I have a 12" Delta lathe model 46-700 and I would like to get a chuck to fit it so I can turn some smaller spindles. I don't do much turning so I don't want something expensive. Besides, I am a cheapskate. I would like a chuck but there are so many different kinds on the market it is very confusing. Advice please.
I am not a spindle turner by any means, nor much of a turner compared to most who inhabit these boards. But I'll give your question a shot anyways.
Smaller is a relative term, so I'll have to guess at what you mean. With a mini or midi lathe (12" max diameter) I am guessing that smaller means smaller than is easily driven by a 4 spur drive center. Have you tried a Jacobs (drill) chuck? While i would not recommend it for pieces that you need to remount, or for square pieces, it certainly can hold small round pieces well. They are not that expensive (compared to scroll chuck at least), and often come with a Morse taper suitable for your lathe.
What Henry says is true as far as it goes, but there are complications...
First, a lot of spindle turning is done between centers so you wouldn't need a chuck at all.
So we need to know what kind of pieces you would make in a chuck (with the implication that the tail center would NOT be brought up).
Let's say you're making a finial. That would be a good application for a chuck.
The problem with the Jacobs chuck for things like this is that it is not constrained into the headstock and will just go flying right out. If you use a Jacobs chuck in the headstock, you need to have the tailstock brought up to hold the piece in place. If you're going to use the tailstock to hold it tight, I don't see any reason for a chuck at all. Maybe I'm being shortsighted, but nothing comes immediately to mind.
So, if you really need a chuck, I think you would need a scroll chuck. (Jacobs chucks are great for use in the tailstock for drilling.) I will probably raise some ire here when I say I've been using cheap Chinese chucks (from the likes of PSI) for ten years and have never had a reason to buy an expensive one. You can meet your needs for under $100. And that chuck will work just fine for side grain too. It's universal. I actually have three of them because I don't like to take the time to change jaws. I would recommend that you get one.
You will find the difference between different chucks in various price ranges can be boiled down to capacity and ease of use.
I have three chucks, a cheap one from PSI, a stronghold from Oneway, and a Vicmarc.
The PSI one requires two pony bars to tighten and loosen. The others are down with a single key or lever. Since I don't do much small turning or spindles, for that matter, this set up works well for me.
Thanks guys. I thought if I had something like this it would help in several ways, including being able to turn small bowls and things with a tenon on them so I wouldn't have to have any marks or screw holes on the bottom.
A good chuck to me would be the Nova G3 (available at Amazon or the bay for $125 including insert and shipping). It should handle anything you throw at it with your lathe. It comes with 2" jaws so if you want to hold something really small you may need a different jaw set. You can also make your own collets to reduce the diameter. This is a very good video on different holding methods (about 1.5 hrs long) and may give you more ideas.
You definitely want a chuck. You've gotten a lot of good advice here above to help you pick one. Two of mine are actually Grizzly, and I've used them for going on ten years on my 12" lathe without a problem.
Please consider this:
You'll soon find that you'll want some accessories --
a screw center that clamps in,
a steb center that clamps in,
maybe some step jaws,
a set of "jumbo flat" Cole jaws,
maybe some tower jaws,
bigger (3") jaws,
and the list goes on...
This is the best reason I can think of to start with a chuck brand that is part of a "system", so you can upgrade features as you find the desire and need.
PSI does this on the cheap end of the scale with more than adequate quality. The others mentioned are a bit more expensive and a bit higher quality. It all depends on your druthers.
Thanks to all but there is so much info here I think I am gonna have to wait until I can get to a place where I can see what I am getting and see it in action. I am not in a hurry.
A higher quality chuck like a Oneway Talon, a Supernova-II, or a G-3 chuck will do anything you can make with that lathe.
For spindle work, you could get the taller jaws to grip longer, thinner pieces. Most spindles don't require a chuck, but holding a spindle with a chuck will usually reduce flexing a lot.
For smaller diameter spindles you could start with a Beall collet chuck and the insert that's the best size for your work (maybe 5/8" or 1/2"?). Collet chucks won't be good for bowls but will be excellent for spindles. These are also mighty handy for turning miniatures or long, thin work from dowel sock, which can pass through the hollow spindle, allowing you to work on a short segment, then pull more through, etc... For really small diameters, you might want a revolving center with a Jacob's chuck and a threaded draw-bar, so you can hold the piece in tension between centers while being pulled tight by the tailstock, instead of being compressed between headstock and tailstock.
One post provided a link to rebuilt Nova equipment -- looks like some very good deals to me.
Chucks will come direct threaded or be insert type; most are insert type. Your lathe should be 1X8 so you would need a 1X8 insert. A good point is insert type chucks are normally no more expensive in total than direct threaded.
If you ever went to a larger capacity lathe (like 16") it would probably have a 1-1/4X8 spindle. With direct threaded you are sorta out of luck, with insert type you just change the insert ($8-20) to fit your new lathe spindle and keep using the same chuck.