Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

lamp progress

Posts

lamp progress

#1

lamp progress

John Lucas

I built the taper jig yesterday and started cutting staves. I'm using some cheap furring strips for practice. I needed practice on everything from cutting to glue ups. Good wood is too expensive to screw up so this will be a good test. If it comes out reasonably successful I'll use these scrap pieces for some project.

Gluing up in packs of 8 was a real pain. I put tape on the back. When you try to open the joint to spread the glue it sometimes comes off the tape a little. this makes it hard to get the joint really tight roll it back together.

Another problem is wood that isn't truely flat or has tendency to twist when I cut it. As you clamp the wood there isn't good way to knock all the pieces into alignment like you can when you glue up a flat ring. As you can see in photo 2 there are some miss alignment problems. I'm hoping when I go to good quality wood and take the time to true up all the boards before I start cutting that this problem will be somewhat self correcting.

I'm trying some 4 stave glue ups this morning and the first one went much better than the 8 stave glue ups.

The bottom photo is my stave cutting jig. With the new Forest blade it is really cutting well. The only problem I'm having is the boards seem to warp a little after cutting but then this is about the cheapest lumber you can buy.

Re: lamp progress

#2

Re: lamp progress

Barry L Elder

It's still a good start on an awesome project! :D

Re: lamp progress

#3

Possible Glue Up Problem Solution *LINK*

charlie belden

I may have a solution for your coopered staves glue up "challenge".

The fun and games with coopered staves glue up is keeping the parts aligned AND seeing both sides of the joint so you can make sure the joint is actually closed its full length.

The Tape On The Outside And Fold Joints Closed Method works fine - except that the Tape Can Come Off When You Don't Want It To.

A possible solution to your glue up challenge is - RUBBER BANDS - and working with pairs of staves, then pairs of pairs of staves, then . . .


With some working time hide glue provides, you have time to adjust the rubber bands

Another consideration is glue. You want something with a long set up time - and hide glue has a longer set up time than TiteBond and the like. You also want the glue to be reversible - just in case. Again, hide glue fits the bill.

Now if you plan on staining the finished piece, any glue squeeze out that you miss during clean up will stand out noticably when you apply the stain - or any finish for that matter, especially with TiteBond. Michael Fortune came up with a great solution to that problem when he was doing Windsor chairs with lots of joints in tight spots. His solution to the glue squeeze out problem - Waxalit (Lee Valley carries it). Gue won't stick to wax - or a waxed surface.

Waxalit is a wax in a solvent with a toothpaste consistency. When dry it's white - so you can see it when dry. Alcohol will remove it.

So if you apply a little Waxalit to the inside and outside of your staves near the joint, any glue squeeze out can be popped off easily. Wipe off the Waxalit and you're good to go. If your going to scrape and shape the glued up staves to a continuous curve you won't need the Waxalit trick.

I don't recall if you described how you're going to hinge the "door". Hinges complicate things considerable, especially when the door is tall and knife hinges can't be used. Installing hinges on a flat door is tricky enough. But on a coopered door it gets even trickier because you either have to mortise them in to keep your continuous curve or allow for them on the hinge side stave.

For the length you're working with, a piano hinge would work - but they're a PITA to install right on the first try - and they're not very unobtrusive.

You've chosen an interesting challenge - and a great project for a problem solver ; )


Staves Glue Up - AAARRRGGGHHHH

Re: lamp progress

#4

Re: Possible Glue Up Problem Solution

John Lucas

Charlie I tried stretch wrap which should work like rubber bands. It tended to open the joint once you get to gluing the 4's or 8's together. I guess it was pulling too much on the outside corners. I cut it quickly applied more tape to the outside to close the joint then used tape to pull the inside of the joint together. That seemed to work better but I sure would like to come up with a better solution.

What I'm thinking about is a large clamp made out of All thread rod and boards (think Large adjustable rectangle) to limit the expansion of the arc as I apply pressure to the top of the piece to push the joint together. A little adjustment of the rectangle to make sure the bottom is secure and the proper pressure on the top to push it closes should work.

I have bench dog holes in my workbench so I should be able to rig up a pressure system with a crossbar and some all thread.

I don't know. I have 3 more practice panels to glue up. I'm going to try strapping tape next since it won't stretch it may hold the joints closed better if it sticks to the wood well enough.

Just wondering. I wonder if 2 screw clamps that would go around the ouside and then an all thread rod to go across the bottom. Tighten the all thread to close the inside gap and tighten the screw clamps to close the outside. Or even easier use some strong string across the top and tighten it like a turniquette. I'll play with that last one since it will be the quickest.

Re: lamp progress

#5

Re: Possible Glue Up Problem Solution

charlie belden

John:

With tape or shrink wrap, you don't have much adjustability. If you over or under tension it somewhere you're sort of screwed/

One of the advantages of the rubber band method is that you CAN adjust the tension of each rubber band. If you need more tension on the outside and less tension on the inside you can stretch the outside and move more of the rubber band to the inside. If you need more tension on both sides, a wedge or two between the rubber band and the piece will do that.

This tension adjustment feature of rubber bands can also be used when you're putting together multiple pairs of staves. The size of the rubber bands must be increased of course .

Sometimes the simplest solution is the best choice (other times it ain't).

Re: lamp progress

#6

Malcolm Ray

Re: lamp progress

Malcolm Ray

John,Have you considered cutting scrap plywood or MDF into squares of different sizes and then marking different sized circles on them,cut the circles out with a band saw or jig saw and use them as clamps after you assemble the staves?Just slide the plywood down over the lamp before the glue dries......the different sizes will adjust to the different diameters....I don't know if I am making myself clear...if not,let me know and I'll e-mail a better description of the method..Mac

Re: lamp progress

#7

Re: lamp progress

John Lucas

That would work if I was gluing up the whole thing at once but I'm afraid my saw and my skills aren't up to making perfect segments that size. Consequently I am gluing them up in steps and if necessary correct each section if the angle is off slightly.

Re: lamp progress

#8

A better clamp

John Lucas

I rigged this up to glue together 2 of the groups. I'll try it on the larger group tomorrow. I adjusted the bottom clamps until the bottom of the joint closed and the top was slightly open. Then I put the 2 clamps on to push down which closed the top. The downside is I don't know if it's opening up at the bottom. I checked both ends and they looked closed.

I think I'll rig it up with more all thread rod going vertical with a wooden bar across the top so the whole clamping system can be picked up. That will let me view the bottom to make sure the joint is closed and I can wipe up glue so I won't have to clean that off afterwords.

You can see the first half sitting on the floor. This was glued up with tape and was really a hassle.


Re: lamp progress

#9

I wonder how coopers did it?

Mike Foster

Coopers didn't have all of the fancy jigs and fine woodworking equipment available to them, but got results good enough that a few days of water (or wine or whisky) exposure caused all the joints to swell to water tight. They must have had some trick we don't know.

Regarding the stock, I have done a few pieces of compound mitered construction and find that milling of the stock is really a key piece of the puzzle. John, your project is amplified so much by the length of the staves that I would be tempted to cut the staves all to slightly oversize before jointing and planing. This will relieve some of the stresses that get released from ripping the stock. I would then joint and plane the boards to thickness, and finally re-cut the compound miters to size. May be more than you want to do, but it may also relieve some headaches. Another thought is to glue up in pairs as others have said till you get 2 halves, then joint the 2 halves for the final glue up, given your jointer is big enough.

With all that said, my hat is off to you John for tackling a difficult project. I will be interested in watching your progress.

Mike

Re: lamp progress

#10

Re: I wonder how coopers did it?

bill Crommett

John: Have you considered that SPF studs are NOT kiln dried the same way that good lumber is ? To try a mock-up out of garbage wood is ok if your pieces are small, but in something the size you are working with you are fighting several variables: Poorly processed wood and long pieces that will move even after assembly. Just thought I would cheer you up a bit.

For those who have never seen a coopers saw, It resembles a giant hole saw and the staves are cut to width and the edges jointed to the precise diameter of the finished barrel. I have never seen a coopers rig for making the huge whiskey barrels.

Re: lamp progress

#12

Re: I wonder how coopers did it?

John Lucas

Good idea. More time consuming with all the extra cutting but probably worth it. I've watched bucket makers do their thing. They cut all the staves close and then custom fit the last one. They fit them all in the steel rings. Since they are all wedge shaped the last one is fairly easy to fit. They also aren't fiddling with glue, the swelling of the wood from the water makes it water tight.

Re: lamp progress

#13

Re: I wonder how coopers did it?

John Lucas

Bill I definitely think your correct about the wood quality. I'm going to buy some good air Dried wood from a friend if he has what I need. That and possible cutting oversize and letting it sit for a few days before final cutting will probably solve the problem. At least for accurate fitting. I think my new clamp will solve the glue up problem.

Re: lamp progress

#14

Re: lamp progress

John Lucas

I checked Birdsmouth bits only come in 16 segments max and I need 32.

Re: lamp progress

#15

Re: lamp progress

Dale Miner

I had an Amish fellow make some buckets for 5 gallon ice cream freezers for me. Those staves had matching male and female radii cut into their faces. Looked like the radii were cut with router bits, or more likely a large shaper. Fit up can't be a problem as the angle of the miter is always self aligning with the matching radii.

It appears the staves were shaped on the OD before assembly, and look to have been turned on the inside afterwards. Definately a specialized process.

The buckets have straight sides, so the joints are straight. If shape of details were turned in the outside, the joints would lose that straight line.

Just a thought.

Good luck on the effort, quite an undertaking. Now, when you master the process, putting veneer strips between the staves should be childs play, right?

Re: lamp progress

#16

Re: lamp progress

Doug Turner

John, If you continue to have glue up problems, you might borrow a technique from kayak makers- make plywood forms and the tack the staves to the forms until the glue sets. The brads can be removed before turning. If the brads are located where your decorative rings will be added the holes will be covered up by the rings.

Re: lamp progress

#17

Re: lamp progress

John Lucas

Thinking about that. I can screw them from the inside where the holes will never show. I could leave the outside 2 pieces large and plane them down to a perfect fit so both halves would fit perfectly.

Re: lamp progress

#18

Jesper, Denmark

Re: lamp progress

Jesper, Denmark

The birdsmouth is always 90° - no matter how many staves, so it is only a question of the angle beteen the flat surface and the birdsmouth. The opposite side to the mouth is always 90° to the flat surface.

I use the table saw to cut the mouth. Angle the blade to the correct angle for whatever number of staves, and you can cut both sides of the mouth with the same blade angle by flipping the stave 90° to the land or table surface.

You should be able to extrapolate the angle from the article referenced.

Glue-up is relatively easy with bandclamps. It helps if you have a disc inside at either end with an approximate ID of the final piece.

........and Yes, it would help having more than two hands :(

Re: lamp progress

#19

Re: lamp progress

Bob Macgregor

Maybe its just the setting where I live, but my first thought when you outlined this project was, "why doesn't he just make a lighthouse?" I was thinking of a hexagonal one like at Peggy's Cove, NS.

Of course, the woodturning compulsion would hardly be satisfied by that, though, so how about turning the form you want the way wooden lampshades are made (REALLY DEEP hollowing!), then quartering it on the long axis with a bandsaw and reconnecting the pieces with one section hinged?

BOB