Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Turning tool steel?

Posts

Turning tool steel?

#1

Turning tool steel?

Tony - Memphis

I'm thinking about making a skewchi gouge to play with. What is the best material to use? I see O1, A2, M2 at McMaster Carr, but I'm not sure which one works best. Thanks!

Tony

Re: Turning tool steel?

#2

Re: Turning tool steel?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I use pre-hardened M-2 cutter bits. They are cheap and can be worked with grinders or a torch. Bend by heating red hot. They will keep their temper. It takes factory conditions about 2700°F to properly hardenen it.

Re: Turning tool steel?

#3

Re: Turning tool steel?

john lucas

Tony A2 and M2 are high speed steel and can't be hardened at home unless you have a special oven made for that purpose. I use 0-1 or W-1. O-1 is oil hardened. I mostly use W-1 which is water hardened simply because it's less messy than oil.

You can use prehardened steel like Bill mentioned but be aware you can't cut it with anything short of cutoff wheels. If all you need to do is shape the tip by grinding they work fine.

Re: Turning tool steel?

#4

Steven Antonucci

All of them will work

Steven Antonucci

For the weekend tinkerer, I think there is too much focus on "the best, the right".

Any one of those steels will allow you to figure out if you want a skewchigouge (I have one that I made and almost never touch). The small scale that you are working at (namely, one of an item) gives you the ability to fail cheaply no matter which you choose. If you had to make 10,000 of them for mass market, I'd worry about all of the things you mentioned.

O1 is cheap and usually available locally. Start there. I do not properly harden mine, and they still cut. Go figure. (yes, all steel is harder than all wood and will cut it regardless of heat treating).

If you google heat treating O1, you can quickly make one and figure out if better steel would be a +1... mine will eventually be reground into something else...

Steve

Re: Turning tool steel?

#5

Re: Turning tool steel?

Craig Daymon

Contact Doug Thompson. He has 3/8" (and maybe 1/2") tool blanks for very reasonable. They are hardened and the same quality steel as his other tools.

http://www.thompsonlathetools.com/tooltype.asp?TYPE=OTHER

Otherwise, get drill blanks, not drill rod, from McMaster or Enco. The drill blanks are hardened HSS, usually about 6" long, which is a reasonable length for what you're making. It would be nice if they were offered in say an 8" length, but we're not their target market.

http://www.use-enco.com/CGI/INPDFF?PMPAGE=18&PARTPG=INLMK32

-Craig

Re: Turning tool steel?

#6

Re: Turning tool steel?

robo hippy

Doug has 1/2 round 'fluteless gouges' which I have been using for a year or two, from 5/8 to 3/8 wide. Mostly I use them for the transition in bowls, but also on tops, and for rolling some beads and coves. I prefer them more with a ) shape nose. I did take one and grind it like a spindle/detail gouge, and love it. I used one once in a workshop with Allen Batty, and it is what the Sorby Spindle Master was supposed to be. Works much better.

robo hippy

Re: Turning tool steel?

#7

Re: Turning tool steel?

Josh Bowman

I made myself one from a length of drill rod from Fastenel. I also made some pyramid tools and other odds and ends. The edge seems to hold well and the rod was cheap.

Re: Turning tool steel?

#8

Re: Turning tool steel?

Doug Turner

I use 8"x1/4dia prehardened m2 round stock available at ENCO for less tha $3 a rod. I have made a skewgie, a detail gouge similar to Cindy D's, a pyramid tool, and a 1/4 skew. They all hold an edge very well. If I remeber correctly, the blanks are listed under the category, hss tool blanks for metal turning.

Doug Turner

Re: Turning tool steel?

#9

Re: Turning tool steel?

jerryw

Bill: red hot in a dark room is about 1100F. In a lighted room it is much hotter. Hardening temperature for M2 is about 2150F. Tempering temperature is about 1025F. Your hardened M2, shaped with a torch is no longer well hardened, and is probably low 50s HRC. It will cut, but not as well as you may like.

Jerry

Re: Turning tool steel?

#10

Re: Turning tool steel?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I stand corrected as to temp. The M-2 that I have bent was back from the end by about 1/2" to 3/4". With a fine, hot torch you can keep the cutting end cooler than 2150°. The bent ones that I have made were for hollowing Christmas ornaments. Not much edge longevity needed there.

Re: Turning tool steel?

#11

Re: Turning tool steel?

Terry Scott

I used a firring pin out of and old Ramset gun to make a skew gee works a treat

Re: Turning tool steel?

#12

Re: Turning tool steel?

John Lucas

Made this last night out of just regular steel. It's for a video I'm doing on skews and it won't be used very often. I did harden it but since it's just mild steel it probably won't hold an edge that well. Still I be it will surprise me how well it does. As Steve said, steel is harder than wood even without any hardening.

Took me about 30 minutes to make this. I would normally polish the top more but all I need is the edge to be sharp for testing purposes and it will shave hair right now.


Re: Turning tool steel?

#13

Thanks all!

Tony - Memphis

I'm anxious to get some metal and try this out. I made a small cove cuttter based on an article in Woodturning (I think). That works very well. It's nice to be able to make things that you just want to try.

I have a background in metals (mechanical engineer by day), but that was 16 years ago and mostly castings, titanium, etc. We made race car parts. Wish I still had access to the shop at my last job! I could make all sorts of fun stuff! Went from race cars to shipping boxes. We don't have any tools here!

Tony