Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Walnut lidded box

Posts

Walnut lidded box

#1

Walnut lidded box

Roger Chandler

I have a demo on lidded boxes to do in July. This is just the first in several I will do to be able to show at the demo.......which will be of different styles and sizes.

This one is 4-5/8 wide and 4.25 tall......The finish is still a little wet in the pics and it still has to be buffed and waxed, so it is still a work in progress.

Re: Walnut lidded box

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Walnut lidded box

Keith Tompkins

Hi Roger, this box looks great, but appears to be side grain?

Re: Walnut lidded box

#3

Re: Walnut lidded box

Roger Chandler

Keith........this particular piece of walnut was given to me last year by a newly beginning turner who visited me along with a friend, and brought a few pieces along with him.............the blank is side grain I believe.........as the ends were face grain, so that orientation is what it is.

Do you forsee any issues with the grain orientation? The wood was pretty dry....not kiln dried, but has been in the shop for nearly a year and was cut likely over 18 months ago.......it was about six inches in diameter and about 7 inches long.........I have the inside and outside finished and so far, after a full day, no ovaling........and the lid sits perfect and still has the light suction to it.

Re: Walnut lidded box

#4

Re: Walnut lidded box

john lucas

Roger On side grain boxes the lid will fit differently during the seasons. This is because the wood moves differently along the 2 axis. If it's a large box the wood movement can be great enough that the lid might not even fit during either the wet season or dry season. Kind of depends on which time of the year you turn it, along with the species of wood.

Most people make boxes from end grain orientation because the wood movement is less in this orientation. Even then if the wood was cut too close to the center you can have wood movement problems.

It also depends a great deal on how large the box is. Small boxes obviously have less movement but we tend to make the lids fit more snug so wood movement can still be a problem.

You can find some good articles on the web about how wood moves which will help you understand the problem better. John Jordan's video on Woodmovement and the Aesthetics of wood is a very good one to discuss this issue.

Re: Walnut lidded box

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Walnut lidded box

Keith Tompkins

Hi Roger, Like John said, wood movement may affect the way the lid sits. Understanding wood by Bruce Hoadley is an excellent reference...a must read for any woodworker. We must understand wood, and the way it moves to create long-term pieces. In flat work , for example, one should never glue in raised-panels in doors...they'll split in the winter. Grain orientation is a big problem in segmented work as well. With turned boxes, end-grain movement is more uniform around the circumference, while cross grain movement is in mostly one direction; wood doesn't move much in the end grain orientation.

Re: Walnut lidded box

#6

Re: Walnut lidded box

Roger Chandler

Thanks Keith..........I have built numerous raised panel doors for kitchen and bathroom cabinets.........and the cabinets,bookcases and furniture as well for that matter. I understand what you are saying.........

This walnut on this box seems pretty stable, and I usually do turn end grain, but since this was a piece of wood sized right for what I had in mind, and I finished the inside and out, I feel pretty good about it. My biggest issue was a couple of stress cracks developed while turning, and I had to glue them.....it does not show in the pics, but I repaired them and it looks pretty good........I went back this morning and resanded and put more coats of finish on it.........it has a dark, lustrous finish now and has had zero movement so far, and the lid still has a perfect fit, with light suction.

I was more concerned with your assessment of the grain orientation......I had seen other boxes, like Raffan's and they seemed to be fine.............I took the dryness of this wood into account when I decided to use this blank. It may yet disappoint me, but I will keep an eye on it, and adjust the lid if necessary if it does move.

Thanks!!!

Re: Walnut lidded box

#7

Re: Walnut lidded box

Roger Chandler

just an update...........it has been just over a week since I turned this box......so far it is still round, and not oval...........we have had a varied weather pattern so far during that week ............it has been rainy, sunny and dry, and today we have had almost 2 inches of rain, and the humidity is very high.........so high that fog is hanging in the air...........

This box is still round and the lid fits just like it did the day I turned it......good so far.........I hope it stays that way! I only mention this as there was some concern over the grain orientation.