather than pine or something similar that's soft. Other than maple, what other common wood types would you choose? Do you think poplar would be too soft? I think poplar would be too soft as would pine or fir. I'd suggest, in addition to red oak and maple, white oak and ash. All are readily available at reasonable prices. I would assume that it would be acceptable to glue up blanks of appropriate thickness. This would let you use generally less expensive thinner stock.

3. Do you think for a novice like me, it would be easier to turn each target piece separately, or turn one long one which I would simply later cut into 20cm pieces? Even though the shape is a simple cylinder, I do need the targets to be the same size. A lot depends on the size of your lathe. It might be simpler and easier to do two or three at a time. A simple cylinder (as opposed to a taper) is not too difficult to obtain as long as you have a good set of calipers and remember to measure often.

4. Looks like the most complicated part are the long tapered bats. Is there a good resource online that would describe how to turn these? The AAW, as part of their FUNdamentals program has a brief video showing how to turn tapers and cylinders. If you are an AAW member (or know a member who will let you see the videos on the member's computer), the videos should get you started.

If not, do as was suggested in the prior response. After you've turned your blank round, carefully lay out the dimensions of the bat. Mark the center and end points of the bat with a pencil. Mark several points in between the center and end points with a pencil. Then, set your calipers for just slightly more than the appropriate diameter at the first of the marked locations (it doesn't matter which one) and use your parting tool to cut the blank down to that diameter -- measuring often. Once the calipers just barely slip over the blank, re-mark that location with a dark pencil line. After you've used the parting tool to set the diameter at each location, use your spindle roughing gouge to "connect the dots" -- being sure to leave your pencil marks at each marked location! After you've connected the dots, you'll have your bat almost completed. It should be just slightly larger than your desired finish diameter along it's full length. A light pass or two along the length of the bat with your spindle roughing gouge and a little sanding should be all that's required (other than cutting the blank to final length) before adding your finish of choice.

Good luck!


Spindle Roughing Gouge

Re: First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

#4

Re: First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

Bob Macgregor

I'd never heard of this, but found a somewhat more complete description, including some construction/materials info, via Google search:

BOB


http://www.google.ca/imgres?imgurl=http://www.strangelove.net/~kieser/Russia/RussianImages/gorodki-photo_tn.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.strangelove.net/~kieser/Russia/gorodki.html&h=300&w=400&sz=32&tbnid=IGyGr8KHMN5VmM:&tbnh=90&tbnw=120&prev=/search%3Fq

Re: First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

#5

Re: First spindle project: some questions

ILYA Z

Hi Bill,

How would oak compare to ash/hickory? Asking since I have a lot of scrap oak in my basement so was planning to use it.

Thanks!

Re: First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

#6

Re: First spindle project: some questions

ILYA Z

Hi David,

Thanks for all the details. I used to be an AAW member, not anymore, but I do know some fellow turners who are so I might ask them.

What type of finish would you apply? I don't think I want to make the targets too smooth since then I think it would be hard to stack them in different ways. But bats are different since people will actually be holding them.

Re: First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

#7

Re: First spindle project: some questions

ILYA Z

Hi Bob,

Thanks for the link. I played this game once many many years ago but did not remember much about it.

Looks like this confirms that pine is no good for this purpose. I was planning to use oak since I have a lot of oak scraps.

Re: First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

#8

Re: First spindle project: some questions

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Oak would be fine. I do not like to turn oak. It throws Sharp splinters and is hard to get a really smooth finish

Re: First spindle project: some questions *LINK*

#9

Re: First spindle project: some questions

David Walser

What type of finish would you apply? If you use your scrap oak, I'd use a sanding sealer to fill the pores and, after sanding back the sealer to bare wood, I'd use an oil finish such as boiled linseed oil or walnut oil. A film finish, like shellac, lacquer, or polyurethane, will show the wear from the pieces banging against each other.