Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

New Sorby Excelsior Tools ?

Posts

New Sorby Excelsior Tools ?

#1

New Sorby Excelsior Tools ?

Don Orr

I've seen some ads for the new Sorby Excelsior tools that are coated with Titanium Nitride. Very thin coating, more like plating. I don't see how it can make much of a difference once it is ground the first time. Sure there will be a TINY little bit of Ti N left on the inside of a gouge right at the actual cutting edge but will it really make a difference? Or is just another gimmick? I have not been impressed with the few item I have used with the coating such as drill bits.

Thoughts?

Re: New Sorby Excelsior Tools ?

#2

Steven Antonucci

No black hands?

Steven Antonucci

Only potential benefit I see is that they won't (or probably won't) react with tannins and make your hands black.

Other than that, I got nothing...

S

Re: New Sorby Excelsior Tools ?

#3

Re: New Sorby Excelsior Tools ?

Dick Coers

Technically, isn't the cutting edge still coated? We don't cut with the bevel. You are only grinding off the coating that is on the relief.

Re: New Sorby Excelsior Tools ?

#4

Yes and No

Dale Miner

The shavings slide over the flute, and the bevel rubs the wood. As the edge wears, both the flute and the bevel just (JUST) under the edge wear.

I've no experience in the TiN coated tools in wood, but for some and not all applications in metal cutting the coating is and advantage. The applications where it is advantageous generally involve cutting abrasive material or applications that involve cutting at high surface speeds. Resharpened end mills with the TiN coating do not hold up as well as a new mill with the coating on both surfaces of the edge.

Most of the offshore TiN coated drill bits are of such poor quality material in the bits themselves that the coating has little advantage other than to make them look nice. Calling them Gold Coated might help improve sales, but not the quality of the material.

My gut feeling is that TiN on a quality woodturning gouge would have some slight advantage. Doubtful to me that the advantage would justify the additional cost, but it might.