Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Penyy Wise - Pound Stupid

Posts

Penyy Wise - Pound Stupid

#1

Penyy Wise - Pound Stupid

charlie belden

Turning miniature finials from the bottom up ain't that hard - till you get to a delicate tip of the finial. THEN things get tricky.

So I'm thinking - "If I had a collet chuck, and a small enough collet . . ."

While at WoodCraft, getting a bunch of exotic wood pen blanks (miniatures don't require much wood) , I asked if they had a collet chuck system. They did - but it was on a morris taper (?) MT shaft - and had EIGHT collets rather than the BEAL Collect Chuck Systems four. And it was $60 cheaper than the BEAL's $160 price tag.

Today, after cleaning off all the cutting oil things were plastic bagged in, I chucked up the end of a little finial I'd done, intending to finish off the tip of the finial. Turned the lathe speed down and fired it up - and watched the tip wobble around like a drunken sailor, sans vomiting.

Removed the little finial and fired up the lathe again. The chuck's end wobbled around visibly. Cleaned out the inside of my drive end and tried again. Same result.

The BEAL collet chuck screws directly on to the lathe's drive head - one less source of misalignment. Would that I'd listened to Glenn Kreug, a Master of Miniatures - and took his recomendation to get the best and save some grief.

FORTUNATELY - WoodCraft has a good return policy. I ordered the BEAL collet system from a closer, local store - the SawDust Shop.

Should have gone with Buy Once, Cry Once.

When I factor in the gas to get to and from the WoodCraft store 25 miles away - TWICE, the difference in price is probably only $40 - less if I take the van rather than the little Miata.

I'm going to put a PostIt in my wallet that says

Penny Wise

Pound STUPID

in hopes that I won't make this type of mistake again. Of course there or so many possible ways to make other mistakes . . .

Bought a Second Choice and had to return it in order to be able to get your First Choice? If so, what was your First Choice and what did you try first?

Re: Penyy Wise - Pound Stupid

#2

Re: Penyy Wise - Pound Stupid *LINK*

John Lucas

Charlie Call Bruce Hoover and ask him about his collet systems. They seemed pretty nice when I saw them in his booth.


http://www.thesandingglove.com/Woodturning-Chucks-And-Collet-Systems.asp

Re: Penyy Wise - Pound Stupid

#3

Alan Zenreich

Re: Penyy Wise - Pound Stupid

Alan Zenreich

I'm quite happy with my Beall collet chuck. I got it as a 5 collet set, and then added a 21 piece metric collet set. If I was doing it again, I would order just the collet from Beall, and add the full metric set. The reason for going metric is that the sizes don't leave any gaps in coverager (unlike the imperial sizes), so I can chuck anything that will fit in an ER32 collet range.

Oh, and just to clarify (particularly for the new turners), the taper you mentioned earler is not a "Morris", it's a "Morse" taper (invented by Stephen A. Morse)

Re: Penyy Wise - Pound Stupid

#4

Re: Penyy Wise - Pound Stupid

charlie belden

I KNEW I should have waited before ordering the BEAL Collet System! The system you suggested has 8 not just 4 collets and it's Quick Change so no spanner to keep track of.

Woodturning tools are getting like computers & cell phones. As soon as you buy one a better less expensive one comes out with more features. Thankfully, there's no need to try and find batteries 5 years later, no compatability problems when upgrading the software, etc. (I'm still using my PowerMac G3 I got in 1998)

Re: Penyy Wise - Pound Stupid

#5

Did you snap the collet into the nut?

Dick Coers

The system that Woodcraft sells, works like router collets. You have to snap the collet into the nut before threading it down.That way the nut pulls the collet off the taper to release the object. Not saying the Chinese item wasn't faulty, just that it takes an extra step in assembly.

Re: Penyy Wise - Pound Stupid

#6

Re: Did you snap the collet into the nut?

charlie belden

Yes, I'd snapped the collet in the "neck". With NO collet in the chuck there was still unacceptable runout. So I took the "neck piece" off and till had unaccaptable runout. Maybe I just happened to get the one the New Guy In The Shop madehis first day. I seem to be lucky that way.