Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Tantung steel

Posts

Tantung steel

#1

Tantung steel

robo hippy

You have all heard me rant about how I love scrapers. Well, I am trying to resurrect the 'Big Ugly' tool. This is a DIY tool that has been used by the Oregon Mytrle wood coastal bowl turners for so long, that no one can remember who came up with the idea for using this metal. The traditional tool is a 3/4 inch square piece of bar stock, with a 7/8 x 1/8 by 3 inch piece of tantung steel, silver (hard) soldered on each end. One end is sharpened almost square, and the other sharpened with more of a fingernail grind. You wear a heavy leather glove on the handle hand. You sharpen in the morning and turn till lunch time, after lunch, sharpen again and turn till beer thirty. It is almost as hard as carbide, and can be resharpened on standard grinding wheels. I hear it eats them up, and I never got a big ugly till after I had my original CBN matrix style wheels (I now have the D Way wheels). I think there are many possibilities for this steel in our turning work, especially with the hollowing tools. I did order some flat stock from them, and a piece 1/8 by 1 by 6 inches costs just over $50, which would make it maybe cheaper than carbide. I asked, and they said they would sell small orders, and they said yes.

http://cutting-tools.vrwesson.com/index.php?type=tantung

robo hippy

Re: Tantung steel

#2

What is Tantung (copied from a web-site)

Ralph Lindberg

What exactly is Tantung?

Tantung is a cast alloy cutting tool material composed principally of chromium, tungsten, columbium, and carbon in a cobalt matrix. These elements combined in the proper proportions and cast in chill molds give Tantung its most important characteristic -- the ability to retain its cutting hardness at temperatures of up to 1500°F. It is neither high speed steel nor carbide. It is unique.

Tantung has a high transverse rupture strength, low coefficient of friction and excellent resistance to corrosion. It is tough, readily absorbs shock and impact, and is non-magnetic...it likes to work.

As a cutting tool, it is ideal for all turning, facing, boring, milling , and cut-off applications on nearly every type of metal as well as non-metallics. Tantung performs best at speeds of 100-250 SFPM and can be used to excellent advantage on machines where speed, power, and rigidity are limited. In addition, it will not anneal or lose its cutting edge as will H.S.S. when subjected to high-red heats generated during the cutting cycle.

Tantung G is recommended for general purpose machining of both ferrous and non-ferrous metal and general woodworking operations. For catalog items, Tantung G Hardness is 60 to 63 Rockwell C and Transverse Rupture Strength is 300,000 psi minimum.

Re: Tantung steel

#3

Re: Tantung steel *LINK*

Mike Brazeau

I Googled "composition Tantung Steel" and came up with an excellent description in an ASM Handbook of Tool Materials by the Materials Information Society. Page 33 . These alloys are very high in Cobalt, Chrome and Tungsten. In my other life I dealt with the spectrometers used to measure alloy compositions and the Cobalt alloys were brutal to work with. There are few companies that make them. In another post a while back, I was flamed for talking about the merits of the ASP 2060 tools from Hamlet, which are without looking up somewhere around 10% Cobalt. The issue was that Cobalt is used when high temperatures are experienced in machining, which is obviously not the case with wood. Still my primary go to gouge, although Doug Thompson's is not far behind. Both sharpen to a fine edge that holds well. As an aside, I have a couple of high carbon steel scrapers I made and they are the easiest thing on earth to sharpen, so could not see spending this kind of money to eliminate a brief lick on the grinder. About 7 or 8 years ago, for $50 I bought almost 3 feet of 1 1/4" x 5/16" thick A10 I think it was.


ASM Handbook Tool materials

Re: Tantung steel

#4

Re: Tantung steel

robo hippy

Mike,

You do not eliminate a brief lick on the grinder for sharpening, you eliminate many brief licks on the grinder. Kind of like the CBN wheels, more expensive, but you get many more times the wear and tear out of them than you would with the same $ amoung of carbon or HSS cutting edges.

robo hippy

Re: Tantung steel

#5

Re: Tantung steel

steve worcester

I love Tantung. Real hard to shape though. Only been able to grind and not cut into shape. But as a scraper insert and such, best I have ever found.

Anyone know a machine shop that can work with it?