Interesting, but I wonder? (Calling Rob Wallace!) *LINK*
Steven Antonucci
I look an these and I am always torn between what I see and what I would expect to see? Perhaps Rob can weigh in as a tree expert? (I am not...)
I get that this doesn't need to be a literal translation of the branch or trunk or any specific tree, but to my eye, the branch that is sticking up has a problem. The smaller branches on it are growing down, and I don't know of a single tree where the branches grow "backwards" towards the trunk?
Secondarily, I'd like to see a progression of smaller branches as you get further towards the end of the limb. I believe that your skills are good and that the concept is strong, but the anatomy just seems a little out of balance.
I've attached a link that describes some of the anatomy things that I see. My apologies if this is too nit picky...
Artistic license allow the inimitable Mr. Hines to make his tree any way he wishes and it does not have to follow what is expected or normal.
Dick, I actually saw some trees similar to this in Norway that were clinging tenuously to the sides of hill and had branches and roots draped over the abyss.
My guess is that you completed this tree during one episode of American Idol. Of course I could be wrong....
Dick, this is wonderful and just like the world's fair your trees are getting bigger and better with every attempt. Good stuff!
One question, how does one lift the lid and what does one do about sitting it down afterwards? That is, assuming that the lid can be lifted by the tree handle.
This is a real beauty Dick. You don't need to tell me how long it took; the "handle" is fantastic. It reminds me of the ivy root attachments I have to pull of the side of the house occasionally.
Re: Interesting, but I wonder? (Calling Rob Wallac
Rob Wallace
Branching in trees and most other plants typically serves to move the lateral organs (side branches and leaves) away from the supporting organ (main stem or trunk), presumably to present the leaves and/or flowers for optimal photosynthesis or reproduction. Rarely do branches "return" to the main supporting stem except as an aberration, although in habitats with extreme stresses (wind, cold, high light, limited water, etc.), all bets are off regarding "normal' architecture of the plant. There are many examples of long-lived plants in stressed habitats (high elevation, strong prevailing winds, thin soils, deserts, heavy predation/herbivory) where gnarled, unusual branching patterns are the norm. I think you may be reacting to the combined visual disharmony of what is assumed to be a natural branching pattern for the entire branch.
I agree that the upward pointing branch seems out of context, given that the other branching pattern seems to follow 'normal' branching form where the branch angles are less than 90 degrees. The upward pointing branch visually follows the same angles, but seems inverted if one is to assume a normally growing plant.
We have been informed that the 'reversed' upper branch is to mimic the artificially-developed forms of cultivated plants grown following bonsai aesthetics. There are several basic principles of number, scale, and balance in the bonsai art form, but I really know nothing about this with respect to the 'naturalness' (or not) of branch angles in artificially-modified bonsai growth forms.
I don't know if this has helped the discussion or not... (?)
I am OK with your explanation and called you because, well, plants are your field of expertise!
I think that it is the smaller offshoots on that branch coming out of the stick in the downward direction that caught me first, but it might be the flow being disturbed by it pointing straight up instead of out to the right like the rest.
Re: Interesting, but I wonder? (Calling Rob Wallac
Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN
The lower branches of pin oaks grow downward and this is a common tree although in the South many people confuse this tree with the willow oak. As one text states, "the pin oak (Quercus palustris) has a characteristic shape. It has a long central trunk. Its upper branches always lift to the sky. Its middle branches extend more or less horizontally from the trunk. Its lowest branches always droop toward the ground."
The Corkscrew willow is a cultivar variant of the Asian willow species selected and cultivated due to its aberrant stem growth form. Even though the tree's stems grow more or less randomly, and are highly curved, the branch angle still tends to follow more-or-less normal development (i.e. the branches do not typically grow at angles over 90 degrees), however the curving internode growth serves to contort the tree into the "screwy" form that is the desirable attribute of this cultivar, and visually is quite out of the ordinary.
Another example of an aberration of a "normal' species is Corylus avellana 'Contorta', known in the horticulture trade as "Harry Lauder's Walking Stick" which is selected for its twisted and contorted stems. Even in this example, the branching architecture seems to be more or less typical of other Corylus species, and it is the curved stem internodes that give the tree its unusual appearance.
As with any aspect of the living world, there will always be exceptions to the norm, and these unusual forms are often easily noticed, highlighted, and revered, particularly if aesthetically pleasing.
Re: Interesting, but I wonder? (Calling Rob Wallac
Roger
Up on the high ridges in western VA. we have lots of trees that due to wind and ice look a whole lot like the one on Dick's box. After mother nature gets through with them, the trees look like mother nature makes them look. Beautiful representation of mother nature at work Dick.
Beautiful box & representation of a cascade. My two addictions are bonsai & turning and have wondered how to incorporate bonsai into my turnings - you've figured it out. And masterfully at that. If your bonsai are half as good as your turnings, you're a master in two arts.
To answer the "trees don't grow like that naturally" Trees like this are found on steep cliffs. Prevailing downward winds and snow cover push the trees down. The upper trunk can be out of the wind and creating it's own new leader trunk/branch. Cascades and windswept styles are difficult to do and make them look right. Bonsai aren't exact copies of natural trees (even though the past several years there's been a 'naturalistic style' movement), but representations. Depending on the design they can be best viewed up close or from a distance.
Bill, I had 75 trees until a tropical storm came through here some years ago. I had so much damage to my house and no power to get water that all my trees bit the big one. Broke my hart. I am in the prosess of starting a couple this summer.
I may never get back to 75 but I will be starting some new ones this fall. Until then I will be working on my box "trees"
Loss from tropical storm really hurts. I know the feeling. I was up to almost 50 trees when stress from work caused me to ignore all hobbies. Over 3 years I lost all but 15 due to negligence and inattention. Luckily 3 that I worked on with Masters (Marco Invernizzi, Ben Oki & Mary Madison) have survived. Now I'm just getting more selective on raw material.