Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Inside bowl rests...

Posts

Inside bowl rests...

#1

Inside bowl rests...

robo hippy

I watched several bowl turning demos in San Jose. I was amazed that a lot of turners prefer to use a straight tool rest on the inside of bowls, preferring to extend the bowl gouges out much farther off the rest rather than using the curved rests. Reasons vary from 'it is inconvenient' to 'i keep running into the post'. I do find this a bit confusing, because when we teach, we continually tell students to keep the tool rest close to the wood for better tool control. I am wondering if this preference is due more to the inside tool rests just are not made in the proper shapes than anything else.

This is my favorite shape. I love the recurve on both ends. The one near the rim allows you to work all parts of the rim, then turn down the sides of the bowl, and then another recurve to go through the transition and across the bottom of the bowl. The main down sides to it are the very wide cross section, and it being made with cast iron rather than the drill rod tops.

http://www.woodturnerscatalog.com/store/Lathe_Accessories___Tool_Rests___S_Curve_Bowl_Rest___s_curve_rest?Args=

I have the Oneway bowl rests. The large one is fine, but does tend to chatter a bit when you are working out on the very end except for all but very light cuts. Shape is okay. It is not an arc of a circle, but a slightly straight section, then the curve. If they were to weld a support finger under the rest, like the one under their coring blade, that would easily solve that problem. No recurve on the top, which does cause some 'interference' problems for working the rim and the inside without multiple moves of the banjo and tool rest.

I have the Robust tool rests, and I love the drill rod, there is no vibration out on the tip, no matter how big of a cut you are making. It is an arc of a circle, about 6 inch diameter. Same interference problems.

I do like that the support finger on the Robust angles away from the drill rod rather than being straight up and down, which would keep you farther away from the wood. I am trying to convince Brent to make a tool rest for inside bowls similar to the Craft Supplies rest.

What do you do on the inside of bowls? What is your favorite inside rest? What do you teach?

robo hippy

Re: Inside bowl rests...

#2

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Inside bowl rests...

Lyle Jamieson

It is my guess that most of those teaching now were influenced by production turners. The bent tool rests get in the way and there is a fiddle factor that slows you down. When most of us are doing one bowl at a time a few seconds wasted moving the tool rest out of the way is not an issue. If you like the bent go for it. Its kind of a whatever you get used to thing.

Re: Inside bowl rests...

#3

Steven Antonucci

I have a bent, but mostly use a straight one

Steven Antonucci

lazy. go figure.

Steve

Re: Inside bowl rests...

#4

Re: Inside bowl rests...

john lucas

I just do it because I don't take the time to change rests and have no problem with the gouge hanging over. A scraping cut applies more down force and would require the rest to be closer.

I do try to change tool rests when doing larger bowls but since most of mine are under 10" it's just easier to keep using 1 tool rest.

Re: Inside bowl rests...

#5

Re: Inside bowl rests...

Dick Coers

I've been looking at bent after doing an 18" dia., 6" deep bowl. Johannes Michelson has an asemetrical heavy bar tool rest that looks interesting. I am having trouble getting his site to load, sorry no link.

Re: Inside bowl rests...

#6

Re: Inside bowl rests...

robo hippy

I have looked at Johannes's tool rest, made by Robust, and it would be better for going down the inside of a deep narrow vessel, but not so much so for a more conventional bowl shape.

The thing about the Craft Supply rest is that you set it up on the rim, and then hollow out most of the inside, then for the final rim to bottom cut, just pivot it in, and not move the entire banjo. I have found that to be very efficient, and no different than moving the straight tool rest, plus, it keeps the tool cutting closer to the wood rather than cantilevered way out. I don't production turn any more, but am a firm believer in "Efficiency is intelligent laziness" and think that the proper inside bowl rest is far more efficient than a straight rest. Time savings, no difference. Cutting efficiency big difference.

When I am using the Robust or Oneway inside rests, and my gouge is hitting the vertical post, or end of the tool rest, that also happens to be the same time where I need to switch to the transition/bottom of the bowl gouge, and problem solved. However, having the proper tool rest with the recurve on the end also helps this problem.

robo hippy

Re: Inside bowl rests...

#7

Dick Hines

Re: Inside bowl rests...

Dick Hines

I have a bent tool rest but only use it on natural edge bowls. I don't like the wings flying around. I don't know if it is better than a stright one but it makes me feel better.

Re: Inside bowl rests...

#8

Re: Inside bowl rests...

Peter Hyde

I made these up about a year ago. Large pair are 14" x 1 1/2" x 1/2" cold rolled steel. Smaller ones are 12" x 1 1/4" x 1/2". Radius of curve is 18". Similar to the Oneways. Best thing I ever did. In use if you position the banjo correctly the rest can simple be flipped from inside to outside without moving the banjo. The radius I find fits most of the bowls I do from 10" to 22" and still allows a pretty close position with probably max 1" tool overhang



I made pairs so that I can put the lathe in reverse and turn from the other side when I get into reversing grains. Total cost for 6 rests (2 went to the welder) was around $80

Re: Inside bowl rests...

#9

Re: Inside bowl rests...

Philip Duffy

Use my PM curved tool rest every day on every bowl. Could not live without it as it allows precise placement of the cutting tools, and scrapers. Philip

Re: Inside bowl rests...

#10

Dick Hines

Re: Inside bowl rests...

Dick Hines

I like the paint job on you banjo Peter. It took me a few seconds to figure that the lathe is a PM and you painted the Oneway banjo to match.

Re: Inside bowl rests...

#11

Re: Inside bowl rests...

Bill Howatt

When I started turning I needed to have a curved rest so the tool would be closer to the surface but as I gained experience I found that I could maintain a good cut with a larger overhang.

A major factor on the need for a specific rest is the shape/size of the bowl.

Bill