Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Hairline Box

Posts

Hairline Box

#1

Hairline Box

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Since I've got several pieces of dogwood, I decided I'd try to do a box with a hairline joint. I wanted to preserve as much of a grain match as I could, so instead of the parting tool, I put a #2 blade in one of my jeweler's saw frames, slowed the lathe down to about 15 rpm in reverse, and carefully cut through for this.


Didn't consider, however, how I was going to hollow the cap as, at 2" diameter, it wouldn't fit in my extended chuck jaws. I thought about making a donut chuck, but wasn't happy with the lack of ability to gauge thickness. Reading John Lucas's post on his gun rack provided the answer however (thanks John) when he mentioned hot-melt glue. I thus turned a small chunk on a faceplate with a depression, centered the cap to run true with the tailstock engaged, and hot-glued the cap in place.


It was then simple to hollow the cap to 1/8".

I needed a retention ring to hold the cap on so I turned a piece with diameter to fit into the cap, parted off about 1", and glued it into the cap still in the hot-glue mounting


It was a simple matter to hollow through the block and trim the ring to fit. I then put the pieces together using the tailstock and a pressure block and returned and sanded the outside surface to match up both pieces.

My first-attempt hair line isn't perfect

But it's pretty close

Piece is 9" tall by 2". Comments are welcome.

Re: Hairline Box

#2

Don Leydens

Re: Hairline Box

Don Leydens

Great job, Mark! Thanks for the info and the step-by-step. Somewhere, I see Mike Stafford smiling. Well done.

Re: Hairline Box

#3

Re: Hairline Box

John Lucas

Mark I have not used a jewelers saw. That would definitely give a smaller kerf but I would probably break a couple of blades doing that. I use a thin kerf tool I made from a drywall saw that I purchased at the flea mkt for $1. I've also used butter knifes.

the procedure I use is safe, doesn't burn the tool and gives me about the thinnest part line I can. What I do is make a shallow cut, maybe 1/4" deep or less. Then I use this cut as a sort of fulcrum or pivot area. I make a cut to the left and then one to the right as I go deeper and deeper. Each time using the first cut as my pivot point. This gives me enough clearance to make the cuts cleanly and safely While leaving the outside area that will be the outside of my box with as thin a kerf as the blade is thick.

Re: Hairline Box

#4

Thanx.  Wish

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I could find some bigger dogwood. Love to turn the stuff and it's great for exercise pieces like this box, but I'm tired of the funky center coloration in what I have. :\

[Note to self, add dogwood to the tree service watch list.]

Re: Hairline Box

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: Hairline Box

Mike Stafford

A great looking box Mark. Expect some problems over time with the alignment at the join as the top and the bottom contract and expand differently. A hairline joint looks great but it will become very visible to the eye and to touch as time progresses. The larger the diameter the wood all the more so.

That is a different way to turn a box but you got it done and like Larry always says, "Git 'er done!"

Re: Hairline Box

#6

Beginner's Luck

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I waxed the blade (bee's) and didn't break it, but it was slow going.

I could probably have used a hacksaw blade as well since the cut depth was only an inch. Have you ever tried one of those no-set pull saws?

Re: Hairline Box

#7

It's Wood, Right?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

It's gotta move. Hell, even metal expands and contracts. This was mostly a skill building / problem solving exercise piece along that path we call "self-taught". I'll probably put it on my desk to hold paper clips.

Curious as to how a box-meister like yourself would have turned it ? ou can e-mail me if it's too long to post here. I just makin' stuff up as I go along :D

Re: Hairline Box

#8

Re: It's Wood, Right?

John Lucas

Mark it's been my experience that yes the wood does move but as long as you make it an endgrain box and align the grain the way you did the lid and bottom will move at the same rate. The only thing I've had happen is the box might become very slightly oval so the lid only fits in one orientaton, but then that's fine because you want those grain lines to stay aligned anyway.

Re: Hairline Box

#9

Mike Stafford

Re: It's Wood, Right?

Mike Stafford

Mount the wood between centers, round up, tenon on each end, parting cut with thin tool finished at bandsaw.

Lid on lathe, hollow and form square flange, sand and finish.

Body on lathe, tenon for lid to barely fit, hollow body and finish.

Adjust tenon for lid to jam fit, turn exterior as a unit, shape lid, finish. Adjust tenon for slip fit.

Reverse body of jam chuck, turn bottom, sand and finish.

Voile'.

You turned the tenon on the lid and there is nothing wrong with that. And, you are correct, wood will move but box purists like to disguise that fact as much as possible. Some designs disguise better than others but with the hairline joint it is more likely to highlight the "out of roundness" at the join than most other methods.

It matters not to most people except box purists and other turners. I have turned quite a few hairline joint box joints because the grain demanded it. I have even parted it much like you did and instead of turning a tenon I formed a tenon on another piece of wood and inserted into the hollowed box so the grain loss was at the ultimate minimum.

Re: Hairline Box

#10

Movement

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hi, John,

Yeah, that's kind of what I expected as the piece is end-grain, centered on the pith, and the retention ring is cut, likewise, from the neighboring section of the trunk. I pretty much matched its radial position to the other two. Dogwood's pretty stable as well.

I'd be interested to hear how others here, including Mike, would have turned this box. Obviously, I left the bottom portion on the original block and parted that off as the last operation, but alternatives on "my" method on the cap would be interesting to me, if not other readers.

Re: Hairline Box

#11

Re: It's Wood, Right?

John Lucas

I essentially do the same as Mike. I also try to hide the hairline with other details if I can. I have however done quite a few with the hairline obvious. As Mike said customers don't care. In fact it sort of tells them it's a lidded box. If the line is disguised well enough and it doesn't obviously look like a box then they don't even pick them up.

Re: Hairline Box

#12

Ah, Ha!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

So it seems I diverted from your work-flow by actually finishing off the top of the cap as part of the first turning. You leave both sections on the tenons through hollowing, right? Does that create issues with thickness gauging?

I take it you would have waited to finish the crown of the cap/lid until your put the parts back together after hollowing both parts, yes? That makes sense, although I personally like to be able to see the entire final shape of the piece before I commit to the parting cut; I do my ginger jars the that way, but leave extra to trim off for the tenon ring.

Thanks

Re: Hairline Box

#13

Ah, Ha No. 2

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

"Customers" may be a key word here. Since I don't sell stuff (give it away instead), I don't GARA about "customer preferences". Several local galleries have inquired about handling my stuff. I just don't want to go there; maybe when/if I hit 75 :D

Re: Hairline Box

#14

Steven Antonucci

A good thin parting tool- Xacto razor saw

Steven Antonucci

Running slowly, in small diameter, you can cut all the way through...

Steve

Re: Hairline Box

#15

Mike Stafford

Re: Ah, Ha!

Mike Stafford

No, I use a homemade depth gauge to judge the lid thickness. I always leave the lid and bottom a little thicker than the sides because my experience has been, depending upon shape of the box, that the end grain is more fragile. I lost a few boxes to clumsy customers when I used to turn the lid and bottom as thin as the sides. The short end grain can break pretty easily.

True confessions....I have to admit to turning through a couple of lids and bodies because I poorly judged the depth. :( Even snatched the bottom right out of box during a demo once because it was thinner than I thought. You know what happens don't you....well it has happened to me more than once. I am truly a student of hard knocks.

Yes, I always turn the lid to final shape with it mounted on the body. That way I get my proportions the way I want them and I can make adjustments in diameter and height. But when you have turned as many boxes as I have you begin to get a feel for the sound and thickness. As Jamie Donaldson once told me, after a while your fingers get calibrated. Mine are reasonably well calibrated at this point on most box forms.

Re: Hairline Box

#16

Mike Stafford

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Hairline Box

#17

Re: Hairline Box

mjonesrdg

Mark has fashioned what I call a "3 piece box", where his tenon (for the lid to fit over) is a separate piece. The value of using a thin kerf saw to part the body from his lid would otherwise be somewhat lost when the tenon is then cut from the body of the box. With 'traditional' cut-from-the-body tenons, grain matching looks good on one side, but not around the entire circumference. Unless, of course, the grain is absolutely straight and vertical.

I would not discourage anyone from pursuing this method to achieve better grain alignment. As for wood movement, I can see no reason to expect lid fit to suffer any differently with this method than any other, and it even makes more sense that the tenon cut from the same wood, but non-matching grain would lend to the integrity and endurance of the fit.

While I prefer very dense wood for making turned boxes, even his dogwood, if dried to equilibrium and well sealed, should make for a long lived box.

Re: Hairline Box

#18

There is also the option/necessity...

JamieDonaldson

..of adding a round of masking tape at the join to hold the top to the bottom, once the final lid fit has been achieved, or not! ;) I have one of those "oriental" design pull saws with a thin blade that works like a champ for making the top cut-off where a thin kerf parting tool won't or shouldn't go.

Re: Hairline Box

#19

Re: Beginner's Luck *LINK*

David Walser

Mark,

I use a hacksaw, with a heavy frame, for making such cuts. I do it on the lathe. With the blank mounted in a chuck and no tailstock support, I start by making a small v-cut with a skew -- just so the blade will not wander. Then, with the lathe speed fairly slow (500 rpm?), I make the cut using the hacksaw. The hacksaw makes a very thin, accurate, cut.

I thought I'd come up with something new until I saw Alan Lacer do it at the Desert Woodturning Roundup a few years ago. (Tickets for next February's DWR are now on sale. What could be nicer than spending three days with a bunch of turners in Mesa, Arizona, next February? Beats shoveling snow!)

I've tried using a small Japanese style handsaw. I don't recommend it. The saw, at least my version of it, was too flexible. It wandered within the cut. One end of the cut blank had a slight crown and the other was undercut slightly. (By the time I faced off both ends so they were flat, I would have been better off using a thin parting tool.) It was an interesting effect, but not one I'd be confident I could reproduce. Besides, it felt like the blade was starting to bind in the kerf -- which could have had bad consequences if the saw were to have been pulled out of my hand and started spinning at 500 rpm only to be thrown who knows where!

Anyway, I endorse the hacksaw method, not the thin pull saw method.


2013 DWR

Re: Hairline Box

#20

Oh, darn!

David Walser

I certainly wish I'd read the entire thread before posting my response, above -- in which I recommend using a hacksaw with the lathe on. Please ignore my advice. (Pretend like you are one of my children. It'll make ignoring my advice feel natural.)

Re: Hairline Box

#21

Re: Hairline Box

Bob Herrman

Mike what finish did you use?

Re: Hairline Box

#22

Hair Spray

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Actually, Bob, it's three light applications of Krylon Matte (discussed below) which is almost the same thing Memsahib puts on her head. I also took Jamie's suggestion and tried some TransTint dye on a little brush to kill the yellow decay spots in the heartwood; marginally effective on this hard wood. Lastly, buffed with 4-0 steel wool. You'll find the same finish (without the dye) on a lot of John Jordan's pieces. Simple and very "close to the wood."

Mark

Re: Hairline Box

#23

Re: Hair Spray

John Lucas

John Jordan is the one who put me onto the Krylon Fixatif. It doesn't change the color of most woods and is still hard enough to buff out. Works really great on the textured surfaces John uses.

Re: Hairline Box

#24

A Word of Caution

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Because of its solvent's exceptionally fast evaporation rate, Krylon is pretty sensitive to humidity being trapped between coats. As an application flashes off its solvent it cools the surface. In warm humid Summer air, that will condense some water vapor that, if you recoat too soon, will haze the next coat making you cut it back. Use light coats and let each application sit for a good 20-30 minutes to allow it to warm up a bit to prevent the problem.

Re: Hairline Box

#25

Steven Antonucci

A picture of the saw

Steven Antonucci

I saw Mike Stafford's note about the danger of running a saw blade on a spinning lathe, and I concur on many types of saws, but the Xacto is a little different.

Here is a picture:


Running the lathe slowly, the saw blade is 13/1000" thick and only 1/2" wide below the reinforcing back. I have another one that is a little wide (maybe 3/4"?). If I dragged it across my hand, it wouldn't even leave a red mark. If you try to part with it and the lathe is running too fast, it smokes in the cut from the friction on the sides of the blade. Of course, it is only useful on very small diameter pieces, since you wouldn't be able to cut through anything larger than 2X the width of the blade.

Tha said, like all things "shop" ... what I can do and what you can do may vary. Use your head.

steve