Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

Posts

Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#1

Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

charlie belden

In our turning club there are only three or four women - and a majority of the club is made up mainly of OF (Old Farts). And at the San Jose Symposium. while there were sevaral demonstrations by women turners, the male demonstrators outnumbered the women demonstrators probably four to one.

It can't be a strength issue - which is why I have a mini lathe and mainly turn small stuff ; )

And it's not that women don't like creating beautiful things or hate wood.

I think The Male Dominated Activities can't be the thing either - that battle's been fought - and to a large extent - been won - though there's still more skirmishes to be fought.

Probably ain't that women "don't like to get dirty and dusty" - gardening ain't the cleanest, neatest, tidyist activity on the planet, and pottery, probably a Female Dominated Activity, can get pretty messy. And when it comes to refinishing and restoring old furniture or changing the color of a room . . .

Women, for the most part, have better Fine Motor Skills and more apt to pay attention to details than men. Turning has PLENTY of room for details - and embellishmenting.

Though mainly male dominated turning clubs and organizations don't go out of their way, consciously, to exclude women, the fact is - turning IS a male dominated thing.

Why aren't we reaching out and recruiting more women to get them into turning?

What can we guys do to encourage more women to take up turning?

And women out there - what can you do to encourage more women to take up turning - and how can The Guys help?

Just something to think about - and maybe share some suggestions or insights.

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: Why Aren't There More Male Needlepointers?


Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#3

Why do Little Boys Play with Toy Trucks,

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

And little girls play with dolls?

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#4

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

John Lucas

Charlie I'm doing my best. I go out of my way to talk to any of the minority groups, women, Asian, Blacks, etc. We have very few represented in our clubs which are of course White male OF's, which I guess I'm included. I know at our clubs everyone is very receptive to women turners and we just a few in 2 of my clubs and none in the other although we may have picked one up this last weekend. She saw my photo in one of the local newspapers and called to see if we had a club. We had a club picnic coming up so I invited her and her husband and she had a really good time.

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Why do Little Boys Play with Toy Trucks,

Lyle Jamieson

I think Wally is on to something there. Lets take it in another direction. When I was in school there was home-economics, art, music, and shop class. Now they are rare. So where are the young people going to get exposed to hands on "work"?? I included art and music in the list because it's not a matter of vocation VS. hobby. I cant tell you how many times I have had old people in my booth that said the first and last time they turned was in Jr High School. We may not be attracting the women and we might be loosing the men too. Will woodturning go the way of the buggy whip??

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#6

sharon in topanga

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

sharon in topanga

I'm a woman turner. I also crochet. I like sports and participated when I was younger. My sister and I were happier playing outside, baseball, football, bikes, cowboys and indians, rather than playing dolls inside. My parents didn't restrict us to 'girl' roles so we didn't accept the stereotypes. My sister is and engineer and I'm a computer programmer. I grew up knowing I could do what I preferred, whether typically a male or a female activity. I don't think all of us are really past those typical role models, although we are getting there gradually. Wayne and I have two daughters. One teaches high school physics, setting a good example for the girls, and the other owns her own business. Both played sports and took ballet lessons. One likes to camp and fish. The other does her own home repairs. However, neither is interested in turning, but then a lot of the population isn't.

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#7

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

Jeff Rich

Well, dont tell my gf there is not a lot of women turners. She turns an average of 6-8 hours a day on the days she is not working the 9-5.

Cheri makes some amazing birdhouses!

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#8

Re: Why Aren't There More Male Needlepointers?

charlie belden

Hmmm - does the name Rosy Greer ring a bell?

Had dinner at a retired plastic surgeon's just last night, Four or five of his needle point pieces are framed and on the wall in his home, two that incorporated tiny little gold beads. Of course fine stitching and good eye sight come in handy if you're a plastic surgeon. He also was into watchmaking.

I haven't tried needle point work - yet - but I do own a sewing machine and can actually use it. Got it to make some sails for my sea kyaks. For segmented turners, quilting would probably be something to look into.

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#9

Dick Hines

Re: Why do Little Boys Play with Toy Trucks,

Dick Hines

Whin I was in school boys could not take HomeEc and gurls could not take shop.

Thaking HomeEc would have saved me a lot of long distance call to my mother when I left home to take a job. I learned to cook by long distance.

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#10

Re: Why do Little Boys Play with Toy Trucks,

charlie belden

Lyle:

I got tracked into science and engineering early on and missed shop class. Took forty years before I got to woodworking and realize how much critical thinking, planning and skills are required - just to get a board Four Square. I thought I'd been "educated / trained" to be methodical. Then I bought a Robland X-31 combination machine and some wood, wanting to be Just Like Norm. Found out that learning to program computers required being methodical, but when you're working with very sharp spinning things you have to be VERY METHODICAL (or learn to live with a nickname like Left ) . . .

While the loss of shop classes in school and what can we do to get them back is a great topic, first let'sgo with my original question,

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: Why Aren't There More Male Needlepointers?

Mike Stafford

So you can name one male needlepointer- Rosie Greer.

I can name dozens of female woodturners, not enough perhaps, but lots of them and many prominent female woodturners. I don't see why it is necessary to make the distinction. They are all woodturners to me.

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#12

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

Carole Valentine

I once got an email from a board member of the nearest club (two hour round trip and a big road toll) inviting me to their meeting after he had seen my web site. I made the trip but he did not show up. The members were the most unfriendly, grumpiest bunch of OFs I have ever seen. The only person who returned a smile was the female secretary and after she had my dues money, that was that. I felt like an intruder. I never went back. The hell with 'em. I dont need them. I have my shop, my tools and a few turning friends. If other clubs are like that, I can see why there are not many female turners being encouraged to take up the hobby.

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#13

Steven Antonucci

Shh!  You'll ruin it for us all!

Steven Antonucci

I started my demo at Smith Mountain last week with the following:

"Thank you for having me. I am honored to be here, but frankly, just a little bit flustered? Why is this club a bunch of older men when most of the clubs I visit 20-something female super models?"

There was a short delay, and then, a pretty good laugh...

As to the answer to your question, I dunno...

Steve

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#14

Re: Why Aren't There More Male Needlepointers?

Stuart Johnson

So you can name one male needlepointer- Rosie Greer.

Sixty odd years ago I knitted purses for my 3rd grade teacher and school principal. Does that count?

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#15

Rob Wallace

There ARE still some woodworking programs alive...

Rob Wallace

In our town (Ames, Iowa) there are still wood shop classes taught at the High School as "Industrial Arts", in addition to a couple CAD courses (....metalwork and auto repair are long gone). Our High School is an anomaly in that this program is still alive and well, and believe it or not, the woodworking classes are all FULL. I was very happy that my son texted me with excitement this past spring during registration that he was able to get in to the "Woods I" class for his sophomore year!! I have a very good relationship with both woodworking instructors, and every year for the past 6 years or so, I do one or two woodturning demonstrations for their woodworking classes. There are 4 lathes in the Ames High School wood shop, and there are sign-up sheets for each lathe that are scheduled weeks in advance; the lathes are almost never idle, and those students taking the woodworking classes and doing woodturning are not only boys - there are a significant number of girls also taking wood shop! On the local cable channel from the school district twice a year there are images broadcast to the community of the fantastic projects the students do, and I'd estimate that at least 30-35 percent of them are turned items. I do whatever I can to promote this program to parents, and have even spoken at past School Board meetings to preserve the woodworking courses in the face of budget cuts.

Even though it seems like woodworking classes have become so widely de-prioritized and are often one of the first things to go in recent school budgets, the fact is that students will take these classes, and get very useful life skills and thought process learning from them. The unfortunate situation is that even if school boards agreed how useful these classes are for students and wanted to add them [back?] to their curriculum, the start-up costs in equipping a new shop "from scratch" are so prohibitive as to be deemed next to impossible for cash-strapped school districts to even consider such a plan. Once the program is closed, and equipment sold off, etc., it likely is gone for good.

I certainly hope that our wood shop program continues, but the teacher responsible for keeping the program alive all this time is nearing retirement age, and finding a "youthful" adequately trained and certified replacement for him will be a real challenge! (What student teachers are being certified in Industrial Arts these days?)

Unfortunately, the few programs that are still out there are in a downward spiral, from which, I fear, there will be no alternate path but total extinction of woodworking programs.

For those of us that were fortunate enough to have gone through such a program (....for me, ALL four years of HS!), it will likely remain as a fond memory and for many, the start to a life-long experience of working with wood.

Rob Wallace

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#16

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

Dale Miner

Carol,

OVWG has their share of OF's, but for the most part, not many grumpy OF's.

Just a guess, but it seems we have probably less than 10 percent female members (200+ total membership).

A two hour drive to sit with grumpy OF's doesn't sound like a "need to do that again" to me either.

Hope you can make it up here sometime, promise, no grumpy. The OF thing is in my shop whenever I am.

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#17

Re: Why do Little Boys Play with Toy Trucks,

Jennifer Indy.USA

I played with toy trucks, and GI Joe and Johnny West dolls. Had my very own Green Bay Packers uniform that I slept in, and I terrorized my sisters Barbies.

Guess that's why I'm a woodturner?

;)

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#18

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

Karen F.

Carole- If you ever in San Diego please stop by our club meeting. Our President is Nan Bushley and I can think of at least 20 more female turners out here but our club has about 180+ members so that isn't a large percentage. I can tell you we welcome anyone and everyone with open arms and a big smile and our regular club meeting cost you $0. We have numerous snow birds from out in the colder weather so I invite anyone who needs a break from the snow to come and visit us out here. BTW- it's about 72 degrees during the day.

As for me- I have had major mood swings in my life choices. I have been a cocktail waitress, Deputy Sheriff, Hair Stylist (and Mom) and I just retired from my second trip working the Jails as a Supervisor. I see more women turning out here but there are also a lot more people living (and driving) out here too.

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#19

Steven Antonucci

Oddly enough, I had a Packers uniform too?

Steven Antonucci

My mom couldn't find our teams, so she bought what she could lay hands on. Packers and Colts...for a bunch of Vikings, Steelers, and Giants fans!

Now, I will be picking up a set of horns to wear in Wisconsin if I can just figure out how to put a faceshield on them :)

Steve

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#20

Re: Why do Little Boys Play with Toy Trucks,

John Lucas

Jen I talked to Kim Winkle yesterday and she said that when she grew up her two sisters got perfume for birthdays and she got a new tool. Guess what, she's a woodturner. :)

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#21

Brad Vietje

Our Club Has More Than Most

Brad Vietje

Good Question, Charlie.

There are so many influences, it may be hard to narrow it down much. Many women just weren't exposed to much in the way of shop class or power tools when they were girls -- probably a holdover from a more sexist past -- and in recent years the opportunities through our school systems have largely evaporated, so younger women and girls aren't exposed much, but neither are younger men and boys.

At the same time, there has been a huge shift from manufacturing things here (in the US) to making things in other countries with cheap labor, and the focus has been on teaching design, engineering, etc... We are starting to have entire generations that don't know how to "DO" anything manually, but are wizards at computer technology. In the long run, this globalized marketplace will be shown to be a very bad thing, indeed. Without abundant and inexpensive oil and natural gas, and without perpetual growth in the worldwide economy (an impossible scenario), the whole system comes tumbling down, and we're left with very little capacity to make anything close to home.

Without getting into the economic parts, the net result is that fewer and fewer Americans know how to work with their hands -- whatever the reasons. That means we have a mission to demonstrate how much fun, how practical, and how creative woodturning can be. If we get our EZ-UP's and mini lathes out there at craft shows, farmer's markets, woodworking events and county fairs, we can continue to inspire, excite, and recruit new members.

My local club (Twin State Woodturners, St Johnsbury VT and Littleton, NH areas) has about 40 members, and at least 10 are women. I'm recruiting a new member in her 20's who went to a vocational high school, but didn't get any exposure to woodturning, though she did learn to make jewelry and work with glass. I think there are quite a few female crafters who are skilled at pottery and/or ceramics, sculpture, jewelry-making, etc... that would probably be thrilled to give turning a try if invited to a meeting or to a public demonstration.

If a club decides they want more participation from women, and learns how to recruit them, they then have to make sure women feel welcome and respected, and not left out (or worse -- the freshest and juciest steaks to arrive at the meat market!). I've seen lots of OF's, but only rarely GOF's, as Carole reported. Turners have always been the most exceptionally friendly and helpful crowd in my experience, though I can't see this through a women's eyes.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#22

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#23

Mike Stafford

Disclaimer!!!!

Mike Stafford

Nick Tuzzolino said that he could not distinguish female turners from male turners. I have no such problem. I would never make such a statement. I am old but I can still distinguish the sexes. I have lived to the ripe old age I am because I learned not to make such statements.

Dear friends, it is with great regret that I report the untimely passing of Nick Tuzzolino who mistook a female woodturner for a male OF woodturner. May he sand in peace! :b :D

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#24

Re: Disclaimer!!!!

Nick Tuzzolino

Mea culpa!!

Re: Why Aren't There More Women Turners?

#25

Re: Was that supposed to be funny?

Donna Banfield

Yes, you hit a nerve. Just because a woman can do something a man can - just as well and sometimes better -- they're probably a guy in drag.

I've dealt with that kind of crap all my life -- all 54 years of it.

Here's why there aren't as many female woodturners. This is based on my own observations and just my opinion. It's easy to turn wood. Put a piece of wood between centers and use a tool to remove the wood. Simple. But it's hard -- very hard to do it well. It takes years. Hundreds and hundreds and thousands of hours standing in front of the lathe, practicing and making mistakes and learning from the mistakes.

What are women doing with their time? They're raising the family, and cooking the meals, and taking care of their sick kids, and driving them to soccer and baseball and ballet and music recitals, and cleaning the house... and oh yeah, working a full-time job, too. Yes, I've no doubt that there are a few of you guys that do some of that too, but if you are really being honest...truly honest...the wives and mothers bear the bulk of the responsiblity.

So what you're suggesting is that Jennifer Shirley, Andi Wolfe, Molly Winton and Marilyn Campbell, (just to name a few outstanding female woodturners) look like guys? I suspect their partners would disagree with you.

Rant off.