Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Finial taking over?

Posts

Finial taking over?

#1

Rob Wallace

Finial taking over?

Rob Wallace

Further on Dick Coers' earlier question: What is the function of an elegant finial?

Is it to provide contrast? To provide a different 'line" (vertical element)? To capture the eye and direct it to the 'foundation' element? To give a very different visual perspective? I am not Cindy Drozda, nor do I play her on TV, but I try to approach the addition of this element to accentuate the base's "foundation" form, and hopefully add visual interest; I'm still working on trying to achieve that balance that Steve mentioned.

The images below show a piece I recently finished that I entered into the Iowa State Fair "Woodworking - Turned Items" division for judging. It got a "wow" from one of the staff there when I dropped it off yesterday, and I wonder if it is the finial they see first, or the combination/whole 'gestalt' of the piece.

The base hollow form was turned from a 100+ year old hickory that had to be taken down in one of our city's public parks due to severe wind damage back in 2010. The finial is ebonized hard maple (leather dye & lacquer). The title of the piece reflects my desire to preserve such rare wood resources: 'Vivat Ligna Publica'

Discussion, comment, and critique welcomed.....

Rob Wallace

Vivat Ligna Publica [2012] - Hickory, dyed maple




Re: Finial taking over?

#2

Yeah

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The pot is there as a mere holder for the finial.

Very interesting shape of the finial, but I think your gloss lacquer is doing you a disservice in that it reveals the surface textures. Ebonizing should, in my view, be done to create the look and feel of ebony which is very fine even though it shows pores, yet holds light on the surface.

I think your finial would benefit if you went in one of two directions. A) wool the finish down to a matte sheen or B) build the lacquer to a depth that the wood surface no longer translates through. Risk, however, is that it'll start to look like plastic. :(

Nice turning on the hickory BTW ;)

Re: Finial taking over?

#3

Dale Jablonski

Re: Finial taking over?

Dale Jablonski

I think the hollow form is diminished by the enormity of the finial. (My opinion obviously) The form of the finial is spectacular...great job!

Re: Finial taking over?

#4

Rob,

GaryG in MD

That's obviously very impressive, and it is what it is -- a beautiful piece of wood art. Great idea and execution. Can it be "improved" -- well, there are other ways it could be done...

If I were to try to "copy" it, I think I would eliminate the whole spike and convert the "chocolate kiss" part above the splash into a smaller, spherical "drop" like we see in stop-action photos of a water splash from a single drop of water. Take your hand and hold over the image and see if you can picture my idea.

That's the nice thing about woodturning -- your first ideas are often good, yet refinements can be made in further editions of a series.

Have fun with it! ...Gary

Re: Finial taking over?

#5

Re: Finial taking over?

John Lucas

Rob This is really interesting. I think I like the idea that the hollow form is almost a base for the finial rather than the finial being a sort of top for the hollow form. I think that is some of what you were discussing below about the finials taking over. Perhaps someone could do a piece where the finial was eating the hollow form like it was totally taking over. :)

The base is a pretty bland wood so it needs something to set it off the larger than life finial does that.

I assume from the small line that the bottom flower portion of the finial was turned separate from the top part. I would have liked to see the line hidden better by being at a joint between two elements.

Over all I like the piece very much and think it's pretty successful.

Re: Finial taking over?

#6

Re: Finial taking over?

matt overton

Rob, I agree with the WOW reaction. It is a unique piece and I like it. I agree the finial is taking over, however. I hear Jimmy Clewes saying "is that the only way to do it, Mate?" How else COULD you improve it in your estimation?... I think the beauty of the design is the 'flower'. To me, the lines in the transition from the flower to the rest of the finial are lost in blackness. I'd like to see the 'flower' part in a compimentary wood, it might set it off, or not.

Re: Finial taking over?

#7

Ellis Walentine

Couple thoughts on this

Ellis Walentine

Hi Rob, and thanks for posting this piece for discussion. I tend to think of finials more in terms of the reaction they produce in the viewer. Like a crown molding or a pediment on top of a piece of furniture, a finial, to me, is there to create a dynamic sense of soaring and motion, by drawing the eye from the base form upwards. I think your piece could have worked better if the base form were shaped in a way that initiated and complimented that upward visual thrust instead of curving back over on itself. Also, despite the virtuosity and good intention of the "crown" element at the base of the finial, I feel that it interrupts the flow and progression of this visual sweep.

I'm not sure what the best proportion is between the height of the finial and the height of the base element, but this finial does appear to be somewhat tall for the vessel. That is not a firm conviction, but more of a feeling.

I've been chewing on these issues a lot in the past few months. I'll be interested to hear other's views on this.

Ellis

Re: Finial taking over?

#8

Re: Finial taking over?

Mike in Southern New Jersey

Hi Rob,

Thanks for your post. I love seeing other's work. You and I are thinking the same way on this topic, my friend. Its tough to be critical of your own work when the work is so technically well done, but you've done everyone a great service with your post, in my opinion.

I have to admit that, usually, I pass right by a post on the board about a "piece with a finial" because it seems to me that the trend for some time has become that the actual piece that was supposed to be the main effort of the turning........ has evolved into a lowly "stand"...... for displaying the finial. The fact that you questioned your finial's purpose caught my attention, and made me read your post and the other posts here.

I liken your design question to the same thoughts that I've noticed with some diamond engagement ring mountings that I've seen over the years. The ring, which is supposed to be the important thing with its symbolism, is oftentimes just a "technique" to attach a huge diamond to your finger so that you don't lose it! That's my opinion anyway of some jewelry design.

I really appreciate a well designed ring that integrates the stone and the band much more. Same goes for finials, at least for me.

Of course there will always be chocolate and vanilla, but thanks for asking for opinions anyway. YMMV, etc, etc. I think that our piece is very nice and well done, and I'd like it more with a finial that is more in scale with the piece.

Best,

Mike

Re: Finial taking over?

#9

Rob Wallace

THANK YOU VERY MUCH......  (long)

Rob Wallace

..... for all the comments and suggestions!!!

I appreciate hearing opinions of other turners, particularly those with a critical eye. I have printed all of your comments and placed them into my "finial research" notebook, and will work to incorporate some of the elements and treatments you suggest in future work.

I agree that the piece is 'finial heavy', as it was intended to be....

The psychology behind this piece is that it was to be submitted to and shown at this year's Iowa State Fair Woodworking Division Judged Entries to compete with other "Turned Items" (broadly defined). When these pieces are judged as a "mass of turnings" (maybe 25-40 pieces or so) all competing with one another, I definitely wanted something that would capture the eye, send the viewer's attention down to the base, and differentiate it as special among a collection of various potentially similar 'round and browns'. I also wanted to combine (and demonstrate skill in) the use of both spindle turning and "faceplate" turning by showing both in one piece. As another feature, I wanted to add something different at the base of the finial to set it off from the somewhat squat base form, so I worked on developing the "crown" (what I call a 'diadem') which, as John observed, was turned separately from the "Drozdaesque" finial.

I have studied the proportions seen on finials applied to various hollow forms by Cindy and many others, and these vary all over the map. I have talked with her over the past few years about this exact issue of finial size and proportion relative to the "base" vessel, whether the vessel is lifted upon a base spindle or not and whether that matters or not, transitions between the base piece and the finial, curve development beneath and above the "onion", adding and delimiting other visual elements in the finial, and other aspects of developing a pleasing "add-on" finial form - but the more I think about it in this context, I am coming down on the side that the base is there to support the finial, rather than the opposite.

I did another "finial heavy" piece last year (...that I entitled "Cindy's Revenge" ! ! - see below) in which I used a spalted maple hollow form base to support about a dozen different finials I turned for it. I continued to swap these out over a period of about 2 weeks until I settled on the one I liked best. The piece was accepted into the Iowa State Fair Fine Art Exhibition last year (2011), and although it was marked 'Not for Sale', I still received two offers, so at least two people liked it enough to ask to buy it.

Some time ago, Charlie Belden posted some diagrams of Cindy's finials on WC, and this got me further along in studying how to make some progress in making my forms better. This is what's so great about Woodcentral, it's that it provides these learning opportunities for those that want to go further....!! (Thanks Charlie!)

I am still not satisfied with my abilities at fitting the finial to the piece, and vice versa and will plug along and continue to search for that elusive "perfect" combination of finial and base form. Thanks for your help along the way!

Rob Wallace

Cindy's Revenge - 2011

Spalted maple form; dyed maple finial; lacquer


Re: Finial taking over?

#10

Re: Couple thoughts on this

bill crommett

It all depends n what your objective is. Are you after symmetry,balance, or adhering to artistic standards.

I personally think the tall finial is spectacular and forget about formulas.