Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

The benefits of lung protection

Posts

The benefits of lung protection

#1

The benefits of lung protection

Steve Criscenzo

I have been using a Airstream respirator for several years. I change the primary filter about once a year.

Last night I took the unit apart the clean it and replace the filter. On a whim, I cut open the old filter. I was shocked at the amount of dust inside. The entire filter, about eight inches long , was coated with a layer of fine dusti

I run a dust collector when I sand and I still had an alarming amount of dust in the filter. Thinking about all that dust possibly ending up in my lungs was scary. The Airstream was expensive (cost 2X the cost of my fist lathe) but I consider it the best investment I have made.

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#2

Re: The benefits of lung protection

Don Evans

I'd be interested in knowing what dust collector you are using? I agree 100 percent on keeping dust controlled but with the face mask doing the work, I also wonder what you are breathing when you remove it. I'm an advocate for cyclone dust collectors and they being the only ones available at this time that do the job good enough. I base this on the fact that my shop (heated and AC) never has dust on shelving and table tops etc. It stays clean as or more so than the house!

If you are using a bagged collector I feel they are not only NOT doing the job but are dangerous in the fact that they make many feel safe when they are not.

Do you wear the mask all the time you're in the shop?

Don

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#3

Re: The benefits of lung protection

Bill Howatt

I consider the lathe one of the worst devices to collect dust from because it is difficult or very inconvenient to place the collector right where the dust is being generated all the time especially with larger pieces. I also think it gets trapped in the spinning air around the piece so it gets ejected at any point around the circumference.

I always wear a minimum of N95 dust mask when doing any stage of turning and the filters do show they are catching dust.

I have a dedicated 1HP DC for the lathe but it doesn't pull enough air to do a great job of collecting - I think you need something that would require you to be tied to the wall so you don't get sucked into it to capture all the dust from a lathe.

Bill

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#4

Not only lungs are in danger...

Molly Winton

Here's my public service announcement.

Tuesday I go in for sinus surgery. Apparently I have what looks like a fungal infection in my deep sinus cavities (middle of head). My ENT says there's a good chance it developed as a result of my woodworking. It is complicated by a deviated septum, but that is secondary to the reason for the surgery. They have to go in and remove the infection, inflamed tissue, etc. I've had symptoms for 2-3 years, so it's been there for some time. It also may be the cause of four points of brain inflamation detected by the MRI. We'll be keeping an eye on that over the next couple months too.

My ENT says the highest rate of sinus cancer when comparing woodworkers, metalworkers, and others exposed to various airbourne particulates is woodworkers, because the particulates are organic, rather than inert. Organic material brings in bacterial concerns, while inert particulates just sit there. Think about when you get a sliver, and how soon it becomes irritated and begins to fester, and then apply that to your sinuses and resperitory tracts.

Not pretty folks. Take care of yourselves!

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#5

Re: Not only lungs are in danger...

GaryG in MD

Thanks for the warning, Molly.

We all need to think about what we're breathing.

I'm going to start wearing my mask a lot more!

Hope your procedure goes well -- definitely not fun. ...Gary

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#6

Mike Stafford

Re: Not only lungs are in danger...

Mike Stafford

I'll be praying for the best outcome Molly. Take care.....

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#7

Re: Not only lungs are in danger...

Steve Criscenzo

Molly

I have heard of such infections in the lungs but not in the sinus. Thanks for sharing the warning. Would you mind sharing the symptoms that made you suspect the infection.

I hope all turns out well with the surgery. You will be in our thoughts.

Steve

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#8

Re: Not only lungs are in danger...

Molly Winton

My symptoms first appeared when I'd get a cold or respiratory infection or virus. When I'd cough I would get excruciating pressure headaches across my forehead. They'd last for about 10-20 seconds, and then when the pressure abated, the headache would disappear. Eventually the headaches would last longer and take less pressure to be instigated. Sneezing, laughing, and sometimes strenuous exercise would bring the headache on.

Because of the inflamation and exaserbated by my deviated septum, the sinus cavities couldn't drain, nor could the infection clear up, hence the need for a surgical remedy.

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#9

Re: Not only lungs are in danger...

Nick Tuzzolino

Molly:

Thanks for sharing all this personal info with us. You just made a believer out of a skeptic. Many Thanks. I hope you will alleviate your present problems. My thoughts are with you.

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#10

Re: Not only lungs are in danger...

Harry R obinette

Molly I'm a believer I have COPD now I did smoke for allot of years BUT the Doc said it's mainly from wood dust and we all know the Doc's like to blame everything on smoking so. I'm using a 1200 cfm DC with two 4" flex ducts that can be positioned right were I wont them.I also wear a positive pressure face shield and I'm doing pretty good so the Doc says.

My prays are with you.

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#11

Re: Not only lungs are in danger...

Bernie Weishapl

I get bronchitis if I don't wear my Airstream. I have a 1200 cfm DC and a air cleaner that runs for 2 hrs after I leave the shop. If I sand, saw, bandsaw, plane, joint, or use a router I use the Airstream. I also have to be extremely careful when using rattle can spray finishes. I don't have windows so either have to use wipe on finishes, water based finishes, etc. in the winter.

Molly hope everything goes well for you and thanks for sharing.

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#12

Re: The benefits of lung protection

Steve Criscenzo

Don

I have a 2hp bag dust collector with the best bags I could find (I think they claim to be < 1 micron.) I have a shop made cyclone type sperator attached to it so only the fines go into the bags. I also run a shop made air cleaner with a hepa grade filter.

I do not have much dust accumulation around the shop so I think I am doing OK with ambient air. I wear my Airstream any time I am tunring or sanding. As others have said, it is hard to capture the fine dust when sanding at the lathe. Given the fact that I run a DC and air cleaner, I surprised at the quantity of fine dust in the filter of the Airstream.

I realize that the Airstream moves a relativly large volune of air compared to what you breathe so the amount of dust in the filter is greater than what might be inhaled, none the less, it was still alarming to me.

Steve

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Not only lungs are in danger...

Keith Tompkins

Hi Molly, Good luck with the surgery! I wonder about the health hazards of spalted wood... some say it's harmless, but who knows? I once let a toothache go unattended...I was young, and broke. What started as a small infection spread into my sinuses, then my right eye socket. The doctor who did the surgery told me if I had waited any longer....well, you know. I'm sorry to hear of your troubles, get well soon!

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#14

Thank you for all the good thoughts!


Re: The benefits of lung protection

#15

BarbS

Re: Not only lungs are in danger...

BarbS

Oh wow, Molly, so sorry for your troubles. And I'd never heard about this; thank you for the warning and I'll start taking better care of myself. I've been ignoring this far too many times. God bless.

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#16

Re: Not only lungs are in danger...

Carol

That did it! I am now seriously shopping for a positive air system.

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#17

Re: Thank you for all the good thoughts!

Roger Chandler

A most excellent thread with very important information. I almost died in 2006 with a serious lung infection that caused [thankfully] temporary heart problems as well..........after a month in the hospital and some of that in ICU, I make sure I take precautions when turning.

I have a DC with 1200 cfm and 1 micron bags, a vortex separator and an overhead air cleaner............about 18 months ago, I purchased a Trend Airshield pro, and I think I have dust collection nearly as good as I can make it in my shop, yet I still don't like the smell of dust that I get at times.

Our best wishes and prayers are with you Molly..........thanks for sharing all this.....it may just help someone avoid an avoidable sickness!

Re: The benefits of lung protection

#18

Re: Not only lungs are in danger...

Mike Foster

Wow Molly, sorry to hear that. Sounds like the surgery can only improve things with symptoms like that. Hope all goes well for you tomorrow.

I wonder about the link to woodworking. If the etiology was fungal infections, I don't see the connection to woodworking. Perhaps (but still a stretch) if you did a lot of work with spalted wood, but my sense is that was not a focus of yours. I did hear of a turner that had some serious lung issues that were blamed on his turning a lot of spalted wood. Microorganisms that eat wood rarely dine on humans, but there could be some link. What do I know?

Again, best wishes tomorrow,

Mike