Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Flat Topped HF

Posts

Flat Topped HF

#1

Flat Topped HF

charlie belden

It was too hot to turn (low to mid 90s) during the day. Started this one around 10pm and finished it up. Did the pyro work early this morning (supposed to be in the mid to high 90s today).

Flat topped HF are tricky. Getting the top flat and keeping the hard edge at the rim being the tricky part. the wood is manzaneta, the finish - car wax.




On a larger piece, the figure in the wood would be shown off on the flat top. At this scale, it's shown a little bit, but not as dramatic as it would be at a larger size.


Though flaws are quite obvious in the photos, their barely noticable if at all when looking at the actual piece. I notice them because I saw them when doing the pyro work - while wearing am OptiVisor that magnifies EVERYTHING - as does the camera.

My critique:

The lip of the raised rim is TOO THICK. Makes the piece look chunky instead of semi-delicate

Should have bought the finest Ball Tip pyro pen. I used the 1/32" Ball Tip and it's just a little too large for this sized piece.

The piece has a very small bead on the bottom. Gives a little lift to the look but would probably have been better to go with a Round Bottom look.

I should've done the pyroed band just below the rim of the piece rather than as far down the side as I did. A thin area of wood just below the rim to set off the pyro work and then just polished wood below that.

The opening should've been smaller. It WAS when I started hollowing, but got widened while I was cutting up under the top (yes - it actually is hollowed out thinner than the lip of the opening makes it look.

Since, at this scale, the figure in the wood isn't shown off, I probably should've done a narrow band of pyroed texture some where between the neck and the rim of the piece. The contrast of a smooth wood surface and a textured pyroed surface might have been interesting.

The profile has a flat section at the top and then transitions into a curve. Having a contiunous curve would probably have looked better.

Should have been a bit more careful when making the cuts for the side pyroed band. But it was late and I was tired. Should have waited.

Most stressful part of doing this piece was parting it off. Used the single bevel bench chisel, with the back of the chisel towards the piece and did cross grain slicing. Get that back's flat surface off the surface being sliced and it would be Catch City - the resulting spiral cut likely to run up the side of the piece. Sort of like dropping a piece of bread with jelly. Almost ALWAYS it'll land on the jelly side ; )

Comments, suggestions, constructive criticism welcomed.

Re: Flat Topped HF

#2

Ellis Walentine

Meta comment

Ellis Walentine

Advertently or inadvertently, you've demonstrated another benefit of making miniatures (besides that they are quick and they don't use much wood) and that is that they can serve as "sketches" for full-scale forms. I have always sketched tiny thumbnail drawings of furniture pieces prior to going to the drawing board, and I see your miniatures as an analogous process. Whether or not you proceed to make these forms at a larger scale, you are using them to view and critique your designs, and that has value.

Ellis

Re: Flat Topped HF

#3

Re: Meta comment

charlie belden

Yes, inadvertently I found that miniatures are great for prototyping / sketching ideas for full sized pieces. But I'm quick to recognize and then use things I learn, intentionally or inadvertently.

Unlike 2D sketches, miniatures give you more persepectives and with more persepectives, shortcomings are easier to see - and correct in the next miniature "sketch". Subtle things you wouldn't think of or be aware of, like shadow lines, become more apparent with a miniature - under different lighting conditions. Actually being able to see color contrasts between polished finished wood and textured areas are another designing benefit.

Miniatures could be a great means for teaching advanced beginners as they transition from between centers simple spindle work to chuck held forms turning, turning techniques being easier to learn than developing an eye for what looks right - and what doesn't. Doing miniatures is also much quicker than doing full sized pieces - and generates far fewer curlies and chips to have to clean up ; )

One of the things that I've found is different with doing miniatures is that refining a profile - with sand paper - is less prone to OVERCUTTING I often do on full sized turning. You can quickly sneak up on curve transition refinement by sanding rather than cutting with a gouge or skew.

I'm not sure the actual turning cuts are transferable to full sized pieces - the longer a flowing curve, the harder it is to turn that long flowing curve. With miniatures, almost all the tool control comes at the hands. For full sized pieces, the whole body gets involved and must be controlled.