Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Raffan style cross grain box.....myrtle

Posts

Raffan style cross grain box.....myrtle

#1

Mike Stafford

Raffan style cross grain box.....myrtle

Mike Stafford

Seeing Roger Chandler's walnut cross grain box made me think of all the cross grain boxes I saw Richard Raffan turn on the Woodturning Cruise. I watched him turn many of them and somehow did not manage to end up with one in my collection. When he was at the N.C. Woodturning Symposium I missed getting one by a stutter.

So I finally decided to bite the bullet and turn one for myself in Richard's style. I had a 5" square block of myrtle with some spalting and decided it was a candidate for the job. I sawed the block in half so that I was essentially turning a bowl with a lid that happened to have some grain match.

Well, the myrtle was softer and punkier than I thought and it was a pain to turn. It was too soft and crumbly to hold bead details but I managed to finish the box. The lid is not a snug fit. It sits inside the body with plenty of room but does not rattle around because I did not want the inevitable twist fit situation that can occur during seasonal humidity changes.

The box finished up at something less than 4" tall and something less than 5" in diameter. This is one of the styles I will be teaching the first couple of days in my class at JCCFS in June. Ya'll come!

Comments appreciated....


Re: Raffan style cross grain box.....myrtle

#2

Re: Raffan style cross grain box.....myrtle

Roger Chandler

Mike..........that is a fine box! I was thinking Raffan-esque when I made mine, but had no picture or reference.........only a faint memory of what I saw some couple years back. I also attended a Raffan demo a few months ago, and he had one of these in his collection to show & sell, but I did not remember that at the time I was turning mine.

At least someone of your stature in boxes recognized a little bit of his style in my box..............I am flattered!

I have been to your website recently and have drawn some inspiration for some others I will make for my upcoming demo......of course, when I post I will properly reference your work when appropriate. Once again........nice work!

Re: Raffan style cross grain box.....myrtle

#3

Steven Antonucci

Twice turned?

steven antonucci

Assumed, but asking...

Also, have you ever tried "stabilizing" the wood to keep it from twist fitting?

Steve

Re: Raffan style cross grain box.....myrtle

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: Twice turned?

Mike Stafford

Yes, I frequently do twice turn both cross grain and end grain boxes if the wood is wet. This block of myrtle was dry as a bone and showed no evidence of moisture.

I tend to rough turn block when I am unsure of their dryness and then do an alcohol soak per Dave Smith's regimen. This wood was so dry and dusty as well as crumbly it might have dissolved in the alcohol..... :b I wish I had chosen better material for the effort but once I chuck up a piece I have the bad habit of trying to salvage it and spend more time, CA and wood hardener on it than the piece is worth.

Steve, I decided to add some more comments. I think the cross fit problem occurs not because of the dryness of the wood but because of the wood's tendency to cup and warp in response to changes in the humidity. End grain boxes turned from very dry wood are inherently more stable than a box or bowl turned from cross grain wood. However as one increases the diameter of an end grain box there is some effect on the fit of a suction fit lid because of changes in the humidity. This can result in a twist fit. Those changes seem to be more profound on cross grain boxes therefore I do not attempt to create a

suction fit on wood turned in this orientation. From experience I have seen lids of cross grain boxes "locked in place" during high humidity which we have in abundance where I live. Very humid here today I might add.

I am reminded of the story told by Roy Underhill of the PBS show The Woodwright's Shop.

Seems he was visiting a famed Japanese woodworker known for his traditionally created boxes. Roy was admiring a sweater box held together with dovetail which had a sliding lid that had little or no side to side movement.

He remarked to the Japanese master that this box must be very hard to open in the summer.

To which the Japanese craftsman responded, "True, but I don't need my sweaters in the summer."

Re: Raffan style cross grain box.....myrtle

#5

Re: Twice turned?

john lucas

Mike Glad to hear I'm not the only one who hangs in there and tries to save crappy wood. Probably a good reason we both keep our day jobs.

Re: Raffan style cross grain box.....myrtle

#6

Beautiful!!

Greg Haugen

That is one style of box that I've yet to attempt. This is a beautiful box, Mike.