Turned this for a friends parents. They're very devout Catholics and I think this chalice will have a significance for them.
Hopefully I won't loose it before it gets to them ; )
Tried a smaller version, but cherry just wouldn't let me get the detail I was after.
Getting semi-decent images of these things is difficult with an older $100 digital camera, even with photo floor lights and a tripod, may be beyond my camera.
Charlie Your doing great on those. I went through the same thought that cherry just wouldn't go small enough. However when I got really really tiny it turned out the be the wood that made the smallest. I think it has to do with weaknesses in the wood itself. Some parts of the same small piece of wood will be tougher than others.
When I started getting small I kept breaking the ebony goblets so I changed to yellow heart. It seems much stiffer. Then it started breaking so I tried holly, too flimsy, flexed and broke, so I grabbed one of the small splinters of ebony and it worked to go even smaller. Then is started breaking, I think because it had almost microscopic pores and if one of those ended up in the rim or stem it broke. I went back to the cherry that I first tried and then made the smallest one. It's height it approx the thickness of your dime.
Sorry to ask the dumb questions, but are these all endgrain? And, regarding your photos, do you have your camera set at its highest possible resolution? The pix look grainier and fuzzier than they should. I don't know if it's resolution or optics or both.
You're going to need magnifying goggles soon if these get any smaller.
and turn the INSIDE first with a home made hollowing tool that "C shaped)
then the outside with an 1/8" parting tool to round to CLOSE,
1/4" bench chisel to get even closer,
and 600 then 1000 grit sand paper to final shape.
After doing the inside, I waxed the inside with car wax (Mother's Ooriginal Caliifornia Gold Car Wax , which has carnuba, a pale pink dye and a solvent). Polish the inside with a paper towel at high rpms while there's still plenty of wood left behind the opening.
Basically the trick is to start on the end, complete a section, finish it and then NEVER GO BACK. If you turn the full profile first, then try and go back to fine tune things - it's almost quaranteed that the piece will break off.
This Small Thing seems to have some of its own Guidelines.
Size Threshold Limitations
Size vs Form:
Too small and the tinyness of the piece becomes the focus of attention. At some smallness, the form turned is merely recognized, the details of its profile overlooked or ignored and the interest level drops off to nothing.
Size vs Strength of Material:
Too small and the strength of the wood and one's fine motor skills limit the profile possibilities and thus the interest of the piece, other than its minute size.
Size vs How The Piece is Experienced
Small pieces seem to be experienced differently than "normal sized" pieces. Small pieces are seen more as little gems, the profile, details and general color of the wood noted and perhaps appreciated rather than figure/grain of the wood.
Size and Turning vs Machining:
At some size, for a given form, the limits of most humans' fine motor skills, visaul acuity and the tools that can be used "hand held" are exceeded. To go smaller, the process of creating the piece becomes more that of machining than turning. At that point the aesthetics of the piece is probably lost.
Size - Percieved vs Actual
When doing famiiar forms in miniature, the proportionate egg shell thinness of walls becomes impractical. Egg shells, though very thin, have a structural strength built in that's required for the egg shell to do its job - protect its content, yet release its content at the appropriate time.
Wood, on the other hand essentially has to support what's above it - resist compressions - and to some extent, bending. It doesn't need to resist lateral compression or tension much if at all.
BUT - you can deceive the viewer into seeing what he/she EXPECTS to see and not what's ACTUALLY there. Thin a bowl at and near the rim, and the viewer will assume the walls of the piece are just as thin everywhere else. The calabash bowl I posted earlier does just that. At the rim and half way down the sides, the walls ARE very thin. The walls of the rest of the piece are two or three times thicker. Even if you could feel the thickness between thumb outside and finger inside, you probably wouldn't notice the change in thickness since, at the rim, you have both tactile as well as visual confirmation of the thinness.
The scale of an object seems to bring along with it its own aesthetics. Go BIG and BIGNESS dominates the experience. Go tiny and tinyness dominates the experience. Seems that at the miniature scale there's a middle ground - the piece conveys most of the experience a "normal sized" version would convey.
Got any observations on the aesthetics of pieces in terms of size/scale? Care to share?
Re: Same way as the plates, bowls, vase & cookie j
Ellis Walentine
Got any observations on the aesthetics of pieces in terms of size/scale? Care to share?
Thanks for those insights, Charlie. I would agree that the middle ground is where viewers are most accustomed to viewing turned work. We had big yesterday with those 9-foot turned log assemblies, and your tiniest items are definitely small (though not as small as the pieces John Lucas showed us at the Hartford symposium a couple years ago: those literally required a magnifying glass to see any detail at all, at least to these eyes).
My answer is "I dunno." Your delving into this realm has certainly opened a lot of new issues around here. Technically, it must be an intriguing exercise to learn the specific challenges associated with work this small. Aesthetically, I think you are still pretty much free to impose your aesthetic, except in matters of proportionality like the eggshell thinness you mentioned and the thickness of the stem because of wood pore structure, etc. But these aesthetics are relative to the scale. I think that most viewers want to be able to see and enjoy the work at a scale that is more accessible. You might overcome that by displaying these pieces somehow under magnification, or otherwise guiding the eye.
I don't know if you recall Steve Paulsen, a California turner who used to make some pretty exciting shadowbox diaramas with his miniature turnings. This format provided a larger framework that drew the eye to the compositions, and in turn to the components.
Just free-associating here. It's an interesting topic. Thanks for carrying it forward for us.
You failed to mention that Eugen Schlaak has EIGHTY SIX PAGES of images on WOW - 15 images per page!
I found two images of his miniatures (so far) that reference using modified dental tools - but no accompanying images of the tools nor any descriptions.
It's easy to make miniature tools, I have tons of them starting at 1/4" and going down to .008" The good thing is the quality of the steel is really not critical at all. Just grind the tip so it resembles a cutting edge. You can bend them if needed to get into hollow vessels. Gouges don't need a flute, just polish the upper surface and they cut just fine for this kind of work. Here's a photo of my .012" tools. One is a skew and the other is my gouge.
You brought up an often overlooked topic - presentation.
Art schools emphasize approaches, methods and techniques - and usually completely overlook two key topics - presentation and preservation. Wife #2 was a custom picture framer. With the right matting and frame, a so- so painting, water color or charcoal could be made to appear much better. And if the piece was to have glass - the glass was held off the mat and piece - with UV protection in the glass, and anti-glare glass used. If the piece was a water color, she stressed the importance of using Acid Free Paper. Water colors on non-acid free paper would destroy the colors over time. She also made a point of using archival paper to cover the back of the framed piece to provide a barrier to air pollutants.
She did a bit of framing of pieces that required seeing the front AND back of the object - usually a document. For that, she used a Three Layers technique - glass up front, the matted document next, and a stepped back mirror for the back - all in a thick frame (actually a box). She mounted a cut nautalus shell for me this way, allowing you to see the chambers pattern inside the shell as well as the smooth outside of the shell with its pale banding pattern.
I think even pieces in galleries - up on pedestals - usually aren't presented all that well. At the SJ symposium, the Walk In The Woods exhibit was "less than perfect" - narrow pedestals and walls with door frames, folding screens with dark colored frames and a dark and light patterned rug made it very difficult to get good shots of pieces, without a very distracting background.
Bihn Pho and Clay Foster have two distinctly different approaches to presenting their pieces, Pho creating pieces that are essentially small stage sets for the focal piece, Foster setting his pieces on a largish, integral pedestal. Both build in Reserved Space for their main piece - and make it part of the piece.
We THINK our creative work is done when the piece is off the lathe and finished. But it's the NEXT step - the presentation - that will strongly affect how others will experience the piece. THAT can be a "Oh, another bowl - NEXT!" - or - THAT grabs me!"
The idea of framing miniatures and hanging them - with proper accompanying lighting - mounted at eye height - seems far better than a bunch of miniatures in a cabinet or on a display table or pedestal.
One of the things about miniatures is their potential ability to get people close, really close, where they can be EXAMINED rather than looked at and the viewer moves on.