Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

Posts

Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#1

Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

charlie belden

As a new turner who'd just bought a little lathe and a few tools, and had some Flat Work scraps around, every time I'd stick a piece of wood on the lathe, grabbed a tool and turned the lathe on - I was dancing with disaster. A few books and a video tape later, I had to dance out a little farther to get to the edge of disaster.

Then I got a chuck and it was a short trip to the edge of disaster. Then I tried doing a hollow form and danced on the edge of disaster with each inside cut/scrape. But a MiniMonster hollowing system move the edge of disaster back a ways

Going for Thin Walls moved the edge of disaster closer, but eventually I had to dance a ways to get to it.

Now I'm doing miniatures and the edge has gotten closer again, though disaster is more like disasterette. If I dance passed the edge there's disappointment, but no bleeding or wall dents. Oddly the concentration is greater, the adrenaline level almost the same as earlier dances with edges.

So what have been YOUR edges? Which ones have you danced off once and only once and stopped dancing in that direction? Which edge did you fall off a few times before you discovered where it ends and disaster begins? Got and Edge of Disaster you're thinking of dancing on? If so care to describe it?

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#2

Ellis Walentine

What an interesting way to put it

Ellis Walentine

I've never conceived of turning in those terms, but it really puts a focus on the risks of learning to do something new. Since so much of lathe turning has to do with proper technique and practice, we are always at some risk of making mistakes. Disaster is a pretty extreme result to contemplate, though. Short of wearing head protection and trying to be as diligent and clever as we can, I don't know that we can ever totally remove that possibility.

For myself, I've had a few really major, potentially life-threatening blowups over the years, but I learned from them all. One had to do with the soundness of the spigot or tenon or whatever you want to call it. If there are any cracks or voids, or if the wood is weak compared to the amount of finesse you intend to apply to the turning, there's a real accident waiting to happen.

I've also had scary episodes with skews and with big scrapers. I think that diligence is the key to using both those tools, as with all tools.

Other than that, I don't usually get so adventurous that I feel I'm skirting the edge of doom.

Ellis

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#3

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

Jeff Rich

My dances were always with bowls when I first started at age 12.

I had no idea what I was doing and ruined a few spindle gouges along the way.

After the teen years and regular work settled into adult life I decided to do things right and learn the "correct" ways of turning. Luckily, I have worked into a somewhat competent turner. I still have issues with scrapers.....

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#4

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

John Lucas

Simply putting yourself into your work is an element of risk. You hope anyone besides yourself enjoys the work. The work or making the work doesn't have to be dangerous as in on the edge of disaster. It's simply trying to express yourself and putting your ego out there that has an element of risk, and maybe disaster.

Now turning this 46" long 14" diameter stave constructed vessel is on the edge of disaster. Since it's a little out of round there is a definite risk that I will go too far when turning this thing and have an odd shaped barrel come off the lathe. You can bet I'll be as careful as I can but there isn't any way to stand out of the line of fire when turning a spindle like this. I will be dancing on the edge of disaster.

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#5

Steven Antonucci

If you want to make an omelette, you are gonna...

Steven Antonucci

break some eggs.

I think one of the simple epiphanies in a turner's development is that failure is part of the process. If you stop treating failure as a finality, and start thinking about it as a part of growth, the world changes.

I tell people that even with my skill level, I still probably lose more pieces than most beginning turners do. However, the ones that make it off the lathe are pretty good pieces because I took that extra cut, went a little thinner, or decided that "Good enough, wasn't."

White Man Overbiting until it hurts...

Steve

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#6

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

Jim Breeden

Has to be the skew. I know how - but - waiting for it is a nervous undertaking. :b

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#7

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

Mike Foster

I seem to flirt with disaster quite a bit. I take it as a matter of course, especially with the minimal surface I have been doing. I am always thinking about ways to hold the wood and turn it in order to achieve the final form I'm after. I've had my share of failures/disasters. I just had a piece fly off of one of my unusual mounts last week while turning it. I was able to re-mount it and get it turned, but had to figure out how to firm it up some. I am well aware of the possibilities, and take care to stand out of the line of fire, and try to keep the tool rest between me and the piece. Like Steve mentioned, I consider failures a part of the process. As long as you are aware of the risks and take care to do things as safely as possible, I think the real risk of injury is quite small.

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#8

Thinking about asking wife about her weight gain


Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#9

Re: Right along with telling her you like

Stuart Johnson

the new frosted look in her hairdo.

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#10

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Sometimes you don't realize the dance has started

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Yesterday, I had finished a finial and put my 1/2 skew on the lathe bed handle outward. Then I moved something else on the lathe bed and accidentally nudged the skew. The skew fell, did a 180 in mid air and skewered my left shin. Result: an inch-long deep gash. End of dance. >(

Dennis

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#11

Not following TS safety rules

Jimmy Edwards

As I took off the blade guard and riving knife I could hear Little Richard and Chuck Berry rocking on out. Hard to "bop" when pushing thru the table saw. Result-amputated my favorite finger.

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

Keith Tompkins

Hi Charlie, I've always danced on the edge..I still ride a motorcycle; I won't say I exceed the speed limits, but a couple of ounces of nitro-propane in the fuel tank does wonders for the top-end! I cannot dance, I've taken a few lessons; I was called aside by the instructor and told "do us both a favor, and don't come back." However, I have a sign by my lathe that simply says "dance". My work on the lathe is my way of dancing, some having titles such as "Tango" and "Merengue". I push myself to the limits on the lathe, sometimes beyond...Sadly, my long-term marriage has come to an end; one reason you haven't seen much of me on the turning sites. On the bright side, I have a new lady friend who is an actor and dancer. I'm so screwed...I might be dancing off a cliff. :D

Re: Dancing on the Edge of Disaster

#13

A Reminder

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

This hangs on a screw on the wall near my lathe.


The plate was less than 1/8" thick when, working from the backside to trim the foot, It Happened. A most satisfying "CRACK!!" followed by pieces hitting things in the line-of-fire (not me :) )