I went to the Flea mkt this morning and was looking through a tool vendor and found these wonderful turning tools. I paid $1.50 for each one. These were probably state of the art amateur tools in 1950. They will still work today of course and frankly aren't much different than the current crop of scraping tools other than not being carbide. That's not a knock on scraping tools. Read Richard Raffin's article in the latest AAW journal.
If you look close you'll notice that it did include one modern tools with replaceable HSS cutter. Also there is a double ended HSS planer blade tool.
I think you can FILE this one under "Tools, repurposed" and be fairly accurate.....
There are all kinds of ground-down files that appear on eBay very often that are sold as "antique turning tools"...... .... I'm not sure I would buy any of them, other than as curiosities. Just be careful about the brittleness of the files and the possibility of non-visible cracks in the metal. I have heard (urban legends?) about scrapers made from files snapping-off in use when hitting knots and other dense woods.
I guess you used what you could "back in the day"......
Reading Richard's article on scrapers made me gush a bit, and I normally don't do that. Scrapers, the forgotten tool. Most interesting thing to me was that his box scrapers look more like my bowl scrapers, and his bowl scrapers look more like some of my shear scrapers.
Rob I did a lot of research and experimentation before I did the article on tool making for American Woodturner. I broke files, heat treated them, bent them etc. The fun part was putting the files in vise and hitting them with a hammer. I think that is much more severe than hitting a knot.
Thick files like these are very unlikely to break although it would be easy to chip the edge. That's why I heat them to 325 degrees and let them cool before I use them. It softens the metal just enough to take out the brittleness. It could still break at the stamped file lines but in my testing it doesn't shatter.
I think those of us who started turning before the advent of the bowl gouge are more likely to think of scrapers as being a valid and efficient tool. I think I used scrapers almost exclusively for the first 15 years I turned and still like them better for some instances.
Hey! (very big grin) you have my tools I started with. Yes some of them where made from files and yes a couple of them did break. But that's all I had back then.