Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Negative rake scraper angles?

Posts

Negative rake scraper angles?

#1

Leo Cuellar

Negative rake scraper angles?

Leo Cuellar

Which combination of top & bottom bevel angles seem to work best for you? I have a few new tool blanks ready, and would like to try these out in addition to regular scrapers. Thanks in advance for your input!!

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#2

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

Greg Haugen

As long as the included (thanks John, that's a better term for it than "combined") angle of the two bevels are less than 90 degrees, you're in the "negative rake" range. As far as what's best? In my opinion, that doesn't matter too much as long as it's in that range. Less the 90 degrees combined and a fresh burr/edge is what matters.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#3

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

John Lucas

I think they work well with a really sharp angle like a skew laying on it's side. I think we would have to call the angle an included angle measuring from the top face to the bottom face. I have on that is about 70 degrees. It seems to hold the burr a little longer but doesn't cut as easily. I use it more in a skew scrape angle. I'm still regrinding my big bowl scraper to a sharper angle. Every time I sharpen it on the grinder I take a little more off the top. It's now down to about 50 degrees.

I don't do much scraping anymore except for some shear scraping. I know when I'm playing with the skew I will often use it as a scraper to see how it cuts or if I'm trying to turn a really accurate sphere I will sometime use the skew on it's side. It cuts very easily and very cleanly this way which is why I'm slowly taking my big scraper down to a sharper angle. My skew doesn't have a burr and that could easily change how a tool cuts.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#4

John....about burrs.....

Greg Haugen

John,

I've been playing around with burrs, burnishing options, and how a tool cuts over the last couple of years. One thing I like about scrapers is their versatility. One grind can have multiple uses depending on the level of burr. In my box turning, depending on the application and wood species, I'll use a freshly dressed edge that I've honed the top surface to remove all of the burr to a burnisher induced monster burr and the positions vary from dead flat to shearing at a near 80 degrees vertical.

I think a lot time a scraper without a burr is underestimated.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#5

Re: John....about burrs.....

John Lucas

Greg I do play with burr's. Everything from a burnisher to diamond hones of different grits and straight off the grinder. There is definetly a diffence and it depends on the hardness of the metal and how you use the tool which method works.

I suppose what I need to do is to take a sharpened skew and cut with it. Then raise a burr on it (wow that would hurt to dull a tool) and see how it cuts differently. That may be a test tomorrow. I plan to try and play in the shop a little tomorrow.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#6

Steven Antonucci

I use a skew, so the answer is "it doesn't matter"

Steven Antonucci

If I need to neg rake scrape something, I grab for a skew of any sharpness. If it happens to be freshly sharpened, I sort of feel guilty using it to scrape, but man can I get a smooth cut! Even the dull ones do a pretty good job of it.

I can also negative rake scrape with a standard scraper just by lifting the tool rest higher and tilting the tool down. go figure, the wood doesn't know it...

Steve

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#7

Re: I use a skew, so the answer is "it doesn't mat

John Lucas

Steve The way Stewart Batty teaches the negative rake scraper it is 2 things. The negative rake, which as you say is simply lifing the handle, and the sharpness. There is also another function. Then angle of the body of the scraper.

I have been playing with this and there is a difference between holding the handle high thereby creating a negative rake to the upper surface of the scraper, and holding the handle level with a negative rake ground on the top. The difference is the force applied to the turning by the cutting edge. With the true negative rake scraper there is very little force applied to the turning. The tool rest supports the tool and lets you be very gentle with good control. If you hold a regular scraper higher it is tilted on the tool rest and there is a more pushing action against the wood because of the angle of the tool on the tool rest which is downhill.

When you combine the purposely negative rake ground scraper with a grind that is 45 degrees or so included angle you get a very clean cutting tool.

I hope that explained it well enough.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

Mike Stafford

Having watched Richard Raffan use scrapers very closely in the last year or so I have begun to incorporate them more and more into my work. I have found it amazing how well I have been able to remove large volumes of wood very quickly and then refine the surface to the point of almost not needing to sand. Of course the shape of the object determines how successful the process will be.

Richard sees no advantage to negative rake scrapers and is not concerned one iota about a burr. As a matter of a fact he routinely hones the top and side surfaces of his scrapers with a diamond hone and achieves remarkably smooth surfaces. Perhaps the only time he has a burr is when it is fresh off the grinder and after that he hones.

The burr lasts a very short amount of time while the sharp clean intersection of the two adjacent surfaces cut very well for a long time. The thin wispy shavings coming of a honed scraper sometimes amaze me. And I love the reduced sanding time.

Richard says, "I feel sorry for people who do not know how to use scrapers." Well, I'm learning......

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#9

My take on scrapers

Doc Green

I did quite a bit of experimenting with scrapers about a year ago. What I found is described in three articles on my website:

www.docgreenwoodturner.com

One thing I discovered is that if the included angle on a negative rake scraper is more then 90 degrees (for M2 HHS), grinding Does Not produce a burr. This enables you to grind the tool without producing a burr.

Another thing I found is that the smaller the included angle between the bevels, the weaker the burr, and the sooner it will be gone. If the angle is as small as 35 or 40 degrees (skew), the burr will disappear as soon as it touches the wood.

In my opinion, a scraper with an included angle of less than 90 degrees is not a negative rake scraper even if it is presented with the handle held high.

Also, I found that if an ordinary scraper is ground with a bevel of about 75 degrees, it does not tend to grab or catch if the handle is lowered. In fact, if the burr has just a small amount of "curl", you can rub the bevel and this will give the best possible surface off the tool. Depending on the wood, the surface may be glassy smooth.

I invite you to take a look ...

~Doc

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#10

Mike Stafford

Hear, hear!  Doc methinks you got it!

Mike Stafford

What you describe is exactly what I have been trying to perfect after watching Raffan use a scraper.

Your explanation agrees with the results I see now that I am using the scraper as Richard suggested.

I start with the handle level or slightly elevated and as I move through the cut the handle is lowered and a bevel riding cut ensues. The finish is dramatically improved.

I have no idea what angle I grind my scrapers at but I would guess they are in the 75-80 degree range. I guess I need to buy something to measure with.

Whenever I get poor cutting results I can quickly improve them by honing with a diamond hone. I do not find it necessary to regrind all that often as long as I am doing finishing cuts. When I use the scraper to remove large volumes of wood more frequent grinding is necessary and before making finishing cuts I sharpen and hone.

Still learning how to use them but amazed and disappointed by the "common" wisdom that good turners do not use scrapers.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#11

Steven Antonucci

Understood...but...

Steven Antonucci

I think too many people try to turn too many turning things into a formula of how thick+what angle+which steel+presentation method= instant results.

The truth be told, if you have the appropriate skills + appropriately shaped and sharpened tools+ used correctly= success. The wood only sees these things and doesn't care about which handle it is in with whose name on it. Problems arise from skill deficiencies, not tool deficiencies and expensive tooling is not a substitute for low skills.

Don Riggs gave me a scrap of planer blade that he uses as a negative rake scraper. I gave him a hook tool that I hammered out of O1 steel in his shop. I can get the same finished surface with either of them, or any other tool. The better question to ask is what those tools are really good at. A hook removes a ton of wood cleanly, but is hard to make small ridges go away. A NRS is good for small clean-ups.

Steve

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#12

Leo Cuellar

Re: My take on scrapers

Leo Cuellar

Thank you for the link to your website, Doc. I found the articles very informative. It gives me a great starting point. I have been getting good results from traditional scrapers, having some that are mirror finished, and some that I have used either a diamond hone or fine kitchen steel to raise burrs with. I have some hardwood of indeterminate origin (possibly some type of cottonwood) that not even sanding can tame the end grain. I figured it would be a good test subject for tuning the NR scrapers.

I must say, I'm enjoying your book on chucking fixtures & jigs. It is well written and very helpful.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#13

Leo Cuellar

Not a formula, just a starting point.

Leo Cuellar

Hi Steve, I searched through the archives, but couldn't really find what would be a good set of angles to start with. I love making tools and experimenting out in the shop, but as I'm getting older, I don't mind benefitting from others experience. I have used a skew in that way before, in fact when I first started that was the only way that I knew how to use one.

I picked up and adopted a set of prejudices about tool use from this forum that did me no favors as a novice turner. Now I am ready to drop my personal sticking points and discover other techniques that might work better for the types of things that I do. Please don't take that as a criticism of you, I like you just the way you are :D and always enjoy your contributions to the forum! You are absolutely correct: there is no substitute for putting in the time. I do however believe that every tool exists for a reason, even if that reason is to separate someone from their hard earned dollars :\ I'm hoping to fire up the forge this fall and try making one of those hook tools.

P.S. I confess to having bought a Hunter #3

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#14

Leo Cuellar

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

Leo Cuellar

In the end I think it all comes down to time spent sanding, anything that reduces that is my friend. It is not really so surprising, in retrospect of course, compared with "traditional" cutting tools that the finer the edge, the better the cut.

It makes me wonder if the negative rake was first tried in an attempt to reduce the awkward angle that your arms must be in for some presentations?

You don't have to feel sorry for me, I'm capable of that all by myself :D But as you said: I'm learning!

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#15

no burr not good

John Lucas

Mike perhaps I'm doing something wrong but I did a test for Betty Scarpino about a year back on burr vs no burr on scrapers and found that the no burr gave a worse finish.

I went out to the shop this morning and did the same test. cut a cove with a scraper with a burr and then polished off the burr with 1200 grit hone on the top and sides. I got a worse finish. I then used the tool in a bevel rubbing cut and got a better finish but not as good as the burr finish. I did the same with a hardwood piece and same results. This was on a round nose scraper with about a 60 degree bevel.

Then I used a spindle gouge with a 40 degree grind and got a better finish than both. I guess I'm still not a scraper convert.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#16

Steven Antonucci

Part of the time spent...

Steven Antonucci

has to be on experimenting. You can take any old scraper and grind a bevel on the top. It won't be wrong. You simply cannot do it wrong. However, you may not be able to cut with it if you haven't spent the time at the lathe. Almost any angle will work, and anyone that tells you differently probably has a line of tools somewhere.

I usually tell people that if you cannot cut with the tools you already own, odds are new ones won't solve your problem no matter what angle, or steel, or whatever...

Steve

P.S. The only person that can tell you what you can or can't use is you...

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#17

Steven Antonucci

Spindle vs bowl?

Steven Antonucci

I use scrapers in only a couple of situations where I think that they help me do things that are HARDER to do with other tools.

First, if I am working in an end grain situtation like a box, goblet or similar, I might use a scraper to get a clean continuous surface. Other tools like spindle gouges backhollowing or hook tools can do that job cleanly, but I sometimes have small ridges or tool marks that the scraper is the easiest tool to put to the task.

Secondly, if I am making a platter or a shallow bowl, it is sometimes hard to get that perect curve from top to bottom. If you've ever seen a platter with ripples, I like the scraper for taking them out.

I don't use a scraper to remove "a lot of wood", only 1/1000ths...

Steve

P.S. Not saying that using a scraper otherwise is somehow inferior, just that I don't ...

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#18

Leo Cuellar

Re: no burr not good

Leo Cuellar

John, I've had some limited success with this, but my scrapers are at about an 80-85 degree grind. I'm going to regrind one to about 75 or less & see what happens.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#19

Leo Cuellar

HOLY COW, MIKE!!!

Leo Cuellar

I took one of my scrapers to about a 70 degree angle then polished the face and top. I then ran the tool on both sides with red rouge on the buffer. It did not feel particularly sharp with the fingernail test, no burr. Man does that baby cut! Now I just need to learn some control with it. This first pic is what the tool looks like.



This second pic is of the difference this made.



Starting left to right, the base was done with an NR detail scraper I just made. Then a band at first pass with my regular scraper. Next the best I could get with that one. Just after the center is what I was able to get with the tool in the first picture, it would still feel fuzzy if you could touch it, but it looks good. The rest out to the end was gouge, no pun intended :\ This is a really crummy piece of wood. I originally bought it to make some flat work with, but the end grain was impossible to make nice by any means. It didn't even feel nice after using shellac to try to fix it up. I thought that I had burned all of it. This one was never going to be a keeper though, more of an exercise in patience.

THANK YOU, so much for passing on that tip from Richard Raffan. You just dispelled a few other preconceptions that I had. :D And you saved me from making more tools I don't think I'll be needing now.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#20

Good Deal, Leo!

Doc Green

Your picture shows what I've observed many times: in many cases a scraper produces a much better surface than a gouge.

If you haven't tried it already, my suggestion would be to take your polished scraper and put a burr on it by burnishing. That is, take the shank of a gouge and stroke it across the cutting edge, only once or twice, with fairly light pressure. The result should be a burr that is so small that it is actually hard to feel, but it should (may) make a big difference in how it cuts.

Play around with it and see if you get a surface with fewer or less fuzzies. Also, try shear scraping with the small burr. I'll bet it works!

And you should get tiny shavings so fine they almost float in the air.

Scrapers are wonderful!

Leo and Mike, thanks for your comments. A bit of validation means a lot.

~Doc

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#21

Steven Antonucci

Try using your skew as a NRS.

Steven Antonucci

I think you'll be surprised at how well it works. If you try to remove that much tearout in one pass, you'll never do it. Should be doable in small passes. Angel hairs...

Steve

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#22

Leo Cuellar

Re: Try using your skew as a NRS.

Leo Cuellar

I'm no stranger to using a skew in that fashion, but now that Mike revealed Richard's little trick, I probably won't anymore. I blew the piece up trying to do what I think was shear scraping on it. A very grabby chunk of wood. A quick picture to show you that I actually can handle a cheap Grizzly gouge fairly well...


The left side is all gouge. I have a hard time with flowing cuts, but I'm sure I'll get there. A little (started with) 400 grit sanded band for comparison. Next, to the right of the band, a scraper set up as Mike suggested, with my buffer wheel tuneup. Then another band of 400 grit sanding for comparison.

Now, I'm not going to try to convert you to a scraper guy. I'm just saying that you can take such fine shavings with a scraper set up this way that they float away like smoke. I'm sure that there must be some sort of burr raised but it is too refined to even feel, I don't have a magnifier that would even come close to revealing it.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#23

Re: Good Deal, Leo!

John Lucas

I really find that hard to believe. I can get a polished surface off a gouge. I can get a good surface off of a scraper if I polish the edge and rub the bevel but why would I do that. I have a gouge. I would use the scraper where it's needed, which is either to fare out a large curve where the gouge left a lump, or to work in areas where you can't rub the bevel.

After reading this I went out to the shop and using a fairly good quality piece of wood used the scraper first in scraper mode. I got minor tearout. In shear scraper mode I get a better surface getting rid of the tearout but still a satin finish. Then I polished the edge of the scraper and stropped it. Using it in a bevel rubbing mode I got a pretty darn good finish.

Then I took the Thompson 1/2" spindle gouge ground to a 35 degree angle. It was a polished finish. Then I used the new Hunter Osprey tool and got the same finish as the spindle gouge. Both were superior to the scraper. Now that would make sense. The scraper cutting angle is 50 degrees and the Spindle gouge is 35, the Ospry which has a #4 hunter cutter is even sharper.

The I went back and put a burr on the scraper and tried lots of different angles and was never able to match the spindle gouge quality of cut.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#24

Leo Cuellar

Re: Good Deal, Leo!

Leo Cuellar

John, smoothing out those rough spots, is exactly why I was looking to bridge the gaps in my control. I can get smoother cuts with a gouge or skew, but getting that flow on the curves, that's what is tripping me up at the moment. I know the flow will come with time. Sanding is just noxious no matter what, so finding ways to lessen it is a boon. Since I do have to sand, I'd rather start at 400 or so. Also, that scraper treatment doesn't seem to work as well with a more cooperative specimen of wood, but it does very well with end grain though. So if you, perish the thought, ever come up against a piece of wood that just won't cooperate, this might be the trick. One other thing, all of my scrapers are made of old leaf spring stock, I do have a little HSS that I might treat the same way, to see if that makes a difference in its ability to form that micro-burr.

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

#25

Re: Negative rake scraper angles?

steve worcester

I think there needs to be some points of clarification here.

A negative rake scraper is really any scraper that has a bevel on both sides.

It is designed to lay flat on the tool rest. It can be used to shear scrape, i.e. to be tilted at a 45-60 degree angle (vertical) and used to shear scrape.

An NR scraper, definitely uses the burr to cut, the reason you use the side up, the one that was not against the wheel.

I use them all the time on my own work, maybe because it is easier to use for refining than a gouge, maybe because I am not as proficient in the deft handling and dainty-ness required for what I need it to do for the same maneuver I would use an NR scraper.