Black finials
Dick Hines
Last night on the chat Wally Dickerman asked a good question. Why are finials mostly black. No one there could give a good answer.
Any ideas. I bet there will be tons.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Black finials
Dick Hines
Last night on the chat Wally Dickerman asked a good question. Why are finials mostly black. No one there could give a good answer.
Any ideas. I bet there will be tons.
black doesn't compete
Steven Antonucci
I've seen a lot of turnings where the finial is one wood, the "cap" is another wood, the vessel is a third and so on... too many cooks in the kitchen.
The black finial is a supporting player. It is my personal belief that it is almost impossible to compose a better piece than with just a simple black finial.
My .02
Steve
Re: black doesn't compete
Bill Howatt
It also doesn't compete with itself. Finials can be relatively busy and if there is a pronounced grain in the finial it makes it too busy causing the finial detail to be lost. Something like the dazzle camouflage on ships in WW1.
Bill
Re: Black finials
Bill Turpin in WNC mountains
I believe that the physical traits of Afr. blackwood lends itself to the fine detailed finials that we love. The fact that it is black is just an added benefit. Hard, shiny, strong when fine. Its cost keeps finials small, better, and not too large!
Re: Black finials
Nick Todd
With black being a neutral color it doesn't detract from the shape or the figure or color of the piece.
nick
Re: Black finials
Dick Hines
Then why not holly? I am playing the Devil's Advicate here.
Re: Black finials
Nick Todd
I think it is the same, except for some reason people perfer black finials.
Why Not Holly
DickL in Tampa
The eye is drawn to bright/white things. If one has an even slightly darker turning with a white final, the finial is the the hero - point of attraction.
Personal preference?
Ellis Walentine
I'm sure there's a more articulate answer, Dick, but I just prefer the look of a dark wood as a finial. Call it gravitas or something. I've experimented with light-colored finials and don't like them as well as the dark ones.
Ellis
Re: Black finials
John Lucas
Dick I suppose it depends on what I'm making. I don't make many hollow vessels and usually they are open with no finials. Since most of the woods I use for these are light I choose a dark finial. I use black because I don't often have exotic woods to choose from so I stain them with Indian Ink most of the time. consequently they are black.
When I make boxes if I put a finial on it is either made from the same wood or I choose a contrasting wood.
For Christmas ornaments I almost always choose a contrasting wood and since I make the Balls usually from darker woods I make the finials very light. If the Ball is made from light colored woods then I choose darker exotics if I have them.
Black finials can be easier -
Ken Vaughan
When turning with lighter woods, the colors in the woods can be problematic on finials. Fieblings USMC Black makes it all neutral black.
I will acknowledge that when I can find it, a scrap of boxwood is a joy to turn details -- such nice wood.
Re: Black finials can be easier -
Dick Hines
Instering answers. Wally brough up the question and just got me to thinking. I am in the middle of an order for 16 globe ornaments with finials. The lady wanted them turned out of a walnut tree that came from her late father's farm. So everything will be dark.
Turning walnut finials is not as easy as turning blackwooh finials 
Re: Black finials can be easier -
Brad Vietje
Like John reports, I use woods of contrasting colors. I've done some Walnut ornaments with Sugar Maple, Yellow Birch, White Birch, Eastern Hophornbeam, etc... and would certainly use Holly if it grew around here. I've also done some with Apple sapwood with good success -- I cut small squares or turn small dowels when fresh and green, and cross-stack & air-dry these so they retain the nice light color. Apple can take fine details very well, and can be very pretty when light colored or streaked with heart- and sap-wood.
I hope you can post some pic's of the ornaments, Dick, I'll bet they are beautiful when you're done with 'em.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Black finials
Keith Tompkins
Hi Dick, I think the color black creates a strong silhouette, and just oozes with class. Many color combinations create a garish effect, and appear to have very little thought process involved...but black works with nearly any combination. Sometimes I view a piece made with contrasting woods, and I ask myself Why? Did the maker run out of one type of wood? What look was he trying to create? Even more confusing is a piece with three types of wood...the form, the lid, then the finial from different species. (?)