OT - Pentacryl
Jim Breeden
Does this stuff really work? 
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT - Pentacryl
Jim Breeden
Does this stuff really work? 
Re: OT - Pentacryl
John Lucas
I've never used it but have read a lot about it over the years. It does work. It is expensive and it causes problems with most finishes. I guess those are the two reasons you don't hear of it being used.
Ed Moultrhop used it extensively and I believe he used an epoxy finish. I've heard that some of his pieces have needed re finishing over the years.
You might try doing a search on WC to see other discussions or you might try doing a Google search because there have been discussions on other sites.
After reading about the possible problems I decided it wasn't worth trying out for myself. I just learned to deal with green wood and how to prevent it from cracking and that took care of most of my problems.
This seems opposite what I just wrote *LINK*
http://www.preservation-solutions.com/turningtopics.php
here's a price quote *LINK*
http://www.woodcraft.com/product/2001793/29300/pentacryl-gallon.aspx
Re: OT - Pentacryl
Bill Howatt
I've never used it but I believe wood carvers use it more than turners. This is probably because turners are interested in preserving cut logs rather than stabilizing pieces while carving. I'm not a carver though so my understanding may be incorrect.
It is more pricey than Anchorseal.
Bill
Re: This seems opposite what I just wrote
Mike Foster
John,
It seems the opposite because they are are really 2 quite different products you are seing. I am pretty sure the Moulthrops used PEG. That's polyethelene glycol. It has different molecular weights depending on the formulation. It is used for a lot of different things, including a lot in the cosmetic industry. For stabalizing wood, you soak the turning in PEG and the PEG will displace the water and replace it with PEG. This keeps the original form of the piece stable, no shrinking or cracking as we usually experience with wet wood. Problem is just as you said. It leaves a slightly slimy or soapy feel to the wood, and is really difficult to put a finish on it. I experimented with it a long time ago, and did not care for it at all. Twice turning is my preference.
I think Pentacryl is similar to other plastic type products which does leave a hard blank after treatment. Never used it, so have no real idea how it works. Possibly the same stuff tha some of the pen blank suppliers use to stabalize wood. I have turned a couple of those and find that turning the stabalized wood is less like turning wood, more like a hard plastic. Easy to finish. Probably helps a lot with porous or punky wood.
You are correct Mike-senior moment
Re: This seems opposite what I just wrote
Jim Breeden
John: The article was interesting - makes me want to try it, but not completely convinced. I tried the alcohol thing with a box elder burl - not much luck. Dunked it every 2 - 4 hours, then let it "dry" for a couple days as recommended by our club members. That thing was wet for three weeks! So - as you can probably tell by my alcoholic experience, I'm willing to try just about anything. Even the Per-re-dactyl "sauce".
Not for me
Ray - Middletown, in
I tried to stabilize a punky spot and spent weeks soaking and waiting and nothing happened.
Ray
Re: Not for me
Bernie Rose
My experience with Pentacryl dates back to so long ago that I don't remember why I stopped using it.
But PEG is another thing. I have used PEG to stabilize full log sections to make foot stools. I still have a foot stool that was done 25 years ago and has not checked or cracked in that time. But it doesn't take a shiny finish.
Re: This seems opposite what I just wrote
Ric Taylor
Jim,
It's not supposed to be dunked, it is supposed to be soaked, which is a big difference.
I'm guessing that your wood was wet for three weeks because it was still green-wood-wet instead of alcohol-soaked-wet.
Ric
I use Cedarcide's "Turners Choice" and...
Don Leydens
have had great results with it. Also not cheep. I don't have the bucks to submerge a large turning in a few gallons of the stuff, so I brush it on heavily, sometimes multiple coats. It really sinks in deep. Even large cedar turnings have remained crack free. This link explains it better than I can:
http://www.cedarcidestore.com/catalog/item/3343694/2900278.htm
Re: This seems opposite what I just wrote
Rodney
It sounds (reads) to me more like you are thinking about polycryl which is a large molecular weight acrylic polymer that will fill and strengthen semi-punky or spalt wood rather than pentacryl which is used to speed drying time for rough turned green bowls.
About alcohol soaking, yes overnight and then bagged or wrapped in paper is the recommended method for rough turned green wood, the alcohol migrates into the cells and replaces most of the bound water (to the concentration of the alcohol solution) and may speed drying time.
Soaking is also the recommended method for polycryl.
Re: I use Cedarcide's "Turners Choice" and...
Rodney
This sounds like a good product, seems to be a combo drying and stabilising agent while pentacryl is to speed drying and polycryl is to stabilise punky and spalted wood. Polycryl isn't for green wood. Painting on is one method that can be used on big pieces with either polycryl or pentacryl according to the manufacturer but they are supposed to be kept wet (plastic bagged or covered in some way) between brushings. The price could add to the cost of a piece but probably could be worth it for some unique partially spalted pieces. Does the cedarcide turn well on a dried rough turned piece or do you just use it after finish turning.
Re: I use Cedarcide's "Turners Choice" and...
DLeydens
Hi Rodney. I've used it both ways. Sometimes I plan on turning and finishing up a big piece, but an unplanned interruption doesn't allow me to finish it the same day. In that case, I hit it with the Turners Choice and have yet to have cracks in the piece the next day (I don't even cover the piece, normally). Other times I finish it all up and because it might be a decent piece, I hit it with the stuff as an insurance policy, then put on my normal finish the next day (I usually use Formby's Tung Oil). Depending on the shape, some warping might occur, but no cracks. The piece linked below was turned from fairly green cedar and no cracks and no warping after a year (19" tall).
http://www.woodturnersresource.com/wrphotopost/showphoto.php?photo=8872&ppuser=4174
Re: This seems opposite what I just wrote
Jim Breeden
Ric - I used dunked instead of soaked, which is what I ment.
And to all - I'm still pondering all the advice. My quandry is: My brother brought me about 1100#s of White Oak and Western Red Cedar that he had just cut down two days before, and I helped a friend cut down a Bradford Pear @ 18" in diameter with numerous crotches, and a friend of his gave me some Apricot branches @ 9" he had trimed off his gig-a-mun-gus tree. Plus, I came across the Albuquerque city parks guys cutting down a bug infected Red Ash @ 18" in diameter in one of the medians - so I'm kinda swallowed up with wet-green wood. Everything is sealed with green wood sealer - had to get some more after all that. So, I'm still studying the situation.
Yeah, I can hear it now - WOOD GLOAT ! 
Re: I use Cedarcide's "Turners Choice" and...
Rodney
Thank you.
So, from your description, it seems to work on green wood without the soaking and subsequent drying required of either the pentacryl or alcohol method. Of course I'm not sure what "fairly green" means but if it stops cracking and warping with just a paint on coat after turning then it seems to be worth the effort and it seems to take an oil finish.
I guess I was more interested in it's properties with regard to stabilising punky wood and how that turned after treatment. I'm currently trying a polycryl soak on some wild cherry that was killed by the root rot fungus and has some soft spots in the center. Don't have any data yet as it still has to soak a couple more days. According to the directions, it has to soak for a week for good penetration then dry out a bit before turning (of course they don't specify how long as it would depend on the piece). I am wondering if it is going turn out to be like the "hard plastic" mentioned by Mike Foster in another part of this thread but I suppose I'll know at some point in the future. I was hoping to be able to compare with your experience with turners choice but it appears that you aren't using it on punky wood.
As the wood seems to take up a fair bit of the polycryl it's going to add cost but your method with the turners choice doesn't sound like it would add much cost when used to prevent cracking in green wood. In addition, turning to completion and finishing the next day is faster than the other methods of rough turning - drying - finish turning.
Re: I use Cedarcide's "Turners Choice" and...
Don Leydens
Sorry I forgot to mention punky wood. Probably because I haven't tried this product as a cure for that. Quite frankly, I don't think it would do much good as I haven't found any "hardening" qualities with this product. Perhaps others will know more about it, I still use CA glue for that.
Re: I use Cedarcide's "Turners Choice" and...
Jim Breeden
Don - I went to the Cedercides web to learn more. Yes EXPENSIVE! But, doesn't it infuse the cedar oil and silicones into the cell structure and, not allow a finish to adhere to the wood?
Re: I use Cedarcide's "Turners Choice" and...
Dave Kartzman
I've been using "Turner's Choice" for a year and a half with great results. I do submerge my bowls. They say to soak it for a day and let it dry for a few days, but with ikebana bowls (because they are so thick), with green wood, I soak it for 3 days, and let it dry a minimum of a week before finish turning it. With rare exceptions, the wood generally moves 1/16" or less after drying that long. However, there have been some blanks that have moved considerably if there was a lot of stress relieved during the turning.
I have used polyurethane as well as sander/sealer/ multiple wax coats, with no issues whatsoever. The finish stick to the wood. It does impart a cedar aroma to the wood, but no one seems to mind it.
Re: I use Cedarcide's "Turners Choice" and...
Don Leydens
Dave, nice to hear from someone else who uses this stuff!
Jim, After using this on well over a hundred pieces, I can only think of two times where the finish (Tung Oil) just didn't want to stick. Ironically both were cedar pieces (other cedar pieces have finished just fine) and I'm still not sure if it was the wood or the Cedarcide. It eventually worked out, but took quite a few coats to get it just right.
Re: I use Cedarcide's "Turners Choice" and...
Dave Kartzman
My mentor and good friend also uses it extensively. From my perspective the one downside to using "Turner's Choice" is that fact that my green wood ikebanas use so much of the solution that I have to order a 5 gallon supply around twice a year. My friend turns a lot of rough-turned bowls, but he doesn't go through nearly as much as I do.
But having said that, if you turn a lot of green wood and you can't wait a long time to let it air dry, I don't think there is anything better that you can use.
Dave
Re: I use Cedarcide's "Turners Choice" and...
Jim Breeden
Good advice from everyone - thanks!
Believe I'll try "Turners Choice". I don't do a lot of green turning, so I'm open to try it - IF - I can get the family accountant to look the other way. 