Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Hairy bowl tale

Posts

Hairy bowl tale

#1

Hairy bowl tale

Jorge

Today I did turn a red oak bowl, soaking green, it was

messy and malodorous, the piss oak nickname is true.

Not so easy to turn, very fibery, had to sharpen often, and prone to tear out. Rusted the ways and made the tool bevels black.

As soon as I started to do the inside, it started to change shape on me, so had to hurry and decide to turn it to final thickness, when I was getting close I did blow air to get rid of the dust and I noticed the air was blowing right thru!

So, I started thinking "What if?" And applied a generous coat of sanding sealer to the inside and did turn the lathe on. An hour later came back and found this:


Here is the hairy beast, 14" x 7 ", looks huge in person.


Hairs!, maybe this could be put to some creative use...

Re: Hairy bowl tale

#2

Re: Hairy bowl tale

robo hippy

I remember Roy Underhill showing why red oak is not used for whiskey barrels. He split off a billet about 1 inch square by 14 long, stuck it in a bucket of water and blew on one end. Bubbles came out the other.

The hair is interesting.

robo hippy

Re: Hairy bowl tale

#3

Re: Hairy bowl tale

AMD

Hi ! This is my first post here ;-)

I started wood turning last fall and I got a red oak three.

All my firsts try was disappointing (rusting tools, too wet,

bas cracking, molds staining, etc.). Finally I put the oak on the side

behind the shop outside and I went to other wood But this spring (after

fall and a good winter with snow) I re-tried and this time was very different...

Clean cut, no rusting, and no cracking problem !

So my advice: put log end sealer and waits six months ...

For me that makes all the difference and now I love this wood !

Re: Hairy bowl tale

#4

Re: Hairy bowl tale

Jorge

AMD

Thanks for the input,I still have the other half of that billet,

today after all morning de-rusting everything in sight I don't think I will ever turn the other, but then again I am known to change my mind,

Thank you!

Re: Hairy bowl tale

#5

Re: Hairy bowl tale

robo hippy

Walnut will do the same job on cast metal that the oaks will. With my old PM, I just would buff it lightly with the synthetic steel wool so it didn't pit out. It developed a nice black patina over the years I had it. If I had removed all the black each time I turned, I would probably would have worn the ways down to paper thin.

robo hippy

Re: Hairy bowl tale

#6

Re: Hairy bowl tale

Bill White

To quote:

"Discretion is the better part of valor".

Bill

Re: Hairy bowl tale

#7

About the rust with oak

Scott Crumpton

I started with wet red oak on my first lathe and am now doing some on my new 3520b. What I've found over the years is to let it rust a little and then clean it up with phosphoric acid. The next time it won't rust as bad. Clean that up the same way. After a few such treatments the lathe bed will become much more resistant to rust due to the coating left by the acid converting the rust. I never use an abrasive on the bed because it would remove the coating left by the acid.

Re: Hairy bowl tale

#8

Re: About the rust with oak

Jorge

Sounds like you have a good system, let it grow its own coating, where do you get the phosphoric acid?

Re: Hairy bowl tale

#9

Rob Wallace

Phosphoric acid.....

Rob Wallace

Phosphoric Acid is one of the main ingredients in "Naval Jelly" rust remover, found in concentrations of between 10 and 30 percent, along with other acids, stabilizers, and other components.

I'm not sure I'd advise the intentional development of rust on and pits in cast iron, although an oxide patina will slow (but not eliminate) development of further rust. I have been told that once pitting begins, it is irreversible, and will slowly progress through time. Maybe the metallurgists in the group can weigh-in on this?

I try to avoid rust altogether, and when wet turning acidic woods (oak, walnut, cherry, etc.) I routinely spray-on a liberal coat of Bostik Top-Cote prior to turning, allowing it to dry completely. Others use water-repelling solutions, such as WD-40 for the same purpose (although the residual oil gets a bit messy, IMHO) to protect the ways and other cast iron parts from the acidic wood's moisture.

Rob

Re: Hairy bowl tale

#10

Re: Phosphoric acid.....

Scott Crumpton

Totally agree with the above. I should clarify that by "let it rust a little" I mean the thin coat of rust that you get from doing a few wet bowls in one session. Thin enough that you can actually wipe most of it off with a wet paper towel. Treat that light rust to convert it into ferric phosphate (FePO4). I'm currently using Rust Free from the makers of T9. Not that I specifically recommend it, it's just what I happen to have. I'm not fond of Naval Jelly, I prefer a lower viscosity liquid that's easier to spread and remove with a paper towel.

The trick is to slowly, over time, build up the FePO4 coating and to avoid scraping it off with abrasives.

I will occasionally coat with T9 or WD40 if I don't intend to use the lathe for anything big. But I don't like the "oils" because they can sometimes cause slippage when you want a lot of tail stock pressure on a big project.

Re: Hairy bowl tale

#11

Talking about chemicals...

Jorge

Thanks Rob and Scott,

I usually coat the bed with a thin layer of renaissance wax, this is the first wood that broke through it. I do turn lots of cherry, both dry and green and some walnut, mostly dry with no problems.

The oak shavings rusted all my tool rests stored under the lathe.

An additional problem is black dots that appeared overnight on the bowl, is there any way to get rid of them other than sanding?

Re: Hairy bowl tale

#12

Re: Talking about chemicals...

robo hippy

Black spots are metal dust from the grinder which is remains on the tool after you sharpen. I have a 4 X 4 on my bench that I tap my tools on after I sharpen, at least before finish cuts. Concentrated lemon juice will remove it in seconds if you put it right on, like where the chuck jaws contact the wet wood (recess for me). If the wood is totally dry, and the stain has penetrated a little, you might have to let it sit a bit, or do several applications. It will also cut most of the walnut stain off your hands. If you are twice turning, probably not a problem.

robo hippy

Re: Hairy bowl tale

#13

Thanks Reed!