Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

what's the point?

Posts

what's the point?

#1

what's the point?

GaryG in MD

I have a small (fist sized), cleaned, red malee burl that I was gifted by our friend Terry Scott. It's flat on the cut side (which is kind of dark and plain) and full of beautiful points on the rounded, light-colored side. I'm trying to decide what to make out of it and how to mount it.

I can keep the points natural as the outside bottom and just turn a shallow depression (bowl/platter) in the flat side. But then I have to figure out a way to make it sit on a table or be supported somehow. It's not inviting to be picked up that way because of the prickles.

Or I could make a small, real bowl out of it by turning off the points to reveal the birds-eye type character that underlie them. But, somehow, that seems like a waste.

Or I could do "something" (??) to keep the points and display them on the top side, like a pin cushion. Wouldn't even have to turn it to do that -- just flatten the bottom and display it as a natural object.

Or I could do the latter but do a little turning on the flat bottom to raise it off the table a bit. This might be more work than it's worth because of the need to build a chuck to hold the points without damage.

I've searched through many pages of WoW based on a search on the word "burl" and didn't really come up with anything that struck my fancy or spurred my imagination.

I've never had one of these before and don't want to "waste" it.

What should my goal be here?

The main question is whether to keep the points or turn them off.

What do you all feel is the "best" way to handle something like this?

TIA, Gary

Re: what's the point?

#2

Re: what's the point?

Don Lennon

You and I are in the same boat. I have many natural edged maple burls that have been pressure washed

and I want to do a shallow bowl in the cut side and maintain the "points" on the bottom after it is finished.

I have been unable to find a method so far.Any leads as how to do it would be greatly appreciated.

Don

Re: what's the point?

#3

Re: what's the point?

Dan Jechura Temperance Mich.

I to bought a 14" by 10" by 5" burl with many points and a flat side. At this time it is sitting on a end table as a display item, because I do not know what to do with it. After I learn how to use my new bowl coring tool I hope to core out 2 bowls and leave the flat side and left over pins ( dog dish) as a 3rd bowl.

I also would like to here from other turners that have worked with "pin" burl's.

Dan J.

Re: what's the point?

#4

Steven Antonucci

Dunno, I break them all of the time

Steven Antonucci

Whenever I try to do something to preserve a natural burl , I end up breaking the pins and being annoyed by the fact that I broke some pins... and it is all that I ever see on the piece from that point forward.

Good luck, and have a Plan B.

S

Re: what's the point?

#5

Keeping the points

Scott Crumpton

I've never done this myself, only seen a video of it.

Build a hollow chuck/box/whatever on a faceplate that's big enough to set the burl in centered where you want to cut the bowel. Cover the burl with some plastic wrap, place it in the chuck and attach some wood strips over the front to hold it in. The burl should touch only the wood strips, not the sides or back of the chuck. Fill the void between the burl and the chuck with expanding polyurethane foam and allow it to set. You can now turn the bowel on the exposed face. To remove simply remove the wood retaining strips and pull it out of the foam.

Found the link, it was actually on this board a few days back.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RX-kp-HZ5UQ&feature=channel&list=UL

Re: what's the point?

#6

Re: Keeping the points

Chuck Engstrom

Hi all -- a couple of weeks ago someone posted a link to this YouTube showing this box-of-foam idea in action:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RX-kp-HZ5UQ&feature=relmfu

Gary, you may to have to slide the headstock down to the far end of the bed to make room for this apparatus but it oughta work OK if you build it carefully. Let us know how it works out.

Best to all -- Chuck near beautiful downtown Crumpton MD

Re: what's the point?

#7

There is an article...

GaryG in MD

in the latest American Woodturner (the John Jordan issue) on another method for doing it with vacuum, but it's pretty complicated. ...Gary

Re: what's the point?

#8

what I am trying to get at here...

GaryG in MD

...is not technique, but DESIGN.

Once I decide what I want the product to look like, I can work out the process.

The question is:

What is the (an) "ideal" end result for this little burl cap?

...Gary

Re: what's the point?

#9

Re: what's the point?

john lopez

Terry Scott will probably have some good ideas on how to approach it.

I put pieces like that on a shelf and study them until the idea for the form occurs to me.

Sometimes it can take time.

I've mounted between centers & left bottom points alone except for a tenon & then a foot or base and then hollowed the inside.

Other times I've glued a waste block & faceplate then turned a tenon before hollowing the inside.

After finishing you can turn away the tenon and have a flat bottom

or a "calabash" style (rounded bottom) .

The dimensions of the blank often determine the method I use.

A sound fist-sized blank should be okay between centers if mounted carefully ...

and with good tool control you can avoid damage to desired features.

Remember to work out of the line of fire.

The important thing is to relax with it if it is something different for you &

have some general idea of what you want to end up with.

Re: what's the point?

#10

Tony Reynolds

Re: what's the point?

Tony Reynolds

HI Gary,

Don't know how big your burl is but this is what I did with this Red Morrell burl. It's 16" by 12" by 3". I thought of save the natural side too but decided otherwise.

Tony

Back side


Re: what's the point?

#11

that's a real beauty, Tony...

GaryG in MD

Thanks for the inspiration. ...Gary

Re: what's the point?

#12

John,

GaryG in MD

It's just a burl cap, flat on one side.

I'm not sure there's enough there to hollow -- certainly not enough for a traditional HF.

I guess my real decision comes down to

1) pins down

2) pins up

3) pins to the side

4) no pins.

...Gary

Re: what's the point?

#13

Re: that's a real beauty, Tony...

Karen F.

I made a Brown Mallee natural edge platter and I turned a small foot on the back and left the wings with the spikes. I used some sand paper to "blunt" the spikes so it was easy to pick up without hurting yourself. I was looking for a picture but I can't find one and it has already been sold.

Re: what's the point?

#14

Thanks, Karen...

GaryG in MD

I appreciate the idea. Into the hopper it goes! ...Gary

Re: what's the point?

#15

Gary Gary Gary!!!!!

Terry Scott

Stop procrastinating and just turn the B thing :)

Mate I can offer you 333 different ways to attack it.

Seriously not that I am an expert but send me a picture of your burls Ill tell you what I can see being made out of them

If you are struggling that much just send me the burl

Here we go

No1 Hot melt glue it onto a backing board

Turn a single bowl

This was made 15 years ago my first attempt at keeping on mr prickle sat on three ugly acrylic feet



No2 As above but turn multiple overlapping bowls



No3 Why leave the prickles on the bottom ]



No4 Why worry were it sits let mother nature balance it



No5 Turn it inside out

No6 Make a tree farm



No7 Make a rocky Prickle

I could keep going with this all night Ive turned tonnes and tonnes of the stuff Love it with passion

Re: what's the point?

#16

Re: Gary Gary Gary!!!!!

john lopez

Gary ,

hollow was a poor choice of words on my part.

I should have said remove stock.

Anyway, I bet after seeing Terry's photos something will come to mind.

Have fun with it.

John

Re: what's the point?

#17

Lyle Jamieson

Re: John,

Lyle Jamieson

I like to do a shallow bowl. Start with the points up and the flat on the bottom. Make a football shape not a gord shape so the wings of the bowl are natural edge. Make it relatively thin and uniform wall thickness. The only spikes left will be in the edge of the rim of the bowl. You capture the best of both worlds with this design. You get the color and character of the burl in full view, yet you have the natural edge to celebrate the shape and destinct benefits of the burl. A plus for me is when the burl shape also creates natural voids in the side or bottom of the bowl.

I start between centers and use a laser to point at the probable natural edge of the bowl as I rotate the lathe by hand to get the right balance of high and low points of the finished bowl. Expect to move it between centers many times before you put it on the faceplate/glueblock. Take a little off, shaping the outside of the bowl first and watch the edge and shape developing slowly. Adjust the axis as you give yourself more information in the roughing stage.

Re: what's the point?

#18

Don Leydens

Thanks to Terry

Don Leydens

Gary, it's quite a coincidence, but I was up half the night thinking about what to do with a very similar burl problem. Terry's photos just jump started a bunch of ideas. Hope it did the same for you. Off to the shop I go!

Re: what's the point?

#19

It's about time!  ;-)

GaryG in MD

Hi Terry,

I hoped you would see this and jump in!

NOW I have some inspiration. Thanks, mate!

I would like to do "all the above", but I only have one.

We'll see what happens.

Cheers, Gary

Re: what's the point?

#20

That's the point!  :-)

GaryG in MD

Have fun and show us when it's done! ...Gary

Re: what's the point?

#21

Thanks, Lyle...

GaryG in MD

These are very good tips.

I'd never heard about using a laser like that.

Makes a lot of sense. Gotta give it a try.

I'm glad you reminded me about using a glue block too.

...Gary

Re: what's the point?

#22

Re: It's about time!  ;-)

Terry Scott

Come down here mate and you can have a go at turning them all

Re: what's the point?

#23

Don Leydens

Re: It's about time!  ;-)

Don Leydens

Hi Gary! Hope you got a chance to attack your burl. Finished mine yesterday and will post a photo when the finish is done. Terry's photos really got me going. Think I'll go hunt for some more burls!!

Re: what's the point?

#24

Re: It's about time!  ;-)

Charlie Anderson

Maybe I need to spend an extra day in NZ to visit you Terry.

Re: what's the point?

#25

Hope you had fun in San Jose!