Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Shot filled handles

Posts

Shot filled handles

#1

Shot filled handles

robo hippy

At last year's Symposium, it seemed like every one who had after marked handles available, had a plug of some sort in the handle so you could add shot to them. I do have a two gouges with shot in the handles, and never use them. They just never felt right, and I did not like the added weight. When it came to dampening vibration, I felt the best solution was to move the tool rest closer. Well, I saw Soren Berger last Thursday, and he made the comment that he didn't like them either. Reason was that by dampening the vibration, it also removed any feed back from how the tool was cutting. Being able to 'feel' how the wood cuts is pretty huge in getting clean smooth cuts. Now I know why they just never felt right.

robo hippy

Re: Shot filled handles

#2

Re: Shot filled handles

John Lucas

I like them for roughing out bowls. It helps stabilize the handle and reduces fatique. I don't like them for general turning simply because they are too heavy and after long hours get tiring.

Re: Shot filled handles

#3

I agree...

GaryG in MD

They're for roughing. ...Gary

Re: Shot filled handles

#4

Re: Shot filled handles

robo hippy

Well, I do my roughing with scrapers, and I have yet to see a shot filled handle for scrapers. Hmmm. I was wondering if the preference goes between those who prefer straight tool rests on bowls to those who prefer the curved bowl rests.

robo hippy

Re: Shot filled handles

#5

Re: Shot filled handles

jerryw

Reed: I have reported several times on my large 1-1/2x3/8 CPM 10V bowl scraper with a 24" shot filled handle. (Tool is 34" ling overall. It is a dream to turn with. Give Pauline at Glaser a call. He makes lots of scrapers.

Jerry Wright

Re: Shot filled handles

#6

Re: Shot filled handles

jerryw

Reed: I have reported several times on my large 1-1/2x3/8 CPM 10V bowl scraper with a 24" shot filled handle. (Tool is 34" ling overall. It is a dream to turn with. Give Paulo at Glaser a call. He makes lots of scrapers.

Jerry Wright

Re: Shot filled handles

#7

Bill Blasic

Re: Shot filled handles

Bill Blasic

Reed,

The Thompson scrapers fit into the Thompson weighted handles. The thing I like about the Thompson handles is that they have a moveable stopper (for lack of a better name for it) that you can move to add or subtract weight from the handle dependent on how you want it to feel without any shifting.

Bill

Re: Shot filled handles

#8

Don Leydens

Re: Shot filled handles

Don Leydens

I also use my heavy or shot filled handles for roughing only. Too tiring otherwise. Reed, I might have to try your scraper idea though.

I also like the Thompson handles.

Re: Shot filled handles

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Shot filled handles

Lyle Jamieson

I agree. I like the Thompson handles but I take the weight out. I rough with my bowl gouge, fast and easy.

Re: Shot filled handles

#10

Re: Shot filled handles

robo hippy

Hmmmm.... This brings another thought to mind. How do you hold your tools? I use the sliding headstock for bowls, and make my lathe into a short bed lathe. Most of the time, I hold the tools pretty much level, and my right hand more choked up on the handle, with the end of the handle under my forearm. I almost never drop the handle to my side. Just never found that to be comfortable. You can check out my You Tube clips, type in robo hippy.

robo hippy

Re: Shot filled handles

#11

Steven Antonucci

My thoughts on handles

steven antonucci

1.) All of your tools should have different handles. How will you find them otherwise?

2.) All handles should be made by the turner to fit his or her hand and the specific purpose of the tool. One size does not fit all.

3.) Handles should be long. You can always choke up, but try holding onto air.

4.) What is all of this talk about weight? If your tool is long enough to have that much shot weight in it, you probably need it. If you have a lot of "vibration to absorb", you are probably doing something wrong.

5.) Metal is fine, but I feel guilty using the handle as a mallet to seat my spur.

So, I have one Thompson handle in my rack, which makes it easy to find. The best feature of the metal handle is the ability to lengthen or shorten the steel sticking out and to reverse it for packing. I have, of course, done neither of those things.

Would I buy one? Probably not, but I don't really have anything against them.

Steve

Re: Shot filled handles

#12

Re: My thoughts on handles

john lopez

One thing that has not been mentioned in this thread is speed.

It plays into the equation too.

Too fast it wobbles and too slow will beat you up.

For good roughing cuts a piece needs to whirl as you present the tool.

I have a 1/2 inch bowl gouge in a 16 inch Thompson handle and it feels

pretty responsive during the roughing and shaping process.

I found using the shot tiring.

The shot lives in a prescription bottle in a tool drawer.

I wrapped my Thompson in a woven tape to dampen impacts

and warm it up during winters.

It's ugly and lumpy but nicer to my hands.

The bonus is I can use a scraper with the same handle.

Just don't drop the screws into the shavings.

Someone with lots of experience probably has a smart solution

for that.

I still use the bigger wood handles & gouges probably more often because

that is what I've always used and they feel best.

The interchangeable tool feature is probably great for travel.

Re: Shot filled handles

#13

Absorbing vibration with a shot.....

JamieDonaldson

...filled handle requires that the handle not be packed tight with shot, but have some room for the shot to move or "resonate." Packing a handle tight only adds mass, and although that will also reduce vibration slightly, it also makes the tool more "dead."