A friend of mine is just starting to get into wood working. He just bought a lathe. He has seen a set of Buck Brothers turning tools and was asking if they would work. As far as I know he has never used a lathe.
He says there a set fo 12 tools and the store wants $250. I have no idea what shape they are in.
I am probably wrong but I think they are not high speed steel. Someone correct me if I am wrong.
Dick, with your experience I think you should steer him to purchase individual tools instead of a set. Determine what he wants to turn first and make sure he has the basic tools he needs.
Something like a 3/8" bowl gouge, 1/2" spindle gouge, 1/8" parting tool, a spindle roughing gouge (if he is going to do spindle work), a scraper or two and a safety face shield.
As he gets more into it, we all know, he will buy more tools than he can ever use but a good basic collection of individual tools may be a better start than a "set".
The tools are high carbon. They were the best in their day -- but will not hold an edge very long and thus are inferior to high speed steel (which is what almost all the new tools are made of). The powdered metal tools (like the ones Doug Thompson makes) are even better. Your friend probably does not need Thompson tools at this point -- but Doug's prices tend to be lower than the "big name" high speed steel tool maker's because he does not sell through catalogues and thus you are not paying a markup. This makes them very attractive.
It is better (as Mike says) to get a few specific tools, which you or another woodturner can give him some advice on, depending on what type of turning he is interested in (bowl vs. spindle; big vs micro, etc.). Sets tend to have a bunch of tools you never use an thus are a bad investment.
There is a myth out there that you can get a better edge on carbon steel than you can on the high speed or powered metal tools. I believed this for a long time. The problem is, people have been using the wrong stones to sharpen the tools. The old Arkansas stone that has been the mainstay of shops for a couple of hundred years is often used. It will put a fantastic edge on carbon steel. It will not do a very good job on high speed steel as the stone is too soft to cut the steel properly. The Arkansas stone is useless on powdered metal. Try one of the new ceramic stones, or CBN stones. They will do the trick.
Also, the asking price is WAY too high. For that money, you could just about outfit yourself with all the Thompson or high speed tools you need.
A last thought -- The carbon steel tools dull faster (as I mentioned) which means your friend is going to have to do a lot more sharpening f he buys them -- something most beginners find very frustrating and try to avoid.
They will work just fine. You have to learn to sharpen before you start turning anyway, let him learn on those. Seems like everyone is in a big hurry to get to fancy tools these days. Thousands of miles of stair parts were made with carbon steel way before high speed steel tools became available. Let him learn what he likes to do, then he can invest in some better tools when funds allow. Super tools don't make anyone a better technical turner or teach anyone faster.
Sure they'll work, but the price for an old set of carbon steel tools is way too high. I'm quite sure that Buck Bros. never made a bowl gouge so if he wants to turn bowls he'll have to buy even more tools.
I have a couple of Buck Bros. tools that I bought in the '50s. Good tools then but seldom used now.
Rockler sells a set of high carbon alloy tool steel blades with seasoned kilned dry handles and plated ferules for only $109.19. Just type Buck Brothers and see what turns up.
Home Depot once carried a $30.00 set of Buck Brothers tools.
Might be mo-better if went to Harbor freight and picked up $60.00 red handle almost HSS tools to learn on. Could also go to Penn State Industries PSI and buy individual turning tools for a lot less.
I have to disagree with the direction some are taking here. I would not buy cheap tools. You get what you pay for. Get a good deep fluted bowl gouge and a parting tool and have some fun. Its all about enjoying the lathe time. Using a cheap tool that will not hold an edge, and is the wrong shape to turn correctly is not fun or a productive way to get started. Sometimes our frugal gene gets in the way. Yes, I can turn with a sharpened screwdriver or a hachet but it would extend my learning curve.