Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Follow up to GaryG's "Get by with a little help ."

Posts

Follow up to GaryG's "Get by with a little help ."

#1

Follow up to GaryG's "Get by with a little help ."

charlie belden

In an earlier thread, GaryG asked for suggestions on how to finish a hollow form he'd left with a wide flat rim around the small opening through which he'd done the hollowing. Taking the suggestion to ditch the wide flat rim and to thin the walls around the rim opening down, he was able to get a pretty nice little piece out of the dry piece of box elder branch a neighbor gave him.(see thread "with a little help from my friends".

Here's the Before and After versions of the piece, followed by a critique and a suggestion for others who find themself with the same dilema.



Re: Follow up to GaryG's "Get by with a little help ."

#2

Charlie,

GaryG in MD

Your points are well taken for instructional purposes, but, just for the record, I didn't lower the top when I adjusted the opening. In my case, your red line should be the same as the black except at the outer edge of the thick rim band. I removed material from around the outside of the fat lip, maintaining the slight upward curve there, and then angled the inside of the remaining lip downward. The latter operation made the opening just a hair larger in diameter, but nothing of any significance. It went from 15/16 to a hair under 1" -- not a big deal. Thanks for your interest, Gary

Re: Follow up to GaryG's "Get by with a little help ."

#3

BarbS

Thanks, Charlie. Very useful.


Re: Follow up to GaryG's "Get by with a little help ."

#4

Gary, et. al.

charlie belden

Attached is a corrected version of the earlier illustration of Before, After & Suggestion.


I posted this stuff in the hope that another turner, faced with the situation you found yourself in, and one I've often encountered, would start the correction lower down on the piece in order to have more room to blend the two new curves on the upper part of the piece together and the lower new curve into the existing bottom curve. This will create a continuous upward flowing profile rather than an UP, UP, HORIZONTAL and then UP some more.

For me, the problem was getting the outside more or less the way I wanted it - except for the rim width, do all the hollowing except around the neck to the final thickness - then have no wood lower down on the piece to begin the blending.

For me at least,strarting woth the the hollowing hole, then getting the outside profile where I like it - THEN do the hollowing - works best for me.

And when I jump back and forth between changing the profile and hollowing - the result is often "unsatisfactory" - and a compromise that could have been avoided - and a better piece being the result.

Re: Follow up to GaryG's "Get by with a little help ."

#5

Re: Gary, et. al.

GaryG in MD

Charlie,

I certainly agree that one should plan the design of the rim in advance (now I know how to do that!). I also agree that changing a curve at one end often necessitates a complete revision of the entire curve. This is as true for a bowl as it is for a hollow form. There's no question that the outside shape should be completed to your satisfaction before beginning hollowing. (One potential problem here is if you have trouble flattening the center nib at the inside bottom as you complete the hollowing and are OC enough to keep worrying it, plus and minus, until it's flat, but the inside bottom is now a bit deeper into the chuck tenon than the original plan for the shape and location of the outside of the bottom. DAMHIK! That happened on this piece too! I was lucky to have just enough material to get away with it, but the rings on the foot aren't very deep!)

Completing the neck area before hollowing may be nice from a design point of view, but it can be a problem because of the inevitable little bumps that one gets there while hollowing. Leaving it a bit fat and heavy and completing it after hollowing can be a safer bet from a practical point of view.

But the solution for fixing the neck rim width in my case did not involve reshaping or recurving -- just removing a bit of the unwanted material, per below: ...Gary