Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

Posts

Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

steven antonucci

Having spent my yesterday with Michael Hosaluk (recommend it if you get the chance!), I watched him cover a myriad of topics and projects. Drinking from a firehose...

So this morning over coffee, I ask the question:

When you attend a demonstration, which type do you prefer?

Choice #1: The topic is fairly narrow, but deep- such as the steps to turn a hollowform.

Choice #2: The topics are many and varied- such as Nick Cook and Michael, making a dozen or more things throughout the day, and exposing ideas quickly but in very little detail?

I have 2 demos coming up in June in Virgina, and one of each is scheduled at this writing, so I am doing some "market research" :)

Steve

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#2

Dick Hines

Re: Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

Dick Hines

And where will you be in Va? Anywhere close to Richmond?

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#3

Dick Hines

Re: Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

Dick Hines

And where in Va will you be doing these demos? Anywhere near Richmond?

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#4

Re: Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

john lucas

Steve you usually have 2 different audiences. The advanced turners want ideas and advanced skills because they will use those on their own projects. The beginning turners need skill enhancement and projects they can build, step by step. Hard crowd to cater to.

What I usually do is have a step by step project and then add some new skills or tool techniques to that project that the advanced people can use. If it's an all day affair I can break them up. do a beginner project that still may show some advanced turning techniques. Then the next hour maybe do a more advanced skill project or do something like texturing that both parties can learn from.

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#5

Re: Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

Barry L Elder

Yes!

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#6

Re: Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

Don Orr

I like both types but go in knowing which is which usually. I can always get something out of any demo-beginner or otherwise. Watching another turner do things their way can give you ideas or methods you might not have seen or thought of before. Watching a specific technique broken down into managable bits can lead to inspiration.

Watching Ellsworth turn a bowl or hollow vessel is very different than seeing Jennifer Shirley show how she does her texture and pyrography work and the tools and materials involved. The first is very broad in scope while the latter is much more detail oriented and specific. Both are enjoyable and informative-and usually entertaining. I guess what I am trying to say is that beginner type, project oriented demos tend to be broader in scope and more advanced demos probably need to be more narrow in focus.

I would like to see many of your demos Steve. I'm sure I could get a lot out of them.

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#7

Re: Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

Jorge

I prefer in depth presentations, the ones that are very wide leave me "hungry", too much stuff does not feed me.

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#8

no. 2


Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#9

Re: Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

Bernie Weishapl

#2

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#10

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

Lyle Jamieson

My focus is on the process not the finished product. People that have seen my demos know I am not an entertainer (like Jimmy Clewes or Michael) but more in teaching mode. I can take all day to demo a bowl because I use the bowl format to talk about all the foundation elements for turning anything. If you understand tool control, grain issues, green wood handling, sharpening, vibration issues, tornout grain problems, etc, etc, you can go back to the shop and turn anything you want. The advanced turner will always find something in the mix to fine tune their process. I cover design elements and creativity too for the more advanced people. Lets face it not everybody is as immersed in turning as we are. The general audience spends little time in the shop and usually is turning just for the fun of it. In my opinion the more foundation elements you have under control the more fun you can have at the lathe no matter what you like to turn, pens or sculptures.

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#11

Re: Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

robo hippy

Some of both. As a turner who has a lot of experience, I do not need all the details as I can fill in the blanks pretty well. For beginners, this is where they need the detail. So, for general audiences, like a club, you have to be able to get ideas across simply. For a more experienced audience, like at the Symposium, you may not have to detail it so much. The hands on saw dust sessions allow you to do both. You give the outline, then go to the individuals and work with them at their level.

robo hippy

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#12

Steven Antonucci

Smith Mountain and Blue Ridge


Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#13

Jim Evans

Re: Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

Jim Evans

Of the demo's that I have attended Lacer, Clewes, Bosche, and Gary Sanders, I liked the one day of demo's and one day of hands on. Trent & Gary did demo only and I didn't get as much out of it as the double format.

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#14

Steven Antonucci

Seeing vs. learning

steven antonucci

In my experience, the two types of demos I normally get to attend are what I break into simple categories: seeing vs. learning.

In a "seeing demo", the audience is there to watch the process being worked at whatever pace the maker works. It is very voyeuristic, and the demos that come to mind are the likes of Clewes (fast square things whirring), Escoulen (impossibly thin trembleur), and the like. The audience is dragged along at a breakneck pace to watch the item being made, but they'll have to take notes and look up details in subsequent research to truly understand what they saw. If you are like me, you write down 10 things, try 3 of them, and learn one.

In a learning demo, the pace is much slower, and the goal is to impart depth. A good learning demo usually has lots of questions that take you out on tangential topics as the discussion meanders along. The audience usually interacts much more often with the presenter, who moderates and demonstrates/illustrates whatever the topic is.

I try to accomplish both in my demos, but I probably err towards the learning side. I personally enjoy demos that involve more ideas than hands on, as I am at a point in my life where I probably don't need to watch other people turn to enjoy a demo. I am a huge fan of interlacing personal stories into the demo to explain "how we got here" and I have to say that I appreciate slide shows far more than I used to.

That said, if you are around the Richmond area in June, I'll do my best to entertain and educate you at the same time, taking the opportunty to show you how the world's cheapest engineer-artist-father-woodturner-ADHD Type A does whatever it is that I do.

Steve

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#15

Re: Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

Dick Coers

I asked Cindy Drozda the question about demos and teaching when we brought her to Peoria. I get very frustrated trying to teach techniques since the students are too often "deer in the headlight" situations. I mean that I can stand there, one on one with them, tell them and show them what to do, and they go at it like I hadn't mentioned one thing to them. Anyway, Cindy explained it very well. She feels that her main objective is to inspire. Build a fire in the gut that makes the student WANT to practice and work at it. Anything learned after that is just a benefit to the student. So no matter how you demo, leave them with interest and inspiration. Personally, I only hope to learn one thing at any full day demos now. I much prefer to learn by experimentation. I spend hours doing Google image searches. I look at pottery of all sorts, woodturners portfolios, really any 3d art, then spend time in the shop with those inspirations. My favorite thing at any demo now is the finished work the turner brings along. That is where I get the inspiration. If I don't watch another minute of someone sneaking up on the perfect jamb chuck fit, it will be just fine.

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#16

Steven Antonucci

Exactly my feeling!

steven antonucci

I think that demos are something that are really a sliding scale. In the beginning, a new turner is more likely to treat a demo like a magic act than a lesson. I remember being amazed at watching ribbons of wood fly, and nowadays, I'd be the last guy fighting for a chair in that demo.

As you progress, you start to figure things out, and I think you are looking for more ideas and technique to experiment. When you get to critical mass (aka know how to do enough things well enough that you lose your fear of doing them wrong), you will probably start experimenting more often. Having the demo as a source for inspiration is a wonderful thing.

Finally, I think you reach a point where it's less about content and more about context. You care less about what they are doing and much moreso about why they are doing it.

Thanks for crystalizing my thoughts for me.

Steve

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#17

It depends

David Walser

Steve,

Unfortunately, the answer to your question is, "It depends." If I'm really into a topic, the more depth the better. If I'm not (when I cannot picture myself turning a similar item), I'm more than willing to settle for just the general concept.

With "it depends" in mind, here are two tips for an effective demo:

1) Don't forget the salt. Whether it's a simple project or a complex one, be sure to mention every step of the process. My mother's famous in our extended family for sharing recipes that omit the salt. Her excuse is that everyone knows to add salt to their cake batter. Judging from the murmurings of the rest of my female relations, evidently not everyone will know how much salt to add if salt's not mentioned in the recipe. Not every turner will understand how you got from 'a' to 'e', unless you mention steps 'b', 'c', and 'd'. Even if you're not going to demonstrate a particular step, mention it. And, of course, if a particular step requires an unusual chucking method, be prepared to describe that chucking method in detail.

2) Why is as important as How. Sometimes it's more important. For most of the things we do, there are several options for accomplishing the same task. It's helpful to hear why you prefer a particular method. Sometimes it's an aesthetic reason, other times it's a practical concern, and still other times, it's merely force of habit. For example, years a go, I heard Lyle explain why he preferred using a glue block to a chuck when turning a bowl. (Wished I'd heard that before I'd spent so much money on chucks!) His explanation of why he used a glue block was more beneficial than his explanation of how he used one. The explanation of why something is done allows the student to adapt that method to another type of project. Certainly, explanation of a technique is important, but knowledge of the why makes knowledge of the how more portable.

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#18

Dunno About the Salt, But I Agree..


Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#19

Re: Question of the Day:  Depth or breadth?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Attending a year of CMW's demos is almost equivalent to what can be crammed into a visit to a national symposium. I do not carve or do much surface enhancement. I usually avoid our meetings that concentrate on such. I love detailed demos on what my wife and I do. Sometimes a fifteen second tip is all that is new.

Demonstrators need to come prepared with ROUNDED wood. Who wants to see a block turned round? They need to have several prepped pieces in various stages of the project incase they blow something up. We usually have hands-on classes on Sundays and some Mondays after the demos. Attending these classes really locks the new concepts.

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#20

I believe a live demo without a follow-up....

JamieDonaldson

...hands-on day with demonstrator doesn't fully utilize the expense of the demo to the members. When facilities allow, I always encourage clubs to schedule hands-on days when I travel, and do make a significant reduction in my day rate. This allows a club to recoup some of the demo expenses by charging members a nominal fee for a day of individual instruction.

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#21

Another voice on the subject....

Dick Coers

I sometimes read Seth Godin's blog. Here is a quote from him about creating art.

All artists are self-taught

Techniques and skill and even a point of view are often handed down, formally or not. It's easier to get started if you're taught, of course.

But art, the new, the ability to connect the dots and to make an impact--sooner or later, that can only come from one who creates, not from a teacher and not from a book.

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#22

Re: It depends

charlie belden

Ah - the Do You Assume Everyone Knows THAT Omission vs Sit There And Watch Me Turn A Hat - For Three And A Half Hours question.

The solution seems to be provide good step by step handouts, with room in the margins for folks to add their own notes - then do three or four different pieces that use different techniques or use the wood with different grain orientations - each taking under an hour and a half - including time for questions. This way the demo attendees get both - breadth AND depth - and some tips. Of course this requires a lot more prep time - the first time. After that, minor revisions or additions are fairly easy to do.

And it's always good to get feedback - anonymously. Passing out FeedBack cards - before the demo starts and leaving a little time at the end for them to be filled out and picked up is a good idea. If you have a website - preferably with an online feedback form - include that on the feedback card.

ALWAYS encourage attendees to ask questions if they don't understand anything during the demom whether you're being paid to do the demo or not. Your goal IS NOT to show off - but to TEACH - to convey what another turner needs to know - and understand - in order to be able to do what you're demonstrating / teaching.

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#23

Steven Antonucci

Disagree on two items

steven antonucci

1.) I will never bring a handout. Ever. Personally, I find them a waste of paper, even if they are the best written bit of material ever. I will make myself available for Q&A, but to produce 60 handouts to hope that I catch the one guy who would actually use... just not going to happen. Ever.

In fact, I gave away my AAW Symposium handbook as fast as I could find someone to take it. But that's me.

2.) I think I start with the premise that it might be OK to not teach, but merely provide an opportunity to watch someone work. Teaching is noble, but I think half of the audience is there for a good show. Entertainers make more than teachers, right?

And 3.5 hours to turn a cowboy hat... ugh. Even I don't have enough jokes to cover 3.5 hours...

Steve

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#24

Re: Disagree on two items

charlie belden

Steve:

It is possible to be entertaining while teaching. Several of my high school teacher and several more of my college profs did both - and I learned most from them.

Jimmy Clewes is one of the Masters of Both.

In our turning club, within a month or two of a demo by a pro, people start bringing their versions to our club's monthly meeting - for show and tell. So in our club at least, what's taught in a demo gets used by about a quarter of our members in the next six months.

As for "handouts", you can put them on line - as many demonstrators have done. You provide the url and interested parties can download and print them if they want them. No paper to carry, no printing cost , no time spent handing out the handouts - the wonders of the internet.

ON THE OTHER HAND - there are demonstrators who are demonstrating stuff that is pretty unfamiiar to most turners, especially Round & Brown turners. Barbara Dill's multi axes explorationm and the structured approach to the subject she's developed and keeps refining REALLY needs illustrated handouts in order to grasp the concepts. It's one thing to see it done and listen to a word description. At the time it seems to make sense. Then you go home and try to apply what you THINK you learned - and then realize that you probably missed something important - and she's gone and you're stuck.

Re: Question of the Day: Depth or breadth?

#25

Re: Handouts

David Walser

Steve,

I hear you on handouts. You dislike them and I know others share that feeling. Your view might be in the majority. It might be a minority view. I don't know. I do know that a significant proportion of turners appreciate good handouts. Having helped (in a very small way) put on regional symposiums, I can tell you that a lack of or poor quality of the handouts will almost always draw complaints from attendees. We each learn in different styles. For you, a handout is a distraction -- so you ignore it while watching the demo. Others cannot comprehend the demo unless they're able to follow along with the handout.

Keep these different learning styles in mind when planning your demo. You'll miss the mark (by a small amount?) with a large portion of your audience if you don't provide good handouts. You may still get rave reviews, but some portion of the audience will leave saying, "That was great! It would have been even better, if...." Your call.

One nice thing about a good handout, it all-but makes sure you "don't forget the salt". (See my prior post.) You can say, "I've outlined 12 steps to make my crush pepper-mill design. In today's demo, we're going to spend most of our time on steps 4 and 5, shaping the body and the top of the grinder. It's in steps 4 and 5 where you can express yourself in the design of the pepper mill, so that's what we'll be talking about today. The other steps are just as critical to getting a well-functioning pepper mill. Those steps are discussed in your handout and I'll just mention them briefly in today's demo."

If you should choose to provide handouts, there's no need for you to schlep them to the demo. The club should be willing to print copies of your handouts if you'll email them the document a week or so before the demo.