Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

Posts

Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#1

Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

jake Niedling

I generally use Wipe-on poly, Deft lacquer and occassionly Watco Danish oil. I have several spalted birch pieces that I need to apply a finish to and want to minimized the amount of darkening or yellowing. So I just thought I would get some input from the WoodCentral-group-pedia. Look forward to your comments.

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#2

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

Jim Breeden

Just finished a Wester Red Cedar platter, and used Watco Natural. The Pink center turned to a dark red, and the outer edge went from cream to light tan.

Frustrating ! :\ Next time (?) I'll be using unwaxed shellac. Tried the shellac on a piece of cedar I have ready to turn, and it turned darker pink, but when the shellac dried it returned to it's original color. So.....maybe.

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#3

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

John Lucas

I would try bleaching it first and then apply a finish. The bleach usually only changes the lighter areas. If you bleach it enough the yellowing of finishes don't change it as much.

As for finishes Lacquer or wipe on poly seems to change it the least. Krylon Fixatif changes things less than any finish I've tried.

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#4

Two Steps

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

1. Sealer. Krylon matte (fixitif) is very close to water clear and makes a very good base sealer. So good, in fact, that I know some turners who use it as their finish with nothing more.

An alternative would be to mix dewaxed Ultra Pale shellac to use as a sanding sealer.

2. Finish. One of the waterborne acrylic lacquers like General's Enduro Lacquer or Target's Emtech 6000 will give you water-clear results. Keep in mind, however, that applying any gloss finish may seem to darken the wood a bit because of the light refraction in the coating.

This is a set of small urns I did in Big leaf Maple burl using the 2-step described.


While they were dyed, of course, the finish is Enduro Clear Poly. As you can see, the deep blue has not been "pushed" by any ambering in the coatings.

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#5

1 Step

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

This is a spalted wormy maple burl jar (about 7x10") done with just the Krylon matte. Other than an increase in contrast in the spalted areas, the color is the original color of the wood.


Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#6

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

Carole Valentine

Hit it first with a quick wash of thinned lacquer (Deft is fine) ...wipe it on and wipe it dry immediately. Then use your regular finish ( I use Waterlox Original). I use this on all light woods that I want to keep light, especially if they have some spalt or a bit of punk in them. I thin the lacquer at least 50%. Try it on a scrap. Sometimes I bleach first on certain woods, but don't bleach Ambrosia maple...it turns the ambrosia an ugly color in my opinion. Bleach does not affect the black spalt lines.

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#7

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

Barry L Elder

Most of the local pros use Deft Lacquer and in the oils, Tung Oil seems to darken the least of all.

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#8

Phil Stivers

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

Phil Stivers

To help keep the wood from darkening, you'll need to plug up the straws we call end grain. Using deft or cellulose sanding sealer, wipe and allow to dry. Sand the surface back to wood then apply your oil or polly. The color change will be lessened. On the punky woods in the spalted area the deft will also help seal those softer, more porous areas.

In the pictures below, I sealed the walnut with cellulose sanding sealer then applied two coats of tung oil. The color stayed lighter with no end grain "blackening".



Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#9

Sealers @ Finish

Jim Breeden

I've used all those sealers. Some I like, some I don't. They're all lined up across my workbench like spit cups in a rednecks"s pickup. :b I used the Watco on the cedar to slown down the cracking process while I was turning, which was probably a mistake, as the color changed. Next time........ ?

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#10

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

Bill Jacksonville, NC

If do not want any yellowing try a quart of Rust-Oleum Clear Polyurethane. Picked up a quart of gloss at Lowes have not tried yet. They also sell matt and semi gloss too. Price is right and with proper technique will not have a plastic look & feel.

Other waterborne finishes will also not yellow, decided to pick up a quart after some good reviews on another finishing site.

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#11

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

phillip medghalchi

"Sometimes I bleach first on certain woods"

Carolle, when you say you bleach the wood. do you dunk it in the bleach or you wipe it on. the reason I am asking is that I am currently working on some Texas pecan pieces and the problem I have is that they seem to break off while working them on the lathe then i have to resort to find the pieces and CA glue them together and then try to fill them with a dark brown wood dust in order to blend in the mended part. However, my wife has told me that she likes the natural bony color of pecan and since in the past I have tried to finish my utilitarian bowls with Generals salad bowl finsih it turn them into darker brownish color and in some cases as the bowls sat for a while they turned even darker. I was wondering that your above technique would work on these pecans or was it that General finish's salad bowl finish is known to darken the wood anyways? Also, I wonder if I bleach the pecan since it is spalted I end up with some ugly looking piece? I like to learn more about this if it is possible. I hope I am hijacking this thread, but it is in line with what I was doing?

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#12

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

Bernie Weishapl

I have started using Water based finishes such as Target Coatings EM 6000 lacquer and EM 9000 poly. Both leave the wood when finished as natural as it was when turned.

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#13

General Finishes Woodturners Finish.


Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#14

Steven Antonucci

Artist Fixative (buy it at Michaels)


Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#15

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

Carole Valentine

I use Kleenstrip ( or whatever it's called) two part wood bleach. It is the only thing that works in my opinion. Follow the directions. I rarely neutralize though. And bleach does not keep an oil finish from darkening...you still have to seal it with lacquer or similar. Don't turn pecan so I can't really help you there. I use bleach on Holly and figured Maple mostly, including Box Elder. On pieces that I want keep really white, such as holly, I either Aqua Shield by Velvit Products or Krylon crystal clear in the spray can. Aqua Shield provides a very hard durable finish and will not change the color of the wood at all. Do not power buff it though. You can contact Barbara Gill ( a WC member) and she can tell you all the specifics for Aqua Shield since she is a distributor.

Re: Finishes - Which one darkens the least!

#16

Thanks for all the great Input...........

jake Niedling

This was an interesting topic. I think I will go with the thin lacquer and also try the Krylon products. I also use the thin lacquer method on a number of things already and am very comfortable with that method. Heard alot about the Kraylon products, just haven't played with them much. I will try it on a couple of other items first. Never really tried the water based finishes like the "Target Coatings EM 6000 lacquer", but sound interesting, if only I could get a sample size to try first before buying a larger quantity. I like to keep it simple and keep it to just a few finishes. Thanks for all the advice. Much appreciated.