Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Good accident video *LINK*

Posts

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#2

Re: Good accident video

Jim Breeden

I always wear my face shield, ever since I got splattered with CA ! :b

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#3

Re: Good accident video

George Guadiane

This video should be MANDATORY for all turners!

Imagine that turned out to be a good day - everyone/everything but the bowl survived AND we have a scary teaching/learning moment.

Even in slow motion, even knowing it was going to happen, even knowing that he was going to be all right, I felt that sphincter tightening that comes with impending disaster.

Most of us (if we've been turning any length of time) have probably had our "near death experience," but this real time video certainly shows how quickly things can go from great to "near death experience."

Confidence in my knowledge of the wood I am working is not nearly as effective a safety feature as my face shield.

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#4

Dale Jablonski

Re: Good accident video

Dale Jablonski

Excellent and sobering. I agree it should be a "must see". That is why I always wear my face shield. I'm ugly enough!

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#5

Re: Good accident video

Carole Valentine

I have found that type of wood defect several times and each time it was in a crotch piece. I am always especially circumspect when turning crotch wood. You can easily get a void where the two pieces grew together but are not fused in the middle... and you cant always see indications of it.

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#6

Harry Robinette

Re: Good accident video

Harry Robinette

Every club should have a copy of this for all new members to see. We all say wear your face shield but nothing drives it home tell you see it like this. likes been said even knowing whats coming still gave me that neck hair oh my God felling.

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#7

Life's Too Short

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

To turn crappy wood [ John Jordan]

And it can get a lot shorter if you try. [me]

Everyone should take away from this the caution to examine the piece of wood and learn to recognize fatal defects in the piece before they put it on the lathe. He saw the bark inclusion in the crotch, and should have recognized that his piece was actually two, held together by bark and a bit of sap wood.

A wood feather and some curly grain ain't worth dying for, folks. Consider also that if that piece had been spinning a bit faster and if he was in position to true up the rim, that light weight flip-up face shield would not have saved his life.

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#8

Re: Good accident video

Dick Coers

How could he have not seen the defect went all the way through? He must not have shut the lathe off since the beginning, but I always inspect as I turn to look for grain balance, and what is going on. Cheez, sure could have been worse!

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#9

Re: Good accident video

Galen Vetterick

Bad enough to have an accident on the lathe but then to have made a video of it from two different angles! :( I don't need that kind of evidences as a reminder. It generally give me a good enough scare I still have the capacity to remember LONG after mine happen. I have a LOT of examples to flashback to, in more than just turning too.

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#10

Been there, done that. Window replaced.


Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#11

Re: Good accident video

ihmserv

even though the turner didn't get seriously hurt.

Is there such a thing as a good accident?

we have all had close calls. glad this one turned out ok.

IAN

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#12

Re: Good accident video

robo hippy

If I am at all suspicious of the soundness of the piece of wood, I turn much more slowly, and stop to check. I also stand totally out of the line of fire. If he had been directly in that line, instead of a glancing blow, the face shield would have been no help at all, and he would have been in the emergency room at the least. Frequently with crotch pieces, you have the bark inclusion and no sound wood, which guarantees a failure. As soon as he said 'rot' I said 'oh no!' A lot of risk can be eliminated when you identify the problem before you start. Like the quote from Will Rogers, some thing like "There are 3 kinds of men in the world, those who learn by observation, the few who learn by reading, and the rest who have to pee on the electric fence for themselves."

Lesson learned.

robo hippy

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Life's Too Short

Keith Tompkins

Good post, Mark! I've taught classes where people want to turn wood they've brought themselves. Several times I refused to allow pieces to be turned during the class..obvious defects, huge cracks, etc. It seems these defects would be obvious to anyone....but guess what? They're not. That guy was lucky..

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#14

Alan Zenreich

Re: Good accident video

Alan Zenreich

Thanks John for posting this video.

As you know, I'm squarely in the ATGATT (all the gear, all the time) camp of motorcyclist... and I also apply that philosophy to woodturning.

Fortunately, his (quite minimal) protection saved his face from more significant damage.

However, the big takeaway here is not about protective gear... it's about paying more attention to what you're doing, how things are progressing, and if you should continue doing it.

The protective gear is important... but it merely help minimize the consequences of poor (sometimes blink-of-an-eye) decisions and actions.

I'm glad he survived and shared this event.

Now on to figuring out how much of that rot he inhaled... he didn't mention his respiratory protection....

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#15

Steven Antonucci

A problem with YouTube

Steven Antonucci

I have seen a few videos where the person making them is begging for trouble, and I've shared my concern in the comment section. One of the issues with YouTube is that people that post there often aren't looking for help.


I think we all remember the video that from last year where the woman was doing EVERYTHING wrong, and after commenting from WoodCentral expressed concern, she eventually took the video down (I give her credit for realizing that it wasn't something other people needed to see).

In NYC, they run TV ads where a guy leaves a bag on the subway. The warning is "don't assume it was left accidentally". The parting remark is something we should all take to heart:

IF YOU SEE SOMETHING, SAY SOMETHING.

steve

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#16

Re: Good accident video

Jim Breeden

Besides being CA covered at one time: I was turning a burl box elder that had bark inclusion. While turning I heard what I believed to be an electrical short/spark in the shop. I immediately shut off the lathe and everything else I had running, and was looking for/smelling ozone - nothing. After about a minute, I turned the lathe back on - AND POW - the part with the inclusion flew off and hit the wall behind me ! :\ Sure am glad I was standing to the left of the burl when I turned it back on. I did have my face shield on at the time. The only thing I could think of was what I thought was a spark/short was the turning cracked while I was cutting into it. I will always be listening for that sound in the future ! ;)

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#17

Jesper, Denmark

Re: The problem with headlines...

Jesper, Denmark

....is that they can so easily be misunderstood.

I surmise that the intention was: Good video of accident.

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#18

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Good analogy....

Jesper, Denmark

All the safety gear - whether on MC or while WW only reduce the consequences of a mishap.

The primary accident avoidance strategy is still awareness, understanding of the forces involved and having the guts to say: No, this is not safe, I will find another way.

WW safety is easier than MC - you do not have other idiots involved.

Re: Good accident video *LINK*

#19

Good Grief!

Don Orr

It appears he is an experienced turner who misjudged a piece of wood. I give him credit for showing what happened to hopefully help others avoid something similar. I has a piece blow up not long ago that I should not have been working on. I also had my shield on and was out of the way but it was still frightening how loud and fast it was. It sits on a bench as a reminder.

As the sargent on Hill Street Blues always said-be careful out there.