Twice in the last two week, I ordered sanding belts online in the 320 to 800 grits. The first order I received a mixture of CAMI(us - ie 320) and ISO/FEPA (ie P320) Grit designations. When I called to complained they offered a full refund and said it was they same belts they used. Nuf said, Got my refund and won't order from them again.
Ordered from another supplier, received all ISO (ie P320) belts. Neither web site referenced ISO/FEPA (ie P320) grits.
Nick, I can't answer your question but thanks for asking. I never knew this existed let alone was an issue. I thought 320 for example was 320. If anyone else is in the same boat take a look at these two links. They explain the the difference very well.
There is lots of information on the similarities and differences of teh CAMI versus FEPA grading scales available in the Internet. Google is your friend.
I have not thought much about this, but from my flat work days, the american papers do leave scratch marks due to uneven lengths, the european are very regular and more dependable.
I quit using CAMI after I discovered ISO/FEPA sand paper. The CAMI resulted in heavy duty scratch marks in my turnings, no matter what grit I used. Upon switching to ISO/FEPA ( P designation ) the scratch marks disappeared. Until the US mfgs change I will be using Norton, made in Canada. 3M has "tried" to change their system, but to no avail. I still get scratch marks with 3M.
Here is a table I borrowed and added to -- The micron size tells a better story. CAMI and P scales are close in lower numbers but differ a lot as the numbers increase.
I have this in a spreadsheet if you want a table with better alignment
ABRASIVE MICRON SIZE
Norton 3x paper - P120 127
120 paper -CAMI (USA) 116
Norton 3x paper – P180 / CAMI 180 78
Norton 3x paper – P220 65
220 paper – CAMI 60
Norton 3x paper – P320 46
320 paper – CAMI 36
Norton 3x paper – P400 35
3M No-Load – P600 26
Wet/Dry 3M paper – 400 CAMI (USA) 23
Micro Mesh 1500 22.5 22.5
Wet/Dry 3M paper – 600 CAMI 16 16
Micro Mesh 1800 14
Micro Mesh 2400 13
Micro Mesh 3200 12
Beall Tripoli Buffing Compound (EEE compound) 10
Wet/Dry 3M paper – 1000 CAMI 9.2
Wet/Dry 3M paper – 1500 CAMI 8.4
Micro Mesh 3600 7.5 to 8
Wet/Dry 3M paper – 2000 CAMI 6
Micro Mesh 4000 5.5
Novus 2 – 1200 grit (ANSI 1200) 5.5
Beall White Diamond Buffing Compound 5
Micro Mesh 6000 4
Micro Mesh 8000 3
Micro Mesh 12000 2
Micro Mesh gloss – 14000 1
HUT Ultra Gloss – less than one micron less than 1
Green Compound - if only Chromium Oxide as the abrasive. Veritas green honing compound contains larger Aluminum Oxide 0.5
Notes:
Some buffing compounds are a mix of grits and sizes
Not all abrasive papers have the same range of grit sizes.
Tight specs for variation in grits tend to cost more.
There are actually 3 different standards regarding abrasive. Cami is one you mentioned. You do not see this standard much today because most of the manufacturing takes places across the pond. Labor costs are too high in the US. The second is JIS. This is the Japanese standard and again you are seeing less of this standard due to labor cost in the Japanese market. The third is FEPA or (P) standard. This is considered the European standard. The Federation of the European Producers of Abrasives (FEPA) consists of National Associations and European manufacturers of abrasives. Generally what you will see today is the P standard. Also that is why you see many of the abrasive being manufactured in Germany, Switzerland and Finland to name a few. However there are variations in grit tolerances between manufactures that you will want to be aware of. I have seen this first-hand and in some cases what one manufacture called 240 grit seemed closer to 320 or even 400 grit. SO sometimes it is discouraged to switch between manufacturers when sanding such as 80,120 grit with one brand the switch to another for your 150,180 and 220 only to return to the first brand to finish out with 280,320 and 400! I hope this helps and as always please contact me with questions. Thanks, Vince
Vince brings up a point that I've found is important when using abrasives for sanding or sharpening. The various companies grits don't match. I learned this when trying to find a better way to sharpen my edge tools. I found that the only way to know for sure if the scratches left from one grit would be smaller when going to the next highest grit was to stick with the same brand, whether it was sandpaper or sharpening stones. They very quite noticeably sometimes.
Obviously sometimes you have to change when going to the higher grits because they just don't make finer grits in the brand you like. For hand sanding I like the Norton 3X but I can't find it higher than 400 grit. For power sanding I like Vince's discs because I can get them up to 600 grit which is as far as I sand for most projects.
Labor costs are higher in Northern Europe (Germany, Finland) than in the US, so it puzzles me why it should be a problem producing abrasives in this country.
European producers - not only of abrasives - have a much longer time horizon on investments in production equipment to reduce labor costs than is prevalent in the USA. Not so much focus on next quarter's earnings, but more on staying in business long term.
Also, don't forget that there are close countries in the old East Bloc and the south, where labor costs are lower and the work ethic less focused on a 37 hour week and 5 weeks vacation.