Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

A question for the manufacturers....

Posts

A question for the manufacturers....

#1

A question for the manufacturers....

robo hippy

I keep thinking back to a demonstration that our club had. The turner mounted a piece between centers on a DVR. He was unfamiliar with the lathe, and turned it on. It had been left at high speed. He hit the off button. Then he fired it up again, and hit the ramp down speed button. This lathe is very slow to respond, and the piece came off the lathe. It went up, and there were no injuries. Yes, he didn't check the speed first, but this has happened to all of us at one time or another. What I am wondering, is would it be possible to make a lathe which when you turn it off, the rpm reverts to 0 every time?

This could be a big safety factor, especially in school/class situations where you never know who was on the lathe before you. The dial knob would not be a speed indicator, but for me that would not be a problem as I have never had one on any of my lathes. It might be necessary to add an electronic read out to every lathe, but it seems that is already becoming a standard in the industry. Yes, you would have to twist the knob each time, but that is only a second or two. We almost all talk about finding thee right speed for turning by saying, "I just turn the speed up till it starts to wobble, then back it down a bit.

robo hippy

Re: A question for the manufacturers....

#2

Re: A question for the manufacturers....

Dave Paine

The demonstrator definitely was unfamiliar with the lathe.

I have a DVR. When it is powered off (the toggle switch on the left end) it will then default to 500 rpm.

When it has powered, whatever speed it is set to will display on the readout. If you then hit the "ON" microswitch, it will spin up to this speed.

Seems the demonstrator hit the "OFF" microswitch and did not adjust the speed before hitting the "ON" microswitch again.

As you observed the DVR is not fast to respond to speed changes when running.

I do not know why NOVA chose 500 rpm as the default, but it is only re-set to this after power off, not microswitch off.

I expect that if all lathe's had some type of electronic control, they could be designed to start at 0 rpm. Have to decide whether this is after power on, or microswitch on.

If every time you started the motor you had to do something to make the lathe rotate, I could imagine people wanting to by-pass this safety design.

I have a buddy who has by-passed his safety belt warning so that he can drive without the safety belt. Just an example that people can dislike safety devices which may be in their best interests.

I attended a bowl turning demo earlier in the year and was glad that I was at the back. Some of the steps looked a bit too risky for me.

Good job no-one was hurt. I bet lots of people were surprised.

Re: A question for the manufacturers....

#3

Steven Antonucci

Expense

Steven Antonucci

I suspect that the real reason is cost. It would be possible to build a lathe that could sense the mass and diameter before accelerating, but the cost of developing such an item would price it beyond the reach of us mortals. I suspect that big lathes for industrial purposed have such controls rather than spinning 9 tons of metal at 3000rpm and destroying itself.

As a demonstrator, I think it's important to familiarize yourself before the crowd shows up. It also helps to have a good safety mindset when you've got a room full of people who will be asking you questions while you turn. I keep the speed down, and I also make sure I know where everything is (amazing how hard it can be to find the power switch in a moment of panic.)

Don't talk too loudly before SawStop makes a LatheStop and we all have to buy one.

S

Re: A question for the manufacturers....

#4

Re: Expense

Matt

+1 on getting to know the lathe before using it. If the demonstrator doesn't have time, then someone else needs to turn the machine on and adjust speeds for him.

I have a DVR XP and think it's a fantastic lathe. Had the demonstrator taken the time (about 3 or 4 minutes) to get to know the lathe, he wouldn't have had the problem he did.

Re: A question for the manufacturers....

#5

JL

For those of us with Jets or Powermatics...

JL

I always make sure the dial is turned all the way to the left.

Re: A question for the manufacturers....

#6

Re: A question for the manufacturers....

robo hippy

Maybe it comes down to how far do we have to go to protect us from ourselves. I would think that with all the electronic gizmos out there, it would be simple to have an on/off switch, and one speed switch that always goes back to zero when turned off.

robo hippy

Re: A question for the manufacturers....

#7

Re: A question for the manufacturers....

John Lucas

They do, it's called a treadmill. I rigged up a treadmill motor to have a variable speed turntable for a special photo project at work. I had to find out how to override the return to zero function because we needed to run it at a constant speed and turn it on and off frequently. The override I found was an article on how to use the motor for a lathe and apparently he didn't want the return to zero either.

As a demonstrator it is hard to remember all that's going on especially when your using a lathe your not used to. I had the same frustration when I used a DVR Nova for a demo. It may seem natural to those that own one but it frustrated me trying to think of what I was telling them and then trying to concentrate on the unfamiliar buttons of the DVR.