Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

Posts

Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

#1

Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

Roger Chandler

Another piece for the demo........have I told anyone that I am having fun? [like you couldn't guess!]

First of all I want to thank fellow turner , Mike Cruz for this piece of spalted maple. My problem is that I did not have enough to make a lid with it.........that would have been a killer piece! So I improvised and had to use some walnut. The box is fresh off the lathe in the last 10 minutes........I still want to add some more coats of WTF, and sanding in between some of the additional coats........it should only get better!

Size is 4-1/4 wide and 5-3/8 tall..........comments always welcome!!! Guess there is nothing like the pressure of an upcoming demo to get one motivated!

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

#2

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

Bernie Weishapl

Cool box Roger. I do like the wood combo. Looks like the demo will be a breeze.

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

#3

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

Roger Chandler

Given the choices I had as to wood for the lid............I thought the walnut would look better than cherry.........I even made another lid from plain maple..........did not do anything for the form and it cracked on me big time and lost the center because of it...........I toyed with the idea of ebonizing the lid, to match the spalt lines, but in the end, felt like it would overpower the form with all that black.

Given the right piece of maple that had some similar spalting.........this form could have been a real looker........but that was not in the cards on this one.........maybe next time...........anyway, perhaps the audience at the demo will like it enough that they will pay attention to the demo! In my opinion, it shows better in person than in the pics.

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

#4

Ellis Walentine

Very tasty

Ellis Walentine

I think the walnut looks fine. It picks up the brownish hues of the spalted wood and provides a strong value contrast with the lighter maple. The result is quite attractive in its own right, a winner.

Have fun at your demo.

Ellis

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

#5

Re: Very tasty

Roger Chandler

Thanks Ellis.........much appreciated!

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

#6

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

John Lucas

Roger It is a nice box and I love the shape but I'll be honest I'm not overly thrilled with the choice of woods. Don't get me wrong I've been there and done that (probably many times). You scrounge around the shop looking for the perfect piece and it just isn't there. I like that you chose the lid material to help match the bottom.

99% of the population I think would love the box as is so I'm going to play the devils advocate just for the sake of learning. I think there is too much competition between the highly figured maple and the Walnut. My eye keeps following the maple lines up and ends rather abruptly at the lid.

I think maybe if the lid had been wider so it formed a more natural stop for your eye it might have worked better. Maybe an inset lid that fits inside the box and doesn't stick up at all would work because it wouldn't compete so much with the body of the box. Just thinking out loud like I do with all my pieces. I always question my pieces and try to figure out what would make them better. They always sell sooner or later so someone likes them. I can't help but believe that they would sell quicker if I improve the small details.

When I go to the national symposium and see the pieces from the high end professional turners you can really see the little details that take their work to the next level. Since your teaching boxes it is always fun to show the audience what you might do differently to improve a box. It helps them learn as well.

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

#7

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

Roger Chandler

Good points John.........thanks for the critique.........of course now that it is off the lathe, and I have had time to really look at it, I would change the lid a bit, by making the lip a little less diameter and a little thinner. I would also likely make the bead at the bottom a bit more pronounced to give better balance.

I am going to do at least a couple more styles with different woods.......hopefullly refining each one as I go along....................hopefully to help other see what they can do.........many in our club have never turned a lidded box and I am not sure why they chose me to do the demo, but it is what it is, and I will try to give them a quality demo and show what they can do........hopefully a broad overview.

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

#8

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

John Lucas

I think the club is headed for a quality demo. You have been preparing well with lots of good samples.

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

#9

Ellis Walentine

Great critique, John

Ellis Walentine

Your insights are well taken and right on.

Ellis

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

#10

Mike Stafford

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

Mike Stafford

I don't know how tall/thick the spalted maple piece was but I turn this style box from a 4" thick piece and make the lid and body out of the same piece of wood.

Doing this requires that you turn the lid 3 times. The first time you hold the lid from the underside with a wormwood screw or expand into a shallow drilled hole. Then you can turn a tenon on what will become the top of the lid. You can then grip the lid in compression mode and turn the underside of the lid. Finally expand into the underside of the lid and finish turning the top of the lid ending up with a knob made from the same wood as the rest of the box.

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

#11

Good description Mike

John Lucas

I think the thing to remember is you don't have to use every square inch of the wood. You can often (as in Mike's boxes) make them smaller and get a better overall shape and still get a matching lid. It took me a long time to realize that just because the blank is "this" size doesn't mean I can get the best piece by using all of it. Sometimes you have to think outside the "box".

I think John Jordan teaches in his video that you start a bowl between centers and then shift the bowl to achieve a better grain alignment or possibly completely change the shape. This often requires making a much smaller piece. One thing you notice when you go to the National Symposium and view the instant gallery is how small many of the pieces are. When we see them online we assume they are larger I guess. It can be shocking but at the same time the quality of the piece is extremely high. I think it's because they used the wood to it's best qualities and didn't worry about size.

Re: Spalted Maple/walnut lidded box

#12

Re: Good description Mike

Roger Chandler

John and Mike..........thank you both. This is good info. On this particular blank, I would have had to reduce the size a good bit to get a lid out of it.........in my mind that would have made this nothing more than a cute decoration when my intent was something utilitarian ...........the blank was small and I only had one of it.

Regarding your sequence Mike.........the use of a woodworm screw is interesting. What I did was turn a recess in the bottom to hold it, and hollow it out. For the lid I used a tenon.........actually made another lid out of plain maple and it cracked on me big time.......and I did do a couple of trial fits before I lost the center on it, and it added nothing to the form........the walnut looks better.

Had that spalted maple been about 3 inches longer, I could have pulled off the lid out of the same material by making a shorter box, but not enough to do a lid and have any proportional integrity.

I thank you both for your interest in helping me.........that is good info you both gave..........I take it with interest and hopefully can utilize it in the future.