Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

I'm starting to wonder, when does the finial...

Posts

I'm starting to wonder, when does the finial...

#1

I'm starting to wonder, when does the finial...

Dick Coers

I'm starting to wonder, when does the finial take over, or have more visual impact than the vessel? Good/bad? In the new journal, a couple of the vessels had huge pieces of fan coral on them. We also see mini sculptures on top of vessels that are close to the height of the vessel. I have more experience with practical design than art, so would appreciate anyone with formal art training to tell me if visual weight and proportion does not apply here. Oh heck, anyone with an opinion would be welcome too.

Re: I'm starting to wonder, when does the finial...

#2

Re: I'm starting to wonder, when does the finial..

John Veerkamp

What do you intend? Cindy's finials draw the eye. All of those elaborate finials sometimes enhance the piece others are the intention and the base is just support.

Re: I'm starting to wonder, when does the finial...

#3

Steven Antonucci

Finial pieces are hard to do

Steven Antonucci

First, you have to start with a good piece.

Then, you have to make a good finial.

That mates to the good piece and relates in scope, proportion, color, line...

A good finial doesn't mean it goes with the piece it sits on.

A good vessel doesn't always look better with a finial.

Sometimes 1+1=3, but most times 1+1=1.

I'm not sure if there are rules, but you can usually tell when you broke one...

Steve

Re: I'm starting to wonder, when does the finial...

#4

Re: Finial pieces are hard to do

Jim Breeden

Ah Ha ! Now I can stop worrying if I got it right, proportion to proportion.

Re: I'm starting to wonder, when does the finial...

#5

Re: Finial pieces are hard to do

Bill Neddow

Great Explanation, Steve. You have hit the nail on the head! (or maybe it was the finial)