For those who attended demo's at the AAW, how did the new video set up work out. It looks interesting. We need to redo our video set up for both clubs but I think this might be a little too expensive. Still I like the concept and want to know if you thought it worked well.
But if you can, next week is the Smoky Mtn meeting. We are going to start using a system like was used in Nashville. He made it based on what he remembered and man this thing looks and works great. So if you get a chance... Tuesday night......
John, I went to four demos, and all were consistent on how the videos functioned. My frustration with each was that when the operator changed from one camera angle to another, the delay was way too long, then each required a refocus. drove me nuts.
The camera setups worked fine. The quality of the video part of the demonstrations depended on the quality of the camera operators. On some demonstrations the video portion was really good. In other demonstrations, the camera operators were not well trained and the video portions really suffered. In one of the demonstrations that I attended, the camera operator actually sat in the corner and made no attempt to follow the demonstrator, until the demonstrator prodded him to do what he was supposed to be doing.
It is true that when one camera was switched to another, there was about a 4-second delay, but that wasn't a really big deal.
Bottom line: The equipment was great, and with good operators the show was really good, but sometimes the operators needed a lot more training.
The operators have always been the good and weak link. Don't know how to get around that. The operator either cares and does a good job or simply wants a good seat up front and doesn't. We tried at the TAW to use video students from the local college. They at least didn't fall asleep but they don't understand turning and what the crowd needs to see.
At the AAW level they are still all volunteers and most do a pretty good job considering there isn't any time to train them. I thank them very much but wish the few that don't do a decent job would just not volunteer.
I was just wondering how the overall system worked.
Personally I hate autofocus. It is getting better but it still isn't set up to shoot spinning wood and often searches for the correct focus. My new D5100 has a follow focus feature. I haven't tried it out on turning tools yet but when you lock it on a persons face it will follow them around the room and stay in focus. that's really cool.
The facility ( in the heart of silicon valley ) had vga only projectors.
AAW had to buy a bunch of converters HDMI=>VGA.
The 4-6 second delay (with a blue screen on the projector ) was due either to HDMI handshaking or sync issues with the projector.
Word was that an converter that did not have the delay problem would have cost a bunch more.
The frames holding the lights and cameras looked nice but it was a challenge for the operators and demonstrators when the action moved out from behind the lathe.
The camera mounts were flexible within about a 2 foot radius and sometimes needed to be relocated to get a good camera angle.
There were the standard problems of using a projector/screen with lights overhead washing out the image.
The screens were pretty low so that the back rows had trouble seeing the bottom third of the screen.
Elevating the screens was not an option due to fire marshal/facility/cost issues.
At the open meeting, they discussed making the frames available to clubs as part of a volume buying deal and providing the specs of the av gear.
The projector screens and my outdated camera had a problem when my flash washes out the image on the screen. With large screen TVs flat screens hooked to the camera (as at Utah) I can photograph the enlarged image on the wall without washout.
A number of comments I heard were about the little white squares that kept appearing around faces. I was told this was a glitch where the face recognition software kept turning itself on.
Most of the camera assistants were doing a good job. I found that I needed to get in early to get a seat on the screen side of the demo so I didn't have the camera frame work in the way of the screen.
The AAW is doing a great job at improving each year and handling a large number ot attendees.
I am going to get a lot of people that disagree with me but I have to get my 2 cents in here. I am speaking as an advocate for the participants not as a demonstrator. I would love to set a camera on the spinning wood and just do my thing with no regard for the camera position. But that does not work. One of two things need to happen for the participants to see what's going on.
1) The demonstrator must be actively directing the camera to where the best shot is to capture the event being explained.
OR
2) The camera person must be a turner that knows what to look for and take control of what shots need to be taken.
In my demos #1 is true, but many demonstrators do not have the experience or skills to do this and rely on #2. If #1 and #2 both fail the observers get the short end of the stick. It is hard enough for beginners to follow the process and jargon but if they can not see what is going on it is a total waste of time and little will be learned.
In my opinion, even if #1 or #2 happen, it is critical that the camera set up will allow a good angle to get the shot. The overhead camera systems do not work for me and I truly believe they do not work for anybody. The proper way to see what is happening is to look over the demonstrators shoulder from behind the lathe usually. Or a shot from in front of the lathe to see around the demonstrator standing in the way when they are doing the inside of a bowl. Overhead shots, or shots from the end of the lathe like those with fixed position cameras will never be as good and sometimes completely miss what's being taught. My demos includes laser use that is necessary to view from directly behind the lathe from a chest high angle.
I requested from AAW and thanks to Darrel Duer was supplied with a cam-corder with zoom and automatic focus on a mobile tripod. I used the mobile camera for 98 percent of my demo time and the stationary camera was set to view the pad board that I illustrated on. I am sure MY audience could see every bit of the action and count the hairs on the back of my hand. Without a hand held mobile camera I would have been doomed.
After each of my demos I recieved countless glowing reports on how good my demo was. I think a large part of the cudos were due to the fact they could see what I was doing.
My recommendation would be to abandon all these expensive overhead systems and go back to the basics that work better then all the glitz. A simple mobile camera works much better as long as #1 and #2 are succesful. Without #1 and #2 the overhead systems will not work either so why spend all that money.
Lyle I agree. did you see the systems they were using at the TAW symposium. That boom arm with remote zoom let us move the camera to the best position to see the cut and we didn't get in the way of the demonstrator or audience. I plan to work with Mike Zinzer who built that rig to see if we can improve on it. About the only downside is needing the room to move the whole rig and not block a screen.
I really do agree that it needs to be a collaboration between the demonstrator and camera operator. That also keeps the camera operator involved so they aren't bored either. As a demonstrator it is hard to do. You get involved with the audience and forget about the camera. Makes you understand how good professional actors and news people are.
John I do plan to visit Daryl some time. I thought I'd ask what he heard. Now that I'm retiring I can spend some quality time with Mike Z and see if we can really improve the TAW videos.
I wasn't immersed in the new camera setup deeply enough to critique it properly, but it seemed that lack of flexibility was the greatest drawback, particularly for demos that are not lathe-based, like Elizabeth Lundburg's, where she was carving and burning at a table and moving around a lot. The stationary cameras couldn't follow the action well, and the operator couldn't adjust the cameras without hanging awkwardly over the whole demo. Plus, the rigid framework confines the usable demo area to a relatively small space directly underneath it.
As Lyle said, the most instructive camera angle is often one that imitates the turner's own point of view. That way, observers aren't constantly trying to reverse what they're seeing in their minds.
In my view, it would be best to have the camera on a flexible arm that can be quickly positioned anywhere in a five foot radius and zoomed remotely, by either the operator or by the demonstrator. I saw the wrist-mounted lathe controller that Nova has for their lathes, and wondered if something like that couldn't be used by the deomnstrator for zooming purposes.
As for the flex arm, it could be arranged above, behind or at either end of the lathe, or could even be manually moved around to follow the demonstrator if he/she moved to another section of the demo area.
Just thinkin'. I'd like to see what this TAW rig looks like.
It almost sounds like you need a mobile camera person, a fixed camera, and a switcher. Both camera's feed back to a central control screen where the switcher can choose the best shot and flip to that camera to feed the projection screen, while the camera operator can focus on getting the shot. Maybe a little ear phone to take some direction from the switcher for the bigger venues.
Without all that, having the ability to have multiple camera's to feed back to a switcher who can at least choose the best camera shot before sending it to the projector would be good. Then maybe the mobile camera is not so much mobile, but does have remote zoom so that the switcher can work on the shot out of everyone's line of sight. The boom arm design then may come in handy.
Before the presentation, the presenter can give a bit of an overview of his movements to the switcher and he can then plan out the camera placement to provide the crowd with good coverage.
It would be good to find all the pieces and be able to get a package price so that clubs could possible afford it, as good video and audio make the presentation.
In case there are others who are interested in possibly using the camera system purchased by the AAW, here are a few more details involving the system:
- If you have access to the June 2012 issue of American Woodturner, you can see Deryl Duer’s article on pages 18 and 19 (“Can you see me better now?”) which explains the basics of the system.
- Although I was not a videographer at this Symposium, I attended the Videographer’s meeting on Thursday afternoon to become familiar with the system and how it worked. Deryl explained the basics of the new system, and told us that of the number of units purchased (don’t recall the number), two of them had been severely damaged in shipping and could not be used. Despite the newness of these units, and the ‘first time’ situation of getting them assembled and running, these guys did yeoman’s service in setting up and adjusting the equipment in time for the first demos on Friday morning! Although there were problems, they are to be sincerely commended for getting this stuff ready in multiple rooms in such a short time!
- The AAW was under pressure to assure that EVERY lathe had a polycarbonate safety shield in place before any turning actions could be performed – local laws dictated that any symposium activities requiring cutting action MUST have a safety shield in place – including all similar activities in the vendor’s area. The shield was included in the design of the camera support system.
- At the Member’s Meeting on Sunday morning, we were informed that the AAW invested about $ 40,000 on the new system. This is a significant investment, and we need feedback on how we could make it work better. All of this discussion is very useful.
- Several demonstrators lamented that fixed camera positions might work for some demos, but the limited flexibility of having no “floor” camera was a major problem. Several here have already mentioned this.
- Having a dedicated monitor for the demonstrator was a GREAT improvement!
- For tall woodturners (over 6 ft), the relatively low top bar (which included a bank of track lights), seemed to really get in the way – the height of the cage unit might be limiting for many applications, and longer uprights might be considered as a significant improvement.
- Turners who needed to turn off the tailstock end of the lathe were constrained by the presence of the “cage” around the lathe; it was possible to swing the tailstock end of the cage out of the way, but this caused major problems with wires, lights, and camera positions. We might need a modified cage design for demonstrators who request tailstock access.
- For my rotations, I used Powerpoint on my laptop, and for this to work, I needed to unplug the VGA feed to the projector from the switching unit to get a signal from my laptop to project. Thus, it would not be possible to switch back and forth with this system (even with the already mentioned delay) between turning on the lathe and showing a Powerpoint if one wanted to. For me this is a significant problem. Furthermore, the set-up as completed provided essentially no sufficient cable length to accommodate use of a laptop – before my Saturday morning 8:00 am rotation I was rushing to loosen zip-tied cables enough so I could connect my computer to the projector. Also there was no support available on which to place a laptop, so I needed to pull chairs, boxes, crates, etc. into service to position my laptop’s VGA output within 3 ft of the zip-tied video feed cable. It seemed use of computers was not even considered in the design.
- Depending on the placement in the room, it was impossible for some members of the audience to have a clear view of the screen. For example, during my Special Interest Night ‘Gizmos and Gadgets’ activity, at least 30 people were craning their necks to see the screen while trying to look around the “cage”. As has been mentioned, the screens were set too low, and it was not possible to raise them without extra labor and expense.
- The camera support cage also included a small shelf that held the switching and other electronics – this was located at the tailstock end of the late, and I argue that the shelf should be at the HEADSTOCK end of the cage, since this is a little used area by the demonstrator – many turners need to involve the tailstock end of the lathe (particularly with sliding headstocks, or when using long boring bars). A little more flexibility is needed here about where the video controls are located.
For those that might be considering putting a similar system together, several of these issues should be examined for creative solutions to these problems.
If I am elected to the AAW Board this fall, I hope to be able to take a more active role in Symposium planning, and would like to continue to work on improvements to the video system. Having a top-notch video system is a MAJOR requirement to creating a great learning situation for all attendees at our symposium!
I hope some of these observations will help others who may be considering their own video system upgrade.
Being both a demonstrator and videographer provided a thorough experience with using the new video structures. Here are a couple of my reflections:
1- a first prototype -- a good first-try and with some modifications, might provide excellent video
coverage.
a. Pros:
-having the adjustable over-head lights was very helpful.
-the internal monitor was very useful to the demonstrator.
-ad hoc re-configuration useful
b. Cons:
-depending upon the acoustics, isolated demonstrator from audience
-couldn’t hear questions/comments
-felt as if being in an isolation box.
-cameras need fully-articulating boom and zoom control with remote control
-too complicated -- required army to setup -- no design diagrams/instructions
-switching delay unacceptable -- this is a 'MUST FIX' hot issue
-needed significant reconfig for non-lathe demos
-too tiring for videographer -- obviously designed without considering operator
2- the 7-10 second-delay in switching cameras made having a second camera almost useless.
a. Either you’d have to ask the demonstrator to freeze for the camera to catch up or magically
time the switch.
b. Why the need for HD cameras (and expensive switching equip to overcome delay) if electrons
end up at a VGA-projector? Didn’t get this config especially since recording was not a
requirement.
3- not having the ability to re-position or zoom the cameras from the operator's station severely limited
the value of videoing, and thus value to the audience.
a. current design required a 6’ or taller videographer/very tiring for videographer who videoed
many back to back sessions.
b. configuring a camera boom with remote movement and zoom would most likely make the
structure a valuable tool.
c. operator often had to stand with arms over-head, almost on-top of demonstrator for hours.
d. another 'MUST FIX' hot item
4 the requirement for a polycarbonate shield could be met with a simple shield-stand as was
setup for some demonstrators and vendors
a. shield wasn’t necessary for non-lathe demonstrations.
b. the video structures, however, were easily reconfigured (if a wrench was magically produced
from someone's pocket ;>) -- shield easily removed/front-bar lowered for non-turning demos.
c. scheduling dedicated rooms for non-lathe demos might help with having to reconfigure for
each demo.
So, as with most prototypes, hopefully it's back at the drawing board where we get to look at the successes and re-engineer the failures, and develop the next generation video structure with the goal to improve the audience's access to what the demonstrator has to offer as well as keep the operators safe and healthy.