Interesting outcome from Gibson/ebony *LINK*
Gibson/Dept of Justice/Lacey Act
Interesting outcome from Gibson/ebony *LINK*
#1
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Interesting outcome from Gibson/ebony *LINK*
Gibson/Dept of Justice/Lacey Act
Lacey Act Question
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Query if anyone here knows what happens to seized logs and lumber? Do they burn it? Chop it up for mulch? What . . . ?
With the trees already cut, it seems such a waste to see the wood destroyed. Seems like there should be something like a government agency established in the countries of origin that can sell the seized material and then use the proceeds for preservation and reforestation.
Re: Lacey Act Question
Dick Coers
I does seem like a waste, but if you don't take the product out of the market, money will still be made on illegal trade, product is made, and the market continues. Consider elephant ivory. The poaching will continue if ivory still has a market. Make it so no one can, or want to purchase ivory products, the market dries up. Sell off siezed illegal ivory to make product, the market continues.
Re: Lacey Act Question
mjonesrdg
Seized property is auctioned off. So, (possibly) Gibson bids and gets it back. The price of Gibson guitars goes up...contributing to inflation. In the future, Gibson will have to buy "finished" fingerboards from Madagascar, and the U.S. will lose a few more jobs.
Re: Lacey Act Question
Malcolm Ray
Wouldn't you also like to know what becomes of "all" the money that is collected in fines and judgments in this country?
G.S.A. Parties & Cooking School?
I'd guess this is the probable answer!
Steven Antonucci
According to what I read, the logs are illegal, but only because they are raw materials. If you make a fingerboard, that might just be enough to get you past the Lacey Act (no idea if the government considers this a finished part nor if there is a way to make a finished fretboard for a guitar without the rest of the guitar).
Tough thing to deal with on a global level. Who is to say that what the US decides has to be world policy? As much as I would like to protect the forests, it's pretty hard to tell a guy that a tree on his land is worth a years' salary, but he cannot cut it for profit...
In any case, it seems that Gibson is admitting some fault here...
Steve
Clarification
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
The Lacey Act makes it a crime to import materials that are embargoed and prohibited for export by the source country, in this case Madagascar which is trying to control illegal logging of its ebony. Madagascar prohibits export of "unfinished" wood products. Fingerboards, being merely components of another product, were defined as "unfinished" and Gibson reps who traveled there were specifically told about this.
Now, if Gibson would like to start building its guitars in Madagascar and/or India, I'm betting they could get lots of legal ebony and rosewood to make them into legal "finished products."
Re: Interesting outcome from Gibson/ebony
Scott Hurley in N VA
As I understand it, the really bad part about cutting ebony is that the only part of the tree that people want is the black part with no streaks. I saw a video about this a couple of months ago (can't remember the link) where they said that only about 1 out of every 20 trees has the streakless black wood. The rest of the trees that are cut are just left to rot. What a waste!
Re: Interesting outcome from Gibson/ebony
dbonertz
This might be the link you are looking for. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=anCGvfsBoFY
It is a very good review from Mr. Taylor. Listen to the whole 13 minutes for it is well worth it.
The above respoinse has a link to follow
Re: Interesting outcome from Gibson/ebony
dick gerard
Thie 13 minute You tube video mentioned above should be REQUIRED viewing by all woodworkers/woodturners in the US. And, whenever the word "ebony" is used, we can substitute any exotic wood that is endangered or threatened due to overharvesting. I have a recurring image of the day after the last tree of a certain species is harvested and some research scientist publishes an article announcing the discovery of an anti-cancer vaccine, or a cure for autism, or Alzheimer's ...
and you guessed it, the only source of that miracle was the last tree harvested.
Could be applied to any natural resource, plant ot animal, that we overexploit. Kill the last giant blue fin tuna only to find that there is an anti-aging chemical found only in tuna that are allowed to grow to a size no longer found in the wild.
We are spposed to be stewards of this earth and all its resources. We all need to refresh or memories of the definition of being a good steward.
"I am the Lorax. I Speak for the Trees!"
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
not to mention the Brown Barbaloots.
Now why in the world did people think that was just a kids' book . . .
Sustainable turning
Steven Antonucci
Would it be fair to suggest that the only way a turner could be responsible is to turn only what they cut? And cut only from already downed trees?
If the market is driven by behavior, removing the demand for the wood should reduce the supply, which will drive up the unit cost making it less accessible to the masses. I think it would be nearly impossible to accurately manage every last tree in the world, regardless of origin or species. We can get fake IDs, and so can trees I'd bet.
So is the real answer in making woodturners not want to turn the exotics and be happy with their local sources? I teach that in my classes on day one...
Steve
Old Principal
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
There is nothing that makes people want something more than telling them they can't have it, and that drives both the price and likelihood of criminal activity ever higher.
I only work local woods that I have personally harvested or gotten because it would have gone to the county dump if I hadn't done so. That M-O is, however, very easy for me to say and do, living here in wood-rich New Jersey with a whole spectrum of hardwoods right outside my door. Not so appealing a concept for folks in Yuma who have a wide choice of cactus to play with 
It's also a hard concept to sell to an impoverished father in Africa or Brazil whose only means to obtain food for his children is to hijack trees for sale and then use the poor forest ground to try to grow yams and such to eat.
Re: Old Principal
Mike Stafford
The best way to guarantee the supply of anything is to establish a reliable market for it.
If enough people want something someone will figure out a way to farm it, grow it and supply it.
Reforestation
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
takes generations to accomplish.
I've seen old photos of my area of New Jersey where the hills, after being clear-cut to provide fuel and charcoal for the mills, looked like pages out of the Lorax. Now I live in a forest with 80' walnut, oak, and hickory and 120' poplars.
We can't grow such trees overnight, and what we plant now may only be harvested by our great great grandchildren. That kind of foresight and willingness to discount the present for the benefit of generations to come is hard to come by among people whose kids are starving.
And the rare hardwoods grow even slower
Re: Interesting outcome from Gibson/ebony
Steve worcester
There are two sides to this I suppose. I have been collecting exotics hardwoods for 15+ years. I have Rosewoods, different Ebonies and who knows what species, and it would be impossible to supply actual proper documentation. But I am not a large corporation that MUST be accountable. Big companies have to check all the boxes and it isn't about being accountable from the world ecology standpoint, but from a government regulation perspective. Doesn't matter left or right, CITES or not, you have to comply regardless of what business you are in. It APPEARS they didn't and got stung (my opinion). The small guy like us don't quantify, but if you are Gibson, you hit the radar, or at least this shipment did.